Polity· Prelims · GS-II
Federalism in India: why the Centre is stronger by design
Why the framers built a federation with a built-in central advantage, how the Seventh Schedule divides power, and why 2025's language, water and CBI fights keep testing the design.

India is a federation that refuses to call itself one. The Constitution never uses the word federal, describes India as a Union of States, and then hands the Centre powers that would make most federal governments envious. This was not an accident or a drafting error. It was a deliberate choice by people who had just watched a subcontinent tear itself apart. This article explains why the Centre is stronger by design, where the states still hold real power, and how the 2025 headlines keep testing the balance.
Key takeaways
- The Constitution never uses the word 'federal'. Article 1 describes India as a 'Union of States', and K.C. Wheare famously called the arrangement quasi-federal.
- The unitary tilt is structural: Parliament can redraw state boundaries under Article 3, and the design includes single citizenship, an integrated judiciary and All-India Services.
- The Seventh Schedule divides subjects into the Union List (about 100 entries), the State List (about 61) and the Concurrent List (about 52), with residuary powers resting with the Union.
- Fiscal federalism runs through the Finance Commission (Article 280) and, since the 101st Amendment of 2016, the GST Council (Article 279A).
Holding together, not coming together
Federations come in two varieties. In coming-together federations like the United States, sovereign states agree to unite and keep substantial autonomy. In holding-together federations like India, a large diverse country decides to stay together by devolving power downward, and the Centre keeps the upper hand. The framers modelled India on Canada, not America, because India was formed by the disintegration of British India, not by a contract among states.
Article 1 says India shall be a Union of States, and Ambedkar explained the choice: the Union was not the result of an agreement among states, no state can secede, and the Union is indestructible even though state boundaries are not. In S.R. Bommai (1994) the Supreme Court held that federalism is part of the basic structure, so the federal character cannot be amended away, but within that character the Centre is decisively stronger.
Article 1: three kinds of territory, and the sea beyond the shore
Article 1 does more than name the Union. It sorts the territory of India into three categories: the territories of the states, the Union territories, and any territories that may be acquired by the Government of India at any time. The territory of India is therefore wider than the Union of India: the Union is the states alone, while the territory adds the Union territories and anything acquired later. The states are members of the federal system and share powers with the Centre; the Union territories and acquired territories are administered directly by the Central government.
The sea counts too. Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, 1982, the territory of India also includes the territorial waters, the continental shelf, the exclusive economic zone and any other maritime zone, measured from the mainland and from the island groups that form part of India. The Constitution also leaves room for special treatment inside the states: Part XXI carries special provisions for states such as Maharashtra, Gujarat, Nagaland and Assam, while the Fifth and Sixth Schedules carry separate provisions for scheduled areas and tribal areas. As a sovereign state, India can acquire foreign territory by the modes recognised in international law. The French settlements of Pondicherry, Mahe and Yanam were ceded by treaty in 1954 and administered as acquired territories until the French Parliament ratified the cession, after which they were constituted as a Union Territory in 1962.
The federal features
India does have the classic federal equipment: a written and largely rigid Constitution, a division of powers between the Union and the states, an independent Supreme Court to arbitrate their disputes, a Rajya Sabha that represents the states, and dual government, with the Union handling defence, foreign affairs and currency while states handle police, health and agriculture. The Constitution is supreme, and courts can strike down laws that violate the division of powers.
The unitary tilt: where the Centre wins
Against that, the list of central advantages is long:
- Parliament can legislate on State List subjects in the national interest on a Rajya Sabha resolution (Article 249), at the request of two or more states (Article 252), to implement international treaties (Article 253), or during a national emergency.
- Parliament alone can redraw state boundaries, rename states and create new ones under Article 3, without the affected state's consent.
- Residuary powers, including residuary taxation, belong to Parliament under Article 248.
- During emergencies the federal structure converts to a unitary one without any constitutional amendment.
- There is a single citizenship, a single integrated judiciary, single all-India services, and a single audit machinery.
- The Governor, appointed by the Centre, can reserve state bills for the President's consideration (Articles 200 and 201), and the President can veto them.
