Skip to content

Saturday, 21 November 2026 · New Delhi

Economy

Who Pays for the State? Direct vs Indirect Taxes and the GST Story

CBDT vs CBIC, the 101st Amendment, the GST Council's 5%-18% Next-Gen overhaul, India's tax system decoded for Prelims and Mains.

By Harsh28 September 2026Updated 20 November 202630 min readintermediate
Who Pays for the State? Direct vs Indirect Taxes and the GST Story | UPSC

Every rupee the government spends, on roads, salaries, subsidies, or interest, is first collected, and how it is collected shapes the economy as much as how it is spent. India's tax system runs on a deceptively simple divide: taxes you pay directly versus taxes hidden in the price of what you buy. This article works through that divide, the constitutional machinery behind it, and the biggest tax reform since Independence, the Goods and Services Tax, now in its "2.0" avatar.

Direct versus indirect: the master distinction

11.2%Tax-to-GDP, Centre alone17-18%Tax-to-GDP, Centre plus statesabout 34% in OECD economiesRs 22.08L crRecord GST, FY25up from about Rs 10L cr in FY18Rs 27L crGross direct tax, FY25Rs 22L cr net after refunds5%, 18%GST main slabs2025 reform; 40% for sin and luxury17 + 13Taxes and cesses subsumedby GST in 2017
Taxing lightly by rich-country standards: tax-to-GDP ratios, GST slabs and record collections.

The entire tax chapter of the prelims rests on one test: can the person who pays the tax shift its burden to someone else? If impact (who the tax is levied on) and incidence (who finally bears it) fall on the same person, it is direct; if the burden travels, typically into the price of goods and services, it is indirect. Nearly every classification question is a variation on this.

Direct taxes

  • Levied on income, wealth or profits; burden cannot be shifted to others.
  • Generally progressive, higher income, higher rate; administered by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) under the Department of Revenue.
  • Examples: personal income tax, corporate tax, capital gains tax, Securities Transaction Tax.

Indirect taxes

  • Levied on goods and services; burden is passed on to the final consumer.
  • Often regressive in effect, the same rate bites harder on low incomes; administered by the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC).
  • Examples: GST, customs duty, excise on petroleum and alcohol (still outside GST).

Basis

Direct taxes

Indirect taxes

Levied on

Income, wealth or profits

Goods and services

Burden

Cannot be shifted to others

Passed on to the final consumer

Impact and incidence

Fall on the same person

Burden travels, typically into the price of goods and services

Character

Generally progressive: higher income, higher rate

Often regressive in effect: the same rate bites harder on low incomes

Administered by

Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT), under the Department of Revenue

Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC)

Examples

Personal income tax, corporate tax, capital gains tax, Securities Transaction Tax

GST, customs duty, excise on petroleum and alcohol (still outside GST)

The direct-tax toolkit

Income tax, charged under the Income-tax Act, 1961 (a law first introduced in 1860 by James Wilson and consolidated in 1922), is India's progressive workhorse, with a new concessional regime made the default option from Budget 2024-25. Corporate tax is levied on company profits at 22% without exemptions (about 25.17% effective including surcharge and cess) following the landmark 2019 rate cut that aligned India with Asian peers.

The supporting cast matters for prelims: capital gains tax on profit from selling capital assets (the 2018 Budget reintroduced long-term capital gains tax on equities and scrapped dividend distribution tax, asked in that year's mains); Securities Transaction Tax on trades executed on recognised stock exchanges; Minimum Alternate Tax ensuring profitable companies pay at least some tax; and the Equalisation Levy, 6% on online advertisement services (Finance Act, 2016) and 2% on e-commerce supply (Finance Act, 2020), whose provisions ceased to apply from 1 April 2025.

Two exemption traps UPSC loves: agricultural income is fully exempt under Section 10(1), and rural agricultural land is not even treated as a capital asset, but income from allied activities such as poultry farming or wool rearing is not agricultural income and stays taxable. Methods of taxation round out the theory: proportional (flat), progressive (income tax), regressive (uniform levies that burden the poor more), and degressive (rate rises then flattens).

The constitutional scaffolding

Tax powers flow from the Seventh Schedule: the Union taxes income, customs and excise; states tax land, alcohol and (earlier) sales. GST required rebuilding this wall, the 101st Constitutional Amendment (2016) inserted Article 246A (concurrent power for Parliament and states to make GST laws, with Parliament exclusive on inter-state trade), Article 269A (IGST on inter-state supply collected by the Centre and apportioned to states), and Article 279A (the GST Council). Getting these three article numbers exactly right is one of the highest-yield memorisation tasks in economy.

