Environment· Prelims · GS-III
Before the First Brick: EIA and PARIVESH
EIA is India's gatekeeper between development projects and the environment. This article explains the EIA process, the 2006 Notification, the PARIVESH portal, and the reforms reshaping green clearances.
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is a planning tool that predicts, evaluates, and seeks to mitigate the environmental consequences of a proposed project before that project is approved. In India it is the principal gatekeeper between development and environmental protection: no major mine, dam, highway, or factory can legally begin without passing through it. For UPSC, EIA is a recurring GS-3 theme because it sits exactly where growth collides with ecology, and where procedure decides outcomes.
What EIA is, and what it is not
EIA is a systematic process used to predict, evaluate, and mitigate the potential environmental, social, and economic impacts of a proposed project before its implementation. Its purpose is to integrate environmental considerations into decision-making so that development is sustainable rather than merely fast. Equally important is what an EIA is not: it does not by itself approve or reject a project. It produces the evidence and the safeguards on which the competent authority bases its decision to grant, modify, or refuse Environmental Clearance (EC).
The objectives of EIA explain why UPSC treats it as a governance instrument rather than a technical formality. It promotes sustainable project design by building environmental safeguards into planning; it ensures efficient resource utilisation during implementation; it screens out, at an early stage, projects likely to cause significant harm; it gives decision-makers comprehensive environmental data for transparent approvals; and it protects public health and safety by identifying hazards before construction begins.
The process is guided by a set of principles that are frequently examined. Participation means affected communities must have a real voice; transparency requires public access to information and decision criteria; accountability obliges decision-makers to justify their choices; credibility demands professional, impartial assessment with independent verification; and integration insists that social, economic, and environmental aspects be addressed together rather than in silos.
The legal spine: the EIA Notification, 2006
India introduced EIA in 1978 for river valley projects. It became statutory through the first EIA Notification in 1994, issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, and was consolidated into the EIA Notification, 2006, which remains the governing framework. The 2006 Notification created a decentralised structure: Category A projects are appraised centrally by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change through the Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC), while Category B projects are appraised by the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) advised by the State Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC).
Category | Who appraises | Full EIA study | Public hearing |
|---|---|---|---|
A | EAC at the Centre | Yes | Yes |
B1 | SEIAA / SEAC in the state | Yes | Yes |
B2 | SEIAA / SEAC in the state | No | No |
The Notification lists the project types that need clearance: mining, petroleum refineries, and petrochemical complexes above thresholds; thermal power plants above 25 MW and all nuclear projects; chemical, fertilizer, pesticide, cement, paper, and textile industries above thresholds; airports, national highways, river valley projects, ports, and coastal developments; and industrial estates, SEZs, and townships above defined area thresholds. A parallel list of exemptions covers defence and national-security projects, certain public infrastructure, linear projects meeting specified criteria, notified industrial estates, and pure research without production. In January 2025, industrial sheds, schools, and educational hostels up to 1,50,000 sq m were also exempted from EC, but the Supreme Court struck down that exemption in August 2025.
Seven steps from proposal to clearance
Every project that needs clearance walks the same seven steps. Learn them in order, because mains answers on EIA almost always expect the sequence.
Step | What happens |
|---|---|
1. Screening | Determines whether the project needs a full EIA (Category A or B1) or is exempt (B2), based on type, scale, and location sensitivity. |
2. Scoping | The EAC or SEAC fixes the Terms of Reference, defining which parameters to study and the boundary of the study area. |
3. Baseline data collection | At least one season of data on air, water, soil, noise, ecology, and the socio-economic profile, generally within a 10 km radius. |
4. EIA report and EMP | A NABET-accredited consultant prepares the EIA report and the Environmental Management Plan in the format prescribed by MoEFCC. |
5. Public consultation | A mandatory public hearing in the project area with 30 days' notice (Category A and B1 only; B2 is exempt), with objections to be addressed. |
6. Appraisal and EC | The EAC or SEAC reviews the report, the hearing minutes, and the responses, and the competent authority grants Environmental Clearance with conditions. |
7. Post-clearance compliance | Half-yearly compliance reports (June and December), public display of EC conditions, and continuous monitoring where mandated. |
Two steps deserve special attention. Scoping is where the appraisal committee decides what the study must cover, so a weak Terms of Reference produces a weak EIA no matter how good the consultant is. Public consultation is the only point where affected communities formally enter the process, which is why every dilution of the hearing, from shorter notice periods to wider exemptions, becomes politically and legally contested.