- Most constitutional amendments need only Parliament; states cannot initiate amendments.
The Seventh Schedule: who legislates on what
List | Entries | Who legislates | Sample subjects |
|---|---|---|---|
Union List | 98 (originally 97) | Parliament exclusively | Defence, foreign affairs, railways, banking, atomic energy |
State List | 59 (originally 66) | State legislatures, in normal circumstances | Police, public health, agriculture, land |
Concurrent List | 52 (originally 47) | Both; in a conflict the central law prevails unless the state law received the President's assent | Criminal law, marriage, contracts, education, forests, electricity |
The division of subjects runs through three lists:
Money and administration
Financial relations are tilted too. The Finance Commission, constituted by the President every five years under Article 280, recommends how Union tax revenues are shared; the 15th Finance Commission (2021-26) fixed the states' share of the net proceeds of Union taxes at 41 percent, and the 16th, chaired by Arvind Panagariya, was constituted at the end of 2023. Only Parliament can levy a surcharge, and it keeps the whole of it. States borrow only within India and need the Centre's consent if they owe it money.
Administratively, Article 256 obliges states to comply with parliamentary laws and lets the Centre issue directions; defiance can trigger President's Rule under Article 365. The All-India Services, created by Parliament on a Rajya Sabha resolution under Article 312, give the Centre officers posted in every state. Article 355 makes it the Centre's duty to protect states against external aggression and internal disturbance and to ensure that every state government runs according to the Constitution.
The institutions that manage the friction
The Constitution provides safety valves. Article 263 allows the President to establish an Inter-State Council for matters of common interest; one was set up in 1990 on the Sarkaria Commission's recommendation, with a secretariat and a standing committee under the Home Minister. Article 262 lets Parliament legislate on inter-state river disputes and even exclude the courts; the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 creates tribunals with exclusive jurisdiction, which is why the Cauvery, Krishna and Mahanadi disputes travel through tribunals rather than ordinary courts. Two expert commissions have reviewed the whole relationship: Sarkaria (1983), which wanted a permanent inter-governmental council and an eminent, apolitical Governor; and Punchhi (2007-10), which wanted the Centre to legislate on Concurrent subjects only in the essential national interest and a fixed tenure for Governors.
2025: the balance under stress
Recent headlines show federalism is a live argument, not a settled chapter. Tamil Nadu's clash with the Centre over the three-language formula of the National Education Policy 2020 revived the language-federalism debate; Tamil Nadu has followed a two-language policy of Tamil and English since 1968. The Supreme Court ruled that the CBI does not need a state's consent to register cases against central government employees posted in that state, a judgment with sharp edges since several states have withdrawn general consent to the CBI. In 2025 Punjab objected when the Bhakra Beas Management Board raised Haryana's water release, and the long-running Sutlej-Yamuna Link canal dispute returned to the headlines. And Tamil Nadu's 2025-26 budget replaced the rupee symbol with the Tamil letter for roobai, a symbolic assertion of linguistic federalism. Each episode tests the same question the framers debated: how much unity does diversity need, and who decides?
Rajamannar (1969): the first state-level review
The Rajamannar Committee (1969) was the Centre-State relations inquiry set up by Tamil Nadu under P.V. Rajamannar, a former Chief Justice of the Madras High Court. It recommended curtailing the misuse of Article 356, abolishing the all-India services, transferring residuary subjects to the states, and ending the Planning Commission's discretionary grants. It was the first systematic state-level articulation of the autonomy demand, predating the Sarkaria Commission (1983) and the Punchhi Commission (2007) by decades.
Two federalisms: India and the United States
Federalism is not one design. India and the United States both call themselves federal, but they built the union from opposite ends, and the difference shows up in every exam question on the subject.