GST: one nation, one tax, almost

2016101st AmendmentArticles 246A, 269A and 279A enable the dual GST1 Jul 2017GST launchedDestination-based tax; Input Tax Credit kills tax-on-tax2017Compensation promiseStates guaranteed 14% annual revenue growth for five years2022Mohit Minerals verdictGST Council recommendations are persuasive, not bindingSep 2025Next-Gen GST56th Council: two main slabs of 5% and 18%; 40% for sin goods
From the 101st Amendment to Next-Gen GST in 2025: the making of one nation, one tax.

Launched on 1 July 2017, GST is a comprehensive, multi-stage, destination-based tax levied on the supply of goods and services at every stage of value addition. Its core design win is the Input Tax Credit (ITC): tax paid on inputs is set off against tax on output, killing the old cascading "tax on tax". A trader in Maharashtra selling to a buyer in Gujarat pays CGST + SGST on intra-state sales and IGST on inter-state sales, with the Centre sharing IGST revenue with the consuming state.

Manufacturerpays tax on inputs,claims input tax creditITCWholesalerpays tax on sales,sets off input taxITCRetailerpays tax on sales,sets off input taxITCConsumerbears the final tax;no credit to claimDESTINATION-BASEDThe tax follows the goods to the consuming state. A trader in Maharashtra sellingto a buyer in Gujarat pays CGST plus SGST on intra-state sales and IGST on inter-statesales, with the IGST revenue shared with the consuming state.
GST is a comprehensive, multi-stage, destination-based tax levied at every stage of value addition. The Input Tax Credit sets the tax paid on inputs off against the tax on output, killing the old cascading “tax on tax”.

The payoff, per official data: gross collections rose from about ₹10 lakh crore in FY18 to a record ₹22.08 lakh crore in FY25, monthly averages now exceed ₹1.70 lakh crore, e-way bills grew ~21% year-on-year, and 17 central and state taxes plus 13 cesses were subsumed. The GST Compensation Act, 2017 guaranteed states 14% annual revenue growth for five years, the rationale and the COVID-era compensation-fund stress became a full 15-mark mains question in 2020.

GST collections more than doubledBar chart of gross GST collections: about 10 lakh crore rupees in FY18, a record 22.08 lakh crore rupees in FY25.GST collections more than doubledGross collections, ₹ lakh crore06.813.520.327₹ lakh cr1022.08Gross GST collectionsFY18FY25
From about ₹10 lakh crore in FY18 to a record ₹22.08 lakh crore in FY25, with monthly averages now above ₹1.70 lakh crore. Source: Official GST collection data, as cited in the article.

The GST Council, Union Finance Minister as chair, all states and UTs as members, with the Centre holding one-third weight and states two-thirds, decisions by three-fourths majority, is the apex rate-setting body. But note the constitutional subtlety the Supreme Court established in Mohit Minerals (2022): Council recommendations are recommendatory, not binding, cooperative federalism by persuasion, a favourite mains angle on fiscal federalism.

GST 2.0: the 2025 slab rationalisation

GST 2.0: the slab rationalisationBefore: the clutter5%12%18%28%plus compensation cessAfter: two main slabs5% (merit)18% (standard)12% and 28% removed40% for sin and luxuryGross collections: about Rs 10 lakh crore in FY18to a record Rs 22.08 lakh crore in FY25;monthly averages now exceed Rs 1.70 lakh crore.
Next-Gen GST, approved by the 56th GST Council in September 2025: the 12 percent and 28 percent slabs were removed, leaving two main slabs of 5 percent and 18 percent, with a 40 percent slab for sin and demerit goods.

In September 2025 the 56th GST Council approved "Next-Gen GST" reforms, the biggest structural change since launch. The cluttered multi-slab structure was streamlined into two main slabs of 5% and 18% (the 12% and 28% slabs removed), with a 40% slab retained for luxury and sin goods such as pan masala, tobacco, aerated drinks and high-end cars. The compensation cess was folded into the new structure, insurance and essential medicines got relief, and process reforms promised simpler registration, faster refunds and lower compliance costs, a direct response to the long-standing complaints about complexity, frequent rate changes, ITC mismatches and a still-patchy appellate tribunal (GSTAT).

What GST still doesn't cover is equally testable: petroleum products, electricity, real estate and alcohol for human consumption remain outside, leaving a large part of the economy under the old cascading regime, the standard "unfinished agenda" point for any GST answer.

The 57th Council: process reforms, October 2026

The rate rejig belonged to the 56th Council in September 2025. The reform process continued at the 57th meeting in October 2026, which turned from rates to process: registration, returns, refunds and input tax credit. The aim was the same in each case, fewer manual touchpoints, faster money back to businesses, and fewer disputes about what the law means.