PARIVESH: the single-window portal
PARIVESH is a centralised, web-based platform launched in August 2018 to streamline four kinds of green clearance: Environment Clearance (EC), Forest Clearance (FC), Wildlife (WL) clearance, and Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) clearance. Its upgraded version, PARIVESH 2.0, was fully operationalised in 2024 and now automates the entire clearance lifecycle, from the application and Terms of Reference through public consultation and appraisal to the final decision.
The portal's key features are end-to-end digitisation, which replaces the old multi-window paper trail; GIS and Decision Support System integration, which automatically flags overlaps with forests, wildlife zones, and eco-sensitive areas and reduces manual error; real-time tracking and transparency, which lets applicants follow their proposal online with automated alerts; and, under the 2026 reform, auto-escalation, which forwards proposals stalled at the state level to the standing authority so that lapsed committees cannot freeze decisions indefinitely.
The impact is measurable: the average time for environmental clearance fell from 120 days to 57 days in 2025-26, well within the stipulated 105-day timeline. For industry this is a genuine ease-of-doing-business gain, and for regulators the digital trail improves accountability. But three concerns persist. First, speed versus scrutiny: faster clearances must not dilute appraisal quality, genuine consultation, or cumulative-impact assessment. Second, the digital divide: online-only processes disadvantage remote and tribal communities with limited connectivity. Third, data quality: automation is only as reliable as the baseline data fed into it, so weak inputs produce poor decisions faster.
The reform churn: 2020, 2026, and the exemption debate
The draft EIA Notification, 2020 proposed the most sweeping changes in a generation: cutting the public-hearing notice period from 30 to 20 days, widening exemptions for B1 and B2 and so-called strategic projects, allowing post-facto clearance for projects built without prior approval, and replacing six-monthly compliance reports with annual ones. It drew over 17 lakh public comments, and the Delhi High Court ordered it to be translated into regional languages on 30 June 2020. As of 2026 it remains stalled and unfinalised. One of its most controversial ideas, post-facto clearance, was separately struck down by the Supreme Court in Alembic Pharmaceuticals v. Rohit Prajapati (2020), which held ex post facto clearances 'unsustainable in law' and alien to environmental jurisprudence. The battle did not end there: in May 2025 the Court in Vanashakti v. Union of India struck down the March 2017 notification and the July 2021 office memorandum, declaring post-facto clearances impermissible 'in any form or manner', only for a 2:1 majority led by CJI B.R. Gavai to recall that judgment in review in November 2025 (Justice Ujjal Bhuyan dissenting), reopening the regularisation question for exceptional cases.
In a significant 2026 reform, the Environment Ministry on 13 July 2026 notified the Environment Impact Assessment (Establishment of State Environment Impact Assessment Authorities and Committees) Rules, 2026 (S.O. 3862(E) and 3863(E)), giving final shape to proposals first issued as a draft on 5 March 2026. The Rules create a Standing Authority on EIA (SAEIA) and a Standing Committee on Environment Impact Appraisal (SCEIA) to assume the functions of a non-functional SEIAA or SEAC, with delayed proposals automatically routed to them through PARIVESH. The stated logic is administrative continuity: the clearance desk should never be vacant because a state committee's tenure expired. Critics counter that the standing bodies are staffed largely ex officio, without the domain-expertise requirements that Appendix VI of the 2006 Notification prescribes for the EAC and SEAC.