Feature | India | United States |
|---|---|---|
Nature of federalism | Quasi-federal, with a unitary bias | True (dual) federalism |
Source of authority | One Constitution; states derive power from it | States pre-existed the union; both levels draw authority from the Constitution |
Creating new states | Parliament can create, rename or alter state boundaries (Article 3) | States joined voluntarily; equal status after union |
Division of powers | Three lists in the Seventh Schedule: Union, State, Concurrent | Enumerated federal powers; the rest reserved to the states |
Supremacy | Constitution supreme; Centre has overriding powers | Constitution supreme; each level sovereign in its own sphere |
Judiciary | One integrated judiciary; the Supreme Court guards the Constitution | Dual court system; the Supreme Court enforces the federal balance |
Amendment process | Most amendments need only a special parliamentary majority | Needs approval of three-fourths of the states |
Emergency provisions | Centre can override states during emergencies (Articles 352, 356, 360) | No such provision; states keep autonomy |
Citizenship | Single citizenship for all Indians | Dual citizenship: federal and state |
Financial powers | Centre holds the bigger purse | States enjoy wider fiscal autonomy |
The exam shorthand is worth memorising: India is an indestructible Union of destructible states, the United States an indestructible union of indestructible states. Everything in the table above flows from that one line.
Redrawing the map: how India reorganises its states
Article 3 is the Constitution's redraw tool: Parliament may form a new state, increase or diminish any state's area, alter its boundaries or change its name. The President must recommend the bill and the affected state's legislature gets to state its views, but Parliament is not bound by them, and the whole exercise needs only a simple majority, which is why reorganisation is far easier in India than in most federations.
The first decade argued over language. The Linguistic Provinces Commission (Dhar Commission, 1948) and the JVP Committee (1949) resisted linguistic states, but the death of Potti Sriramulu after his fast for a Telugu-speaking state forced the Centre's hand: Andhra State was carved out in 1953, and the States Reorganisation Commission (Fazl Ali Commission, 1953) then recommended redrawing the map broadly on linguistic lines. The States Reorganisation Act, 1956 created 14 states and 6 Union Territories, and the linguistic principle has guided every redraw since.
Later milestones kept the same tool at work: Bombay split into Maharashtra and Gujarat (1960), Punjab into Punjab and Haryana (1966), the northeast reorganisation of the early 1970s, the trio of Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand (2000), and Telangana (2014). The Jammu and Kashmir story, the most contested use of Article 3, is told in full in the article on Jammu and Kashmir.
Year | Reorganisation |
|---|---|
1953 | Andhra State created for Telugu speakers, the first linguistic state |
1956 | States Reorganisation Act: 14 states and 6 Union Territories on linguistic lines |
1960 | Bombay bifurcated into Maharashtra and Gujarat |
1966 | Punjab reorganised into Punjab and Haryana; Himachal Pradesh alongside |
2000 | Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand created |
2014 | Telangana carved out of Andhra Pradesh |
Prelims hooks
- India is a holding-together federation modelled on Canada; Article 1 describes it as a Union of States, and states have no right to secede.
- Federalism is part of the basic structure (S.R. Bommai, 1994).
- Seventh Schedule: Union List 98 subjects, State List 59, Concurrent List 52; residuary powers with Parliament under Article 248.
- Parliament can legislate on State subjects under Articles 249 (Rajya Sabha resolution), 252 (two or more states request), 253 (treaties) and during a national emergency.
- Article 3 lets Parliament redraw state boundaries without the state's consent.
- Finance Commission: Article 280, every five years; 15th FC fixed states' share at 41 percent of net Union tax proceeds; 16th FC chaired by Arvind Panagariya.
- GST is the only tax entry in the Concurrent List (101st Amendment, 2016); surcharges belong entirely to the Centre.
- Inter-State Council: Article 263, set up 1990 on Sarkaria's recommendation; inter-state water disputes go to tribunals under the 1956 Act, excluding the Supreme Court's jurisdiction (Article 262).
- Sarkaria Commission (1983) and Punchhi Commission (2007-10) reviewed Centre-state relations.
- Article 312: All-India Services created by Parliament on a Rajya Sabha resolution.
Mains angle
Federalism questions reward a structured argument rather than a list. Open with the design thesis: the framers chose a strong Centre because Partition had shown what weak central authority costs, and because economic planning and national integration needed central direction. Then show the constitutional mechanisms of central dominance: the Seventh Schedule's residuary rule, Article 3, the emergency provisions, financial centralisation, and the Governor's office.