Registration gets simpler at the edges. The registration application is being redesigned for clarity, with a friendlier portal, drop-down lists and contextual guidance for applicants and officers. Small sellers using e-commerce platforms get a simple PAN-based registration in states other than their home state, provided the input tax credit they pass on does not exceed Rs 2.5 lakh in a month, excluding stock transfers. For prelims, the Rs 2.5 lakh monthly threshold and the PAN basis are the recall facts.

Returns move toward self-correction. GSTR-1, GSTR-1A and the Invoice Furnishing Facility are being enhanced so that outward-supply statements reconcile better with GSTR-3B, and the Invoice Management System lets recipients accept, reject or keep supplier documents pending before credit is taken. The corrected liability and credit mechanism applies from the April 2027 return period.

Refunds become system-readable and largely automatic. The refund application in FORM GST RFD-01 will capture refund details in a machine-readable format for claims on zero-rated supplies and inverted-duty-structure refunds, and acknowledgement time falls from 15 days to 10, with deemed acknowledgement where no response comes. On risk assessment, 90% of the claimed amount is expected to be sanctioned for such claims, and acknowledged claims up to Rs 1,000 in total get automated sanction of the full amount without officer intervention. A cap that limited zero-rated refund turnover to 1.5 times the value of like goods supplied domestically is being removed, and refunds of input tax credit on capital goods will be spread over 60 months for claims arising on or after 1 April 2027.

Credit widens in three directions. Restrictions on blocked input tax credit are being eased, with taxpayers able to object to amounts blocked in their electronic credit ledger. Credit on demonstration vehicles is allowed in specified situations, and e-invoicing extends to domestic supplies received from unregistered persons where tax is payable under the reverse charge. Banks, financial institutions and NBFCs opting for the special input-tax-credit route get clarifications on how their credit claims are treated. For mains, the 57th Council is the compliance-cost story: the same tax, collected with less friction, less blocked working capital and fewer reasons to litigate.

Tax buoyancy versus elasticity: reading the revenue pulse

Tax buoyancy is the percentage change in tax revenue divided by the percentage change in GDP. It captures everything: GDP growth plus every policy change the government made (rate cuts, new slabs, better compliance). Tax elasticity is the same ratio with policy changes held constant, so it measures only the automatic response of revenue to growth. Buoyancy tells you what happened; elasticity tells you what the system would have done on its own.

A buoyancy below 1 is the red flag: tax revenue is growing slower than the economy, which means policy or compliance is leaking. When nominal GDP grows near 10.5% but net GST collections grow only about 7.1%, buoyancy has slipped below 1 and the Budget's revenue projections deserve scepticism. The Viksit Bharat path needs buoyancy in the 1.2 to 1.5 range, so that revenues outpace growth and fund the state's ambitions.

The headline number every tax answer needs is the tax-to-GDP ratio: roughly 11.2% for the Centre alone and 17 to 18% for Centre and states combined, against about 34% in OECD economies. India taxes lightly by rich-country standards; every debate about spending capacity starts here.

Why GST took so long: the second half of the 2013 question

UPSC GS-3 2013 asked why GST's introduction was delayed, and the answer is a federal-bargaining story. First, states feared revenue loss: surrendering their sales-tax autonomy meant trusting the Centre to make them whole. Second, the compensation mechanism itself had to be designed: the five-year guaranteed compensation (14% annual growth promised, funded by the compensation cess) was the price of consensus. Third, a constitutional amendment was needed to let Centre and states tax the same base simultaneously. Fourth, political consensus had to survive changes of government at both levels. GST arrived in 2017 only after all four locks opened.

GST's design details: dual, destination, and the fine print

Dual GST is the simultaneous levy of Central GST and State GST on the same transaction and the same base, with IGST (Integrated GST) on inter-state supplies collected by the Centre and shared with the destination state. GST is a destination-based tax: revenue accrues where goods are consumed, not where they are produced, which is why manufacturing states resisted it.

The compliance machinery has its own vocabulary: the composition scheme lets small taxpayers pay a flat low rate with minimal paperwork; the reverse charge mechanism makes the buyer, not the seller, liable for tax on specified supplies; HSN and SAC codes classify goods and services for rate application; place-of-supply rules decide which state gets the revenue; the inverted duty structure (inputs taxed higher than outputs) traps working capital in refunds; and anti-profiteering provisions require rate-cut benefits to be passed to consumers.

Input Tax Credit has limits, and they are exam favourites. Not every business expense earns credit: blocked credits under Section 17(5) of the CGST Act — motor vehicles, food and beverages, personal consumption and the like — cannot be claimed even when used for the business. And credit already taken must be reversed if the buyer does not pay the supplier within 180 days of the invoice, a rule that ties the credit to genuine payment rather than paper invoices.