Around the same time, three more developments matter. The Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Act, 2023, effective April 2024, converted first-offence violations of the EP Act, 1986 into administrative penalties of Rs. 10,000 to Rs. 15 lakh instead of criminal prosecution, reserving jail only for non-payment beyond 90 days. The Supreme Court struck down the 2020 and 2023 exemptions for ordinary-earth excavation in linear projects in Noble M. Paikada v. Union of India (21 March 2024); a clarificatory order of 15 May 2024 protected only projects whose work orders predated 21 March 2024. In a further rollback, the Court in August 2025 struck down clause 8 of the Environment Ministry's 29 January 2025 notification (challenged through a PIL by Vanashakti), which had exempted industrial sheds, schools, colleges, and hostels up to 1,50,000 sq m from prior environmental clearance; the Court held that projects above 20,000 sq m cannot escape the EIA Notification, 2006. And the National Green Tribunal has cancelled or suspended clearances where cumulative assessment was found inadequate, signalling that post-clearance compliance matters as much as the pre-clearance process.
When the process fails: the NGO record
The 2024 GS-3 paper asked what role environmental NGOs and activists play in influencing EIA outcomes, and the answer is written in four landmark interventions. The Narmada Bachao Andolan, led by Medha Patkar, challenged the inadequate displacement and ecological assessment of the Sardar Sarovar Dam, forcing reassessments and improved rehabilitation. Kalpavriksh exposed forest-clearance and consultation deficiencies in the POSCO steel project in Odisha, contributing to the 2010 revocation of its clearance and the project's eventual withdrawal. The Goa Foundation took iron-ore mining to the Supreme Court, winning a temporary mining ban and orders for fresh EIAs. Greenpeace India used independent scientific data to expose EIA deficiencies at Mundra Port and SEZ, prompting tighter controls. Together they show that where official appraisal is weak, litigation and independent science become the real regulators.
The systemic challenges behind these failures are well documented: weak post-clearance monitoring, with self-reported compliance rarely verified; poor report quality, with incomplete baseline data and generic Environmental Management Plans; tokenistic public participation, especially in remote and tribal areas; ignored cumulative impacts, because the project-by-project approach misses landscape-level effects; a conflict of interest built into proponent-funded EIAs; and dilution through exemptions, as a growing list of exempted categories shrinks the universe of projects under scrutiny.
The social twin: Social Impact Assessment
Social Impact Assessment (SIA) is a systematic process to identify, analyse, and manage the social consequences, both positive and negative, of a proposed development project on affected communities. It examines livelihoods, displacement, land use, cultural heritage, common resources, and vulnerable groups. The division of labour is simple: EIA assesses ecological impacts; SIA assesses the human and social dimension, and the two are complementary tools for sustainable development.
The legal anchor is the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (the LARR Act), which makes SIA mandatory for land acquisition, conducted in consultation with local bodies and gram sabhas. An independent multidisciplinary Expert Group appraises the SIA report and can recommend abandoning a project if social costs outweigh benefits. The Act requires the consent of 70% of affected families for PPP projects and 80% for private projects. In scheduled and forest areas, the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 and the Forest Rights Act, 2006 empower gram sabhas to give free, prior, and informed consent to land diversion.
SIA faces the same pathologies as EIA: assessments treated as a procedural formality, dilution through state amendments and urgency clauses, weak enforcement of Social Impact Management Plans, limited independence from project proponents, and the frequent exclusion of marginalised groups, especially women and the landless, from genuine consultation.
Beyond one project: Strategic Environmental Assessment
Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) is the assessment of environmental effects at the level of a policy, plan or programme, before individual projects under it are proposed. Where a project EIA asks whether one dam, mine or highway should proceed and how, SEA asks the earlier question: what pattern of dams, mines or highways should a basin, region or sector have at all. It matters because many of the failures blamed on project EIA, ignored cumulative impacts, no real alternatives and conflicts discovered too late, are locked in before any single project file is opened.