The second half should show the counterweights: the basic structure ruling in Bommai, the Finance Commission, the GST Council's shared decision-making, judicial review of Article 356 after Bommai, and the political reality of coalition-era bargaining. Apply this to a current issue, such as the language policy clash or the CBI consent controversy, and argue that Indian federalism is best understood not as a fixed division but as a continuous negotiation, with the Constitution providing the table, the rules and, through the courts, the referee. Conclude with the Punchhi Commission's counsel: the Centre should legislate on Concurrent subjects only in the essential national interest.
Frequently asked questions
Can Indian states secede from the Union?
No. The Union is indestructible though states are destructible; states have no right to secede.
What did the Sarkaria and Punchhi Commissions examine?
Centre-state relations. Sarkaria (1983) and Punchhi (2007) both recommended restraint in using Articles 355 and 356 and norms for gubernatorial appointments.
Who gets residuary legislative powers?
The Union Parliament, following the Canadian model of a strong centre, under Article 248.
Is the Finance Commission a constitutional body?
Yes, constituted under Article 280 every five years to recommend the devolution of taxes between the Union and the states.
What political scientists called Indian federalism
Scholars have never agreed on a single label for the Indian federation, and the exam loves asking who said what. Beyond K.C. Wheare's famous quasi-federal description, each of these labels is a definition you should be able to complete: the name, the label, and the logic behind it.
- Paul Appleby: called the Indian system extremely federal, pointing to the sheer scale of governmental activity at the state level despite the Centre's formal supremacy.
- Morris Jones: described it as bargaining federalism, where the Centre and the states negotiate continuously instead of operating in sealed compartments.
- Ivor Jennings: saw a federation with a strong centralising tendency, noting the Constitution's unique safeguards for national unity and growth.
- Alexandrowicz: called India a case sui generis, one of its own kind, arguing that no imported federal model quite fits it.
- Granville Austin: named it cooperative federalism, a new kind of federation deliberately tailored to India's specific needs.
- K. Santhanam: stressed the system's unitary bias, driven above all by the Centre's financial dominance over the states.
- B.R. Ambedkar: insisted the federation is indestructible and not the result of an agreement; the states have no right to secede because the Union was never formed by a compact among them.
Key Terms
- Union of States: Union of States is the description of India in Article 1 of the Constitution: India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States. B. R. Ambedkar explained that the Indian federation is a Union because it was not created by an agreement among states and no state has a right to secede. For UPSC, the phrase is the classic mains distinction between the Indian Union and the American federation. Article 1
- Holding-together federations: Holding-together federations are federations created when a large, diverse country chooses to devolve power to its regions, rather than sovereign units deciding to come together. The term comes from political scientist Alfred Stepan and covers India, Spain and Belgium: the Constitution is framed centrally and autonomy is granted top-down, so the Centre typically retains superior power. The concept explains India's unitary tilt and why its federalism differs structurally from the coming-together model of the USA or Switzerland. India, Spain and Belgium in Alfred Stepan's classification of federations.
- Coming-together federations: Coming-together federations are federations formed when previously independent states voluntarily unite, pooling sovereignty for common purposes, with the United States as the classic example. Constitutional scholar K.C. Wheare’s classification contrasts them with holding-together federations like India, where a large polity devolves power to units while retaining a strong centre. UPSC uses the distinction to explain why Indian federalism leans centralised compared to the American model. The thirteen American colonies came together as sovereign states to form the United States under the 1787 Constitution.
- Sarkaria Commission: The Sarkaria Commission (1983-88), chaired by Justice R.S. Sarkaria, comprehensively reviewed Centre-State relations and submitted 247 recommendations. It favoured a strong Centre with cooperative federalism, restrained use of Article 356, and consultation with Chief Ministers on Governor appointments. Later commissions, including Punchhi, built on its framework. For UPSC, it is the foundational text of Indian federalism. Example: the Supreme Court's Bommai judgment echoes its Article 356 safeguards. It recommended the Inter-State Council be made a permanent constitutional forum.