GAAR and the Direct Tax Code push

GAAR (the General Anti-Avoidance Rules) is India's statutory weapon against aggressive tax avoidance: arrangements whose main purpose is a tax benefit, lacking commercial substance, can be recharacterised and taxed. It is India's domestic answer to the OECD-G20 BEPS (Base Erosion and Profit Shifting) project, which targets multinationals shifting profits to low-tax jurisdictions. Know the sequence: BEPS is the global framework, GAAR is the Indian statute.

The Direct Tax Code (DTC) is the long-pending rewrite of India's direct-tax law, meant to replace the Income-tax Act, 1961. The reform push now runs through incremental streamlining: fewer, cleaner brackets and reduced litigation, because India's direct-tax disputes are among the world's most backlogged. For mains, frame DTC as simplification for compliance and buoyancy: simpler law, wider base, steadier revenue.

Key-term glossary: the tax acronyms decoded

  • CGST (Central GST) is the Centre's component of dual GST on intra-state supplies; SGST (State GST) is the state's mirror component; IGST (Integrated GST) applies to inter-state supplies and imports, collected by the Centre and apportioned to the consuming state.
  • A cess is a tax earmarked for a specific purpose (the compensation cess funds state GST compensation); a surcharge is an additional levy on the tax itself, not earmarked, that goes to the divisible pool. Neither is shared with states the way basic taxes are.
  • E-way bills are the electronic permits required for inter-state movement of goods above the threshold value, giving the tax department a real-time view of goods in transit.
  • Fiscal federalism is the division of taxation and spending powers between the Union and the states; GST is its most ambitious experiment, pooling sovereignty through the GST Council.

Tax subsidies: the hidden half of the Budget

Tax subsidies are financial benefits delivered through the tax system rather than as cash: the government cuts the tax liability of individuals, businesses or sectors through exemptions, deductions, rebates or lower rates. They are the quiet twin of the expenditure subsidies in econ-10; together with tax expenditure (the revenue foregone, detailed in econ-08), they form the part of fiscal policy that never appears as a spending line.

Their objectives, with the source's examples:

  • Growth and investment: tax holidays for SEZs under Section 10AA to boost exports and industrial development.
  • Priority and vulnerable sectors: agricultural income exempt under Section 10(1); MSMEs below Rs 40 lakh turnover exempt from GST registration.
  • Savings and inclusion: deductions for health-insurance premiums that nudge households toward financial protection.
  • Welfare and inclusivity: GST exemptions on education, basic healthcare and unbranded food items.
  • Regional development: the North-East Industrial Development Scheme's tax incentives for businesses in the North-East.
  • Employment and skills: Startup India tax exemptions aimed at job creation.

The problems: revenue foregone shrinks the tax base, layered exemptions complicate compliance, and benefits often accrue to those who need them least. The reform grammar is the Kelkar Committee prescription: rationalise subsidies, give every subsidy a sunset clause (an expiry date after which it dies unless explicitly renewed), and report tax expenditure transparently so Parliament can see what the hidden half costs. That is the mains-ready line to close any subsidy question.

Angel tax: the tax that punished fundraising

Few tax provisions have been as feared by founders as angel tax, the nickname for Section 56(2)(viib) of the Income-tax Act, inserted by the Finance Act of 2012. It said: if a closely held company issues shares at a price above their fair market value, the excess premium received from resident investors is taxed as income from other sources. The intent was anti-abuse: shell companies were laundering money by issuing shares at absurd premiums to friendly entities.

The collateral damage fell on genuine startups. An early-stage company's valuation is a bet on the future, routinely far above any accountant's fair market value, so a legitimate funding round could trigger a tax bill on money meant for growth. Startups faced scrutiny, notices and locked-up capital. Relief came in layers: DPIIT-recognised startups were exempted from 2016, with the exemption widened in 2019, and the provision's reach was extended to non-resident investors in 2023. Then Budget 2024-25 abolished angel tax entirely, for all classes of investors, ending a twelve-year drag on early-stage funding and removing one of the most cited irritants in the Startup India story.

Windfall tax: taxing extraordinary profits

In July 2022 the government imposed a windfall tax on the energy sector: a Special Additional Excise Duty (SAED) on domestically produced crude oil and on the export of petrol, diesel and aviation turbine fuel. A windfall tax is a levy on profits that are extraordinary and unearned, arising from external circumstances rather than the firm's own effort.