Dimension | Project EIA | Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) | Social Impact Assessment (SIA) |
|---|---|---|---|
What is assessed | One proposed project and its site | A policy, plan or programme across a region or sector | Effects of a project or acquisition on people and livelihoods |
When it acts | Before environmental clearance | Earlier, while options are still open | Before land acquisition and rehabilitation decisions |
Core question | Can this project be made acceptable here? | What development pattern should this region follow? | Who gains, who loses, and how will losses be made good? |
Indian anchor | EIA Notification, 2006 under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 | Recommended in reform debates; no standalone SEA law yet | LARR Act, 2013 for land acquisition |
India does not yet have a standalone SEA statute, so SEA enters through reform proposals for sector-wide and regional assessments, river-basin studies and carrying-capacity exercises rather than through one mandatory clearance. That gap is itself an exam point: strengthening EIA may require moving some decisions upstream, so that a project hearing is not forced to relitigate an entire regional development choice. Used well, SEA also improves project EIA, because terms of reference can draw on basin-level baseline data instead of starting from zero for every file.
Environmental Supplemental Plan is an environmentally beneficial project or activity, not otherwise required by law, that an alleged violator agrees to undertake as part of settling an environmental clearance process. It is a restorative idea rather than a clearance condition: the violator funds or performs ecological benefit beyond routine compliance. It matters because it separates two questions that post-facto debates often mix, namely punishment for starting without clearance and additional ecological repair for harm already done.
A comparative lesson runs through the reform debate. In several developed systems, public and expert involvement begins at screening and scoping, reports are written for local readers, and social and health effects are assessed together with ecology. India's recurring weaknesses sit at exactly those points: late consultation, consultant-driven reports and thin multidisciplinary teams. The direction of travel is therefore not only faster clearance through PARIVESH, but earlier, better and more locally legible assessment.
The precautionary principle: act before the proof is complete
The precautionary principle is the safety rule used in science and law when harm is uncertain: where an activity may cause serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific certainty should not delay cost-effective preventive measures. It is applied in environmental decision-making, including environmental impact assessment and the Supreme Court's reasoning in the Jim Corbett matter.
Way forward
Independent assessment: have EIAs conducted or audited by an autonomous body that is not funded by the project proponent.
Technology-enabled monitoring: enforce post-clearance compliance digitally and make violation reporting public.
Landscape-level EIA: move from project-by-project appraisal to cumulative, airshed and landscape-level assessment integrated with climate risk.
Genuine public participation: restore meaningful consultation with regional-language documents and train panchayats to use EIA as a participatory tool.
Empower the NGT: add judicial members and dedicated environmental benches for faster, expert adjudication.
Balance speed with scrutiny: use reforms like SAEIA and SCEIA to end genuine delays without diluting environmental safeguards.
Key Terms
- Environment (Protection) Act, 1986: The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 is the umbrella statute for environmental governance in India, passed after the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy exposed gaps in pollution law. It gives the Centre sweeping powers: laying down standards for air, water and soil quality, regulating the handling of hazardous substances, restricting areas where industries may operate, and delegating enforcement to agencies such as the Central and State Pollution Control Boards. It provides for penalties, including imprisonment, for violations, and is the parent Act for the EIA process and most waste-management rules. Example: Directions closing a polluting factory or restricting construction in a fragile coastal zone are typically issued under this Act.
- EIA Notification, 2006: The EIA Notification, 2006 (S.O. 1533(E), issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986) makes prior environmental clearance mandatory for listed development projects such as mining, thermal power, river-valley projects, ports, airports and large construction. It decentralised the process by creating Category A projects (appraised at the Centre by Expert Appraisal Committees, clearance by the Environment Ministry) and Category B projects (appraised by State Expert Appraisal Committees, clearance by State authorities, with B1 needing a full EIA and B2 exempted). The assessment cycle runs through screening, scoping, public consultation and appraisal. Example: A new thermal power plant, a Category A project, must complete an EIA and obtain clearance before construction begins.