- Punchhi Commission: The Punchhi Commission was the Commission on Centre-State Relations appointed in 2007 under Justice M.M. Punchhi, reporting in 2010. It reviewed Union-state relations, recommending restraint in imposing President's Rule, clearer norms for Governors, and greater state say in Concurrent List legislation. It is the standard reference for contemporary federalism questions. Its advice that Article 356 be used only as a last resort echoes the Bommai judgment.
- Seventh Schedule: The Seventh Schedule of the Constitution divides legislative subjects between the Union and the states through three lists: the Union List for Parliament alone (defence, foreign affairs, railways), the State List for state legislatures (police, public health, agriculture), and the Concurrent List where both can legislate, with Parliament prevailing in conflict. It is the operational core of Indian federalism. Education sits on the Concurrent List after the 42nd Amendment moved it there in 1976.
- Concurrent List: The Concurrent List, or List III of the Seventh Schedule, contains subjects on which both Parliament and state legislatures can make laws, currently 52 entries including education, forests, and marriage. In case of repugnancy, parliamentary law prevails under Article 254. For UPSC, it is the constitutional mechanism of shared federal jurisdiction and a frequent source of centre-state friction questions. Education was shifted from the State List to the Concurrent List by the 42nd Constitutional Amendment in 1976.
- Article 248: Article 248 vests residuary powers of legislation in Parliament, covering any matter not enumerated in the State List or the Concurrent List, including the residuary power of taxation under clause (2), read with Entry 97 of the Union List. In Union of India v. H.S. Dhillon (1972), the Supreme Court held that if a subject fits no list, Parliament's competence follows automatically. For UPSC, it exemplifies India's central tilt, borrowed from Canada. The Information Technology Act, 2000 is widely cited as a law enacted under residuary power.
- Article 263: Article 263 empowers the President to establish an Inter-State Council whenever public interest would be served, to inquire into and advise upon inter-state disputes, to discuss subjects of common interest to states or to the Union and states, and to recommend better coordination of policy and action. For UPSC, it is the constitutional instrument of cooperative federalism. The Council was constituted by Presidential Order on 28 May 1990 on the Sarkaria Commission's recommendation, with the Prime Minister as chairperson.
- Article 356: Article 356 is the provision empowering the President to impose President's Rule in a State when satisfied, on the Governor's report or otherwise, that its government cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution. It requires parliamentary approval within two months, lasts six months at a time, and can extend to three years under special conditions. UPSC relevance: its history of misuse and the judicial safeguards against it. The Supreme Court's judgment in S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) laid down strict limits on the misuse of Article 356.
- GST Council: The GST Council is the constitutional body created by Article 279A under the 101st Amendment of 2016 to steer the Goods and Services Tax. It is chaired by the Union Finance Minister and includes state finance ministers, with decisions taken by a weighted majority in which the Centre holds one-third of the votes and the states two-thirds. It matters for UPSC because it is the flagship example of cooperative federalism, with its rate slabs, compensation mechanism and dispute record appearing regularly in both Prelims and Mains. The 56th GST Council meeting, which restructured slabs while retaining a 40 per cent rate for luxury and sin goods.
- S.R. Bommai: S.R. Bommai was the Janata Party Chief Minister of Karnataka whose government was dismissed in 1989 after the Governor reported he had lost his majority. In S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), a nine-judge Supreme Court bench held that Article 356 is subject to judicial review, that majority must be tested on the Assembly floor, and that secularism is part of the Constitution's basic structure. It matters for UPSC as the landmark judgment on President's Rule and federalism. S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994)
Practice questions
- Consider the following statements about Indian federalism:
- The Constitution describes India as a Federation of States.
- States in India have no right to secede from the Union.
- Federalism is a part of the basic structure of the Constitution.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: (a) Article 1 describes India as a Union of States, not a Federation of States.
- Residuary powers of legislation in India rest with:
(a) the State legislatures (b) Parliament (c) both Parliament and State legislatures concurrently (d) the Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: (b) Article 248 vests residuary powers in Parliament.
- Which of the following statements about the Seventh Schedule is/are correct?
- The Union List currently has 98 subjects