The rationale was the Russia-Ukraine war: global crude prices spiked, and Indian refiners and producers earned record margins on exports while domestic consumers paid high pump prices. The state argued that these were rents from a geopolitical shock, not rewards for enterprise, and that a share should fund public spending. The duty was reviewed fortnightly and calibrated to global prices, then phased down as prices normalised, a design that made it a temporary, counter-cyclical instrument rather than a permanent tax. For mains, it is the textbook case of taxing economic rents: efficient in theory, but politically delicate, because investors read any windfall levy as a signal that extraordinary success may be taxed away.

What makes a tax system good: the canons, named

Before rates, the textbook tests. A tax, in the classic definition used in this literature, is a compulsory contribution from a person to the government towards the expenses incurred in the common interest of all, without reference to special benefits conferred. The tax system in India is mainly a three-tier system, divided between the Central government, the State governments and local government such as municipalities and panchayats. A good system is then judged against a stable checklist.

  • Fairness, achieved through vertical equity, which means those with greater ability to pay, usually measured by income or wealth, should pay more, and horizontal equity, under which individuals with similar income or circumstances pay similar amounts of tax.
  • Adequacy: the system must generate enough revenue to fund public services and meet the government's budgetary requirements without resorting to excessive public debt.
  • Simplicity and transparency and visibility: complexity raises compliance costs for taxpayers and administrative costs for the government, and opens room for evasion and avoidance; taxpayers should be able to understand how rates are set and how revenues are used.
  • Administrative efficiency: the cost of running the system is kept as low as possible without compromising its effectiveness and integrity.
  • Neutrality and economic growth: the system should not unduly influence economic decisions or distort market transactions.
  • Flexibility and responsiveness: it must adapt to changing economic circumstances and policy needs, so the government can respond to crises or shifts in public policy priorities.
  • Predictability and stability: taxpayers need certainty about rates and bases to plan their finances; frequent changes create uncertainty.
  • Protection of taxpayers' rights, including the right to privacy, the right to be informed, and the right to appeal and be heard.
  • Certainty of administration, delivered in the Indian case through fixed tax slabs, TDS and TCS systems, the Annual Information Statement and faceless assessment.

Tax receipts in the data: direct taxes at a glance

Tax collections have remained buoyant, with direct taxes and GST both growing, and the periods matter more than the adjectives. Net direct tax collections for FY2024-25 stood at ₹22.26 lakh crore, against ₹19.60 lakh crore in FY2023-24, a growth of 13.57%. Gross direct tax collections crossed ₹27 lakh crore in FY25 before refunds of about ₹4.76 lakh crore. Within that, Securities Transaction Tax collections rose sharply to about ₹53,296 crore in FY25. The drivers were higher personal income tax, corporation tax and STT receipts, on a widening base that still excludes most of the workforce: the honest conclusion is that direct taxes are rising within revenue, but the taxpayer net remains narrow relative to population.

Two relief landmarks define the current personal-income-tax era. Under the new tax regime, no income tax is payable up to ₹12 lakh of annual income, and the effective limit for salaried taxpayers is ₹12.75 lakh because of the standard deduction. The Income-tax Bill, 2025, which replaces the Income-tax Act of 1961 mainly to simplify language and remove redundant provisions, proposes commencement from 1 April 2026. Appeals administration tightened in parallel: the monetary threshold for filing departmental appeals was raised to ₹50 lakh before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, ₹1 crore before the High Court and ₹2 crore before the Supreme Court, reserving litigation for disputes that matter.

Vivad Se Vishwas: closing tax disputes without the courtroom

The Vivad Se Vishwas scheme is India's standing offer to convert pending direct-tax litigation into settlement: the taxpayer pays the disputed tax and receives a waiver of interest and penalty, in exchange for withdrawing from courts and tribunals. It targets disputes pending before the Supreme Court, High Courts, Income Tax Appellate Tribunals and Commissioners of Appeals, a backlog of roughly 4.83 lakh direct-tax cases at the time it was designed. Settlement arithmetic is time-graded: pay by the first deadline and interest and penalty are waived; pay in the extended window and an additional 10% on the tax amount applies; where the dispute is only over interest and penalty, 25% of that amount is payable by the first deadline, rising to 30% in the extension. Vivad Se Vishwas 2.0 was launched on 1 October 2024, with the filing window closing on 30 April 2025. The design principle mains answers reward: the state trades theoretical dues it may never collect for immediate revenue, litigation cost savings and a compliance culture in which the next dispute is also cheaper to settle.