- Category A: Category A covers projects of national significance or with the largest environmental footprint under the EIA Notification, 2006. Such projects are appraised centrally by the Expert Appraisal Committee and require environmental clearance from the Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change. They must complete a full EIA study and public consultation before clearance can be granted. Example: Large mining leases, major irrigation projects and thermal power plants of 500 MW or more fall under Category A.
- Expert Appraisal Committee: An Expert Appraisal Committee is a body constituted under the EIA Notification, 2006 to appraise projects requiring central-level (Category A) environmental clearance. It examines EIA reports, public hearing outcomes and Terms of Reference compliance, and recommends grant or rejection of environmental clearance to the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change. Separate sectoral EACs exist for industries, mining, infrastructure and other project types. Example: The EAC on coal mining projects appraises the EIA reports of new opencast mines before clearance is decided.
- Category B: Category B covers projects with comparatively smaller environmental impacts, appraised at the state level by the State Expert Appraisal Committee and cleared by the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) under the EIA Notification, 2006. Category B is split into B1, which requires a full EIA report and public hearing, and B2, which is exempt from both. Many building, township and small industrial projects fall in this category. Example: A township or area development project covering 50 to 150 hectares is typically appraised as Category B1.
- PARIVESH: Pro-Active and Responsive facilitation by Interactive and Virtuous Environmental Single-window Hub, the Environment Ministry's web-based single-window system launched in 2018 for processing environmental, forest, wildlife and coastal regulation zone clearances. It digitises the entire environmental impact assessment and clearance workflow, from terms of reference to appraisal and compliance monitoring, making timelines transparent and trackable. It was designed to cut delays while keeping the clearance process accountable. Example: A mining or highway project applies for environmental clearance through PARIVESH, which tracks its proposal through appraisal committees and public hearing stages online.
- Public hearing: A public hearing is the in-person component of public consultation under the EIA Notification, 2006, convened by the State Pollution Control Board at or near the proposed project site. Affected people, local bodies, and stakeholders record their objections, suggestions, and concerns about the draft Environmental Impact Assessment report, and the proceedings form part of the record considered before environmental clearance. It is the principal formal channel for community participation in project approval. Example: Villagers recording objections to a proposed thermal power plant at a public hearing chaired by the district administration
- Draft EIA Notification, 2020: The draft EIA Notification, 2020 was a proposal issued by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change in March 2020 to replace the EIA Notification of 2006. Its most debated provisions were the reduction of the public consultation response period from 30 to 20 days, a formal route for post-facto (ex-post facto) clearance of projects operating in violation, and expanded exemptions for categories such as inland waterways, national highway expansion and large building projects. It drew sharp criticism from environmentalists and a UN Special Rapporteur, and it remained a draft amid the controversy. Example: The proposal to cut the public consultation window from 30 to 20 days, which critics said would curtail the voice of project-affected communities.
- Post-facto clearance: Post-facto clearance means granting environmental clearance to a project that was already built or started operating without the mandatory prior approval. India's EIA framework requires prior clearance precisely so that impacts are assessed before construction begins, and the Supreme Court has repeatedly held that retrospective clearance is alien to environmental jurisprudence. In Alembic Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Rohit Prajapati (2020), the Court struck down the practice of ex post facto clearances and imposed heavy compensation on the offending industries. Example: The draft EIA 2020 notification's proposal to let violation projects be regularised after construction, which drew strong public opposition and remains unfinalised.
- National Green Tribunal: The National Green Tribunal is a statutory environmental court established on 18 October 2010 under the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010, with its principal bench in New Delhi and circuit benches across India. It adjudicates cases on environmental protection, applies the polluter pays and precautionary principles, is not bound by the Civil Procedure Code, and is guided by natural justice. It matters for UPSC as GS-2/GS-3 environment governance, frequently cited in mains answers on environmental justice. Example: The NGT ordered the closure of the Sterlite copper plant at Thoothukudi, Tamil Nadu, in 2018 over pollution concerns
- Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA): Environmental Impact Assessment is a process of identifying, predicting and evaluating the likely environmental impacts of a proposed project before it is cleared, so that decision makers can approve, modify or reject it. In India it is mandatory for specified projects under the EIA Notification, 2006 issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, and it involves screening, scoping, public consultation and appraisal before environmental clearance is granted. Applications and status tracking run through the PARIVESH portal. Example: A proposed mining or thermal power project must obtain prior environmental clearance based on its EIA before construction begins.