Virtual digital assets: the 30 per cent flat rate and the 1 per cent TDS

The Finance Act created a dedicated regime for virtual digital assets, or VDAs, without declaring them legal tender. The definition in Section 2 of the Income-tax Act covers any information, code, number or token, not being Indian currency or foreign currency, generated through cryptographic means or otherwise, providing a digital representation of value exchanged with or without consideration, or functioning as a store of value or a unit of account, including investment schemes; the Central Government may notify inclusions or exclusions. Under Section 115BBH, income from the transfer of a VDA is taxed at a flat 30%. Under Section 194S, a 1% tax is deducted at source on payment for transfer of a VDA above a monetary threshold, so the trail exists even where the trade does not. The earlier policy backdrop matters for GS-3: the Subhash Chandra Garg Committee of 2019 had recommended a ban on private cryptocurrencies on concerns of volatility, instability, security risk and funding of illegal activity, and the Cryptocurrency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill, 2021 proposed banning private cryptocurrencies while issuing an official digital currency through the RBI. The regime that emerged instead was tax first, decide legality later.

The global floor: the two pillars and India's seat at the table

Base erosion and profit shifting, or BEPS, names the practice the global reform targets: tax strategies used by multinational enterprises to exploit gaps and mismatches in tax rules across jurisdictions, shifting profits to low-tax or no-tax locations where there is minimal economic activity. The OECD and G20 answer runs on two pillars. Pillar Two provides a minimum 15% tax on corporate profit, putting a floor under tax competition: if a company pays less in one country, its home government can top up the tax to the agreed minimum, eliminating the advantage of shifting profits to a tax haven. Pillar One reallocates 25% of the profits of the largest and most profitable multinationals above a set profit margin to the market jurisdictions where their users and customers are located.

India's position is structurally comfortable and occasionally vocal. The annual tax loss to India from corporate tax abuse is estimated at over US$10 billion, which is the domestic stake in a global floor. In September 2019 the government cut the corporation tax rate to 22% for companies that gave up all exemptions and incentives, offered 15% to new manufacturing firms, and the effective rate for Indian domestic companies, inclusive of surcharge and cess, works out to around 25.17%, comfortably above the 15% floor. The government has signalled openness to engaging in the global discussion while treating taxation as ultimately a sovereign function: India keeps a rate that the global minimum cannot undercut, and courts the investment that rate certainty attracts.

Tax treaties: DTAA, the shield against double taxation

A Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement is a treaty between two or more countries ensuring the same income is not taxed twice by two jurisdictions; India has signed comprehensive DTAAs with more than 90 countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, Japan, Germany and Singapore. Their purpose in mains answers is dual: relief from dual taxation for investors, and cooperation against evasion for the state.

Feature

What it does

Elimination of double taxation

Achieved either through the exemption method (income is taxed in one country and exempt in the other) or the tax credit method (income is taxed in both countries, but credit is given for tax paid in one)

Reduced tax rates

DTAAs prescribe lower rates on dividends, interest, royalties and other income than domestic law alone would

Prevention of fiscal evasion

Provisions for exchange of information between the tax authorities of the contracting states

Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP)

A dispute-resolution mechanism allowing the authorities of both states to resolve difficulties or doubts in interpreting or applying the treaty

Permanent establishment

The treaty concept that determines the threshold at which a company's profits become taxable in the host country

Residency

Criteria to determine the residency status of a taxpayer, which fixes where the primary tax liability lies

India has been renegotiating the network rather than merely expanding it. The India-Mauritius DTAA of 1983 was amended in 2016 to address evasion and treaty misuse; the India-Singapore treaty carries a Limitation of Benefits clause against treaty shopping; India joined the Multilateral Instrument in 2017 to import BEPS measures across its treaty network at one stroke; and the agreement with Switzerland deepens cooperation against black money. The Place of Effective Management test completes the residency architecture: introduced by the Finance Act, 2015 with effect from 1 April 2016, a foreign company is treated as tax resident in India, and its worldwide income taxable here, if the place where its key management and commercial decisions are actually made is in India.

GST in the data: annual and monthly, period by period

Financial year

Gross GST collections (₹ lakh crore)

Note

FY2017-18

7.41

Nine-month collection year, July 2017 to March 2018 (GST launched mid-year)

FY2023-24

20.18

Previous record year

FY2024-25

22.08

Up 9.4% year on year; works out to a monthly average of about ₹1.84 lakh crore

Month

Gross GST collections (₹ lakh crore)

Note

April 2026

2.42

All-time monthly record; up 18.7% year on year

May 2026

1.94

Highest-ever May collection; up 12.6% year on year

Source-period labels: FY2017-18 figure from the PIB Ministry of Finance release of 27 April 2018; FY2023-24 and FY2024-25 from the government's statement marking eight years of GST, 30 June 2025; monthly figures from PIB monthly GST press releases of April and May 2026. Economy numbers move fast enough that this table records when each figure belongs, not what collections are today.

Note the launch-year arithmetic: the often-quoted FY18 base of about ₹10 lakh crore is inconsistent with the official nine-month series above, which is why the FY25 multiple over the launch period is closer to three times than to two. For prelims, the testable claims are the design features; for mains, this table is the evidence line that GST broadened the base without raising headline rates.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between direct and indirect taxes?

The entire tax chapter rests on one test: can the person who pays the tax shift its burden to someone else? If impact (who the tax is levied on) and incidence (who finally bears it) fall on the same person, it is direct; if the burden travels — into the price of goods and services — it is indirect. Direct taxes include income tax and corporate tax; indirect taxes include GST, which hides in the price of what you buy.

How does GST work in India?

Launched on 1 July 2017, GST is a comprehensive, multi-stage, destination-based tax on the supply of goods and services. Its design win is the Input Tax Credit: tax paid on inputs is set off against tax on output, killing the cascading "tax on tax". A trader in Maharashtra selling to a buyer in Gujarat pays CGST + SGST on intra-state sales and IGST on inter-state sales, with the Centre sharing IGST revenue with the consuming state.

What are the GST slabs after the 2025 rationalisation?

In September 2025 the 56th GST Council approved "Next-Gen GST" reforms, the biggest structural change since launch. The cluttered multi-slab structure was streamlined into two main slabs of 5% and 18% (the 12% and 28% slabs removed), with a 40% slab retained for luxury and sin goods such as pan masala, tobacco, aerated drinks and high-end cars. The compensation cess was folded into the new structure.

Which constitutional provisions govern GST?

GST required rebuilding the Seventh Schedule's tax wall. The 101st Constitutional Amendment (2016) inserted Article 246A (concurrent power for Parliament and states to make GST laws, with Parliament exclusive on inter-state trade), Article 269A (IGST on inter-state supply collected by the Centre and apportioned to states), and Article 279A (the GST Council). Getting these three article numbers exactly right is one of the highest-yield memorisation tasks in economy.

Key Terms

  • Direct taxes
  • Indirect taxes
  • Income tax
  • Corporate tax
  • Capital gains tax
  • Securities Transaction Tax
  • Minimum Alternate Tax
  • 101st Constitutional Amendment
  • Destination-based taxation
  • Input Tax Credit (ITC)
  • IGST
  • GST Compensation Act, 2017
  • GST Council
  • GST rate slabs (5% and 18%)
  • Angel tax

Practice questions

0 of 6 answered · 0 correct

Q1Prelims practice

Consider the following statements:

1. Corporate tax is a direct tax administered under the Central Board of Direct Taxes.

2. GST is an indirect tax whose burden can be shifted to the final consumer.

Q2Prelims practice

With reference to the GST Council, consider the following statements:

1. It is a constitutional body under Article 279A, chaired by the Union Finance Minister with all states as members.

2. In the Mohit Minerals case (2022), the Supreme Court held that the Council's recommendations are binding on the states.

Q3Prelims practice

Consider the following statements:

1. Agricultural income is exempt from income tax under Section 10(1) of the Income-tax Act.

2. Rural agricultural land is not treated as a capital asset, so its sale attracts no capital gains tax.

Q4Prelims practice

Consider the following statements:

1. The 56th GST Council (September 2025) rationalised GST into two main slabs of 5% and 18%, with 40% on select luxury and sin goods.

2. The GST compensation cess was retained as a permanent feature of the tax structure.

Q5Prelims practice

Consider the following statements:

1. The 101st Constitutional Amendment inserted Articles 246A, 269A and 279A to enable the GST framework.

2. GST was launched on 1 July 2017 as a destination-based tax on the supply of goods and services.

Q6Prelims practice

With reference to the Input Tax Credit (ITC), consider the following statements:

1. It is a mechanism to avoid cascading of taxes.

2. ITC can be claimed on any business-related expense.

3. ITC must be reversed if the supplier is not paid within 180 days.

Mains Practice question

Q. Enumerate the indirect taxes which have been subsumed in the goods and services tax (GST) in India. Also, comment on the revenue implications of the GST introduced in India since July 2017. (UPSC GS-3, 2019 · 10 marks)

Framing hintList the subsumed levies in two columns, Centre (central excise, service tax, additional customs duties, surcharges) and states (VAT, octroi, entry tax, luxury tax, entertainment tax), then assess revenue: the ₹10 lakh crore → ₹22.08 lakh crore collection arc, compensation-fund mechanics and COVID stress, state-revenue anxieties, and the 2025 slab rationalisation as the latest revenue-shape decision. Conclude on the exclusions (petroleum, electricity) as the unfinished revenue base.