- Environmental Clearance (EC): Environmental Clearance is the prior permission a project proponent must obtain from the government before starting any project listed in the schedule of the EIA Notification, 2006. It is granted after the EIA cycle of screening, scoping, public consultation and appraisal: Category A projects are cleared at the Centre on Expert Appraisal Committee recommendations, while Category B projects go through State authorities. Starting construction without a valid EC is a violation that can lead to closure orders and prosecution, and applications are filed through the PARIVESH portal. Example: A mining lease cannot be executed until the project secures environmental clearance from the competent authority.
- State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA): The State Environment Impact Assessment Authority is the state-level body constituted under the EIA Notification, 2006 that grants or rejects prior environmental clearance for Category B projects. It acts on the appraisal recommendations of the State Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), and its members must meet domain-experience criteria under Appendix VI of the notification. When a SEIAA lapses, the 2026 amendments route pending proposals to the new Standing Authority on EIA (SAEIA). Example: A SEIAA deciding the environmental clearance of a Category B limestone mining project based on the SEAC's appraisal report.
- Social Impact Assessment (SIA): Social Impact Assessment is a mandatory study under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (LARR Act), conducted before land is acquired for a project. It assesses whether the proposed acquisition serves a genuine public purpose, estimates the number of affected families, examines the social and economic impact on livelihoods, and requires consultation with gram sabhas in Scheduled Areas. The SIA report, along with an expert group's appraisal, is a precondition for the government's preliminary notification of acquisition. Example: An SIA conducted for a proposed industrial corridor project to document affected families and rehabilitation requirements before land acquisition begins.
- Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA): Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) is the evaluation of environmental effects of a policy, plan or programme before individual projects are decided. It tackles cumulative impacts and alternatives at regional or sector scale. Example: a river-basin assessment that decides the pattern of hydropower projects before each dam seeks clearance.
Prelims practice
0 of 5 answered · 0 correct
With reference to the history of Environmental Impact Assessment in India, consider the following statements:
1. EIA was introduced in 1978 for river valley projects.
2. It was made statutory through the EIA Notification of 1994 under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
With reference to the EIA Notification, 2006, which of the following correctly describes Category B2 projects?
Consider the following statements about the PARIVESH portal:
1. It was launched in 2018 as a single-window platform for environmental, forest, wildlife, and coastal clearances.
2. PARIVESH 2.0 was fully operationalised in 2024.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
The Supreme Court in Alembic Pharmaceuticals v. Rohit Prajapati (2020) ruled on which of the following?
Under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, the consent of affected families required for private projects is:
Mains Practice question
Q. How does the draft Environment Impact Assessment Notification, 2020 differ from the existing EIA Notification, 2006? (250 words)
Framing hintCompare provision by provision, then evaluate the critique. Cite the Alembic judgment and the 17 lakh public comments.
Reduced public hearing: notice period cut from 30 to 20 days, narrowing community participation.
Wider exemptions: many B1/B2 and strategic projects exempted from clearance or hearings.
Post-facto clearance: retrospective EC allowed; held 'unsustainable in law' in Alembic Pharmaceuticals v. Rohit Prajapati (2020), relitigated in Vanashakti v. Union of India (struck down May 2025; recalled 2:1 in review, November 2025).
Relaxed compliance: annual instead of six-monthly reports; mandatory public violation reporting removed.
Critique: undermines the rule of law, erodes accountability, neglects cumulative impacts and livelihoods; remains stalled as of 2026.
Q. What role do environmental NGOs and activists play in influencing Environmental Impact Assessment outcomes for major projects in India? Cite four examples. (150 words)
Framing hintOne example per intervention, each showing a different failure of official appraisal.
Narmada Bachao Andolan (Sardar Sarovar Dam): challenged inadequate displacement and ecological assessment, forcing reassessments and better rehabilitation.
Kalpavriksh (POSCO, Odisha): exposed forest-clearance and consultation deficiencies, contributing to the 2010 revocation and project withdrawal.
Goa Foundation (Goa mining): Supreme Court petitions secured a temporary mining ban and mandated fresh EIAs.
Greenpeace India (Mundra Port and SEZ): independent scientific data exposed EIA deficiencies, prompting tighter controls.
Q. Examine the challenges in implementing EIA in India and suggest reforms to balance development with environmental protection. (250 words)
Framing hintDiagnose first (monitoring, data, participation, cumulative impacts), then reform each diagnosis.
Challenges: weak post-clearance monitoring, poor baseline data, tokenistic hearings, ignored cumulative impacts, proponent-funded conflict of interest, lapsed SEIAAs.
Independent assessment by an autonomous body not funded by the proponent.
Technology-enabled compliance monitoring with public violation reporting; landscape-level cumulative EIA.
Genuine participation through regional-language documents and empowered panchayats; a stronger NGT.
Use SAEIA/SCEIA to end genuine delays without diluting safeguards: speed with scrutiny.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Category A and Category B projects?
Category A projects are appraised centrally by MoEFCC through the Expert Appraisal Committee, while Category B projects are appraised at the state level by the SEIAA and SEAC. Within Category B, B1 projects need a full EIA study and a public hearing; B2 projects are exempt from both and need only application-level appraisal.
Is a public hearing mandatory for every project seeking clearance?
No. Public consultation is mandatory for Category A and B1 projects, with 30 days' notice in the project area. Category B2 projects skip the hearing, as do certain exempted categories such as defence and national-security projects.
What is post-facto environmental clearance, and why is it controversial?
It means granting environmental clearance to a project that has already been built or started without prior approval. The Supreme Court ruled it unconstitutional in Alembic Pharmaceuticals v. Rohit Prajapati (2020), holding that it rewards illegality and violates the rule of law.
What does the PARIVESH portal actually do?
PARIVESH is the single-window digital platform for applying for and tracking environmental, forest, wildlife, and coastal clearances. It covers the full lifecycle from application and Terms of Reference through appraisal to the final decision, with GIS-based screening and real-time status tracking.
The two Acts behind every clearance
Two laws sit behind almost every environmental clearance in India. The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 created the Central and state pollution control boards and requires consent before any industry discharges effluents. The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 extended the same machinery to air emissions, and a 1987 amendment brought noise within its scope. Together with the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, they are the legal spine on which environmental impact assessment and the Parivesh single-window clearance system rest.
Asked in the mains
Previous-year questions from this topic
How UPSC has actually asked this topic — with the year and marks for each question.
- 201412.5 marks
Environmental Impact Assessment studies are increasingly undertaken before a project is cleared by the Government. Discuss the environmental impact of coal-fired thermal plants located at coal pitheads.
- 201612.5 marks
Rehabilitation of human settlements is one of the important environmental impacts which always attracts controversy while planning major projects. Discuss the measures suggested from mitigation of this impact while proposing major developmental projects.
- 202010 marks
How does the draft Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2020 differ from the existing EIA Notification, 2006?
- 202410 marks
What role do environmental NGOs and activists play in influencing Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) outcomes for major projects in India? Cite four examples with all important details.
Asked in the prelims
Previous-year MCQs from this topic
How UPSC has tested this topic in the prelims — pick an option to test yourself.
- 2018Prelims
1.How is the National Green Tribunal (NGT) different from the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB)? 1.The NGT has been established by an Act whereas the CPCB has been created by an executive order of the Government. 2.The NGT provides environmental justice and helps reduce the burden of litigation in the higher courts whereas the CPCB promotes cleanliness of streams and wells, and aims to improve the quality of air in the country. Which of the statements given above is/ are correct?