Wealth tax, abolished — and the tax-to-GDP ratio

  • Wealth Tax Act, 1957 — a 1% tax on net wealth above ₹30 lakh.
  • Abolished — by the Finance Act, 2015, effective 1 April 2016; it was replaced by a 2% surcharge on taxable income above ₹1 crore.
  • Direct tax-to-GDP ratio — 6.73% in FY 2024–25, a 24-year high, on net direct tax collections of ₹22.26 lakh crore.
  • Wanchoo Committee (1971) — on direct taxation; its report shaped the tax reforms of the 1970s.
EconomyTaxationGSTGS Paper 3explained

Asked in the mains

Previous-year questions from this topic

How UPSC has actually asked this topic — with the year and marks for each question.

  1. 202015 marks

    Explain the rationale behind the Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act of 2017. How has COVID-19 impacted the GST compensation fund and created new federal tensions?

  2. 201910 marks

    Enumerate the indirect taxes which have been subsumed in the goods and services tax (GST) in India. Also, comment on the revenue implications of the GST introduced in India since July 2017.

  3. 201310 marks

    Discuss the rationale for introducing the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India. Bring out critically the reasons for the delay in roll out for its regime.

Asked in the prelims

Previous-year MCQs from this topic

How UPSC has tested this topic in the prelims — pick an option to test yourself.

  1. 2025Prelims

    1.Consider the following statements: Statement I: In India, income from allied agricultural activities like poultry farming and wool rearing in rural areas is exempted from any tax. Statement II: In India, rural agricultural land is not considered a capital asset under the provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?

  2. 2024Prelims

    2.With reference to Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) rules in India, consider the following statements: 1. CSR rules specify that expenditures that benefit the company directly or its employees will not be considered as CSR activities. 2. CSR rules do not specify minimum spending on CSR activities. Which of the statements given above is/ are correct?

  3. 2018Prelims

    3.Consider the following items: 1. Cereal grains hulled 2. Chicken eggs cooked 3. Fish processed and canned 4. Newspapers containing advertising material Which of the above items is/are exempted under GST (Goods and Services Tax)?

  4. 2018Prelims

    4.With reference to India’s decision to levy an equalization tax of 6% on online advertisement services offered by non-resident entities, which of the following statements is/are correct? 1. It is introduced as a part of the Income Tax Act. 2. Non-resident entities that offer advertisement services in India can claim a tax credit in their home country under the “Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements”. Select the correct answer using the code given below :

Related articles

Continue your preparation with more on this topic.

Shipbuilding schemes: the Rs 44,700 crore bet on Indian yards | UPSCEconomyShipbuilding schemes: the Rs 44,700 crore bet on Indian yardsTwo schemes, Rs 44,700 crore, and a target of 4.5 million gross tonnage a year by 2047. How the Shipbuilding Financial Assistance Scheme and the Shipbuilding Development Scheme aim to turn India from a buyer of ships into a builder of them.MSME Sustainable (ZED) Certification: Zero Defect, Zero Effect | UPSCEconomyMSME Sustainable (ZED) Certification: Zero Defect, Zero EffectZero Defect, Zero Effect certification helps MSMEs raise quality, cut waste and win global buyers. Bronze, Silver and Gold levels, subsidies up to 80 percent, and 6.7 lakh certified units so far.Khadi and village industries: from tradition to enterprise | UPSCEconomyKhadi and village industries: from tradition to enterpriseSales hit a record Rs 1.87 lakh crore in 2025-26, employment reached 2.04 crore, and artisan pay nearly quadrupled. How KVIC, its schemes and women artisans turned a heritage craft into a rural enterprise engine.Saptadhara: the Seven Streams for a Developed India | UPSCEconomySaptadhara: the Seven Streams for a Developed IndiaSeven streams, one destination: manufacturing, farming, technology, connectivity, defence, green and blue economy, and soft power. The framework from the 80th Independence Day address, and the announcements that came with it.Startup India: Building the World's Third-Largest Startup Engine | UPSCEconomyStartup India: Building the World's Third-Largest Startup EngineStartup India (2016) is the government's flagship innovation mission: DPIIT recognition, the 80-IAC tax holiday, Fund of Funds, seed funding, credit guarantees, MAARG, BHASKAR and state startup policies. This article unpacks every instrument, the challenges, and why it matters for jobs.The Final Sheet: Master Revision for the Indian Economy | UPSCEconomyThe Final Sheet: Master Revision for the Indian EconomyThe last-week revision sheet: sector shares, the macro dashboard, thresholds, committees, mnemonics and PYQ trend analysis for the whole Indian Economy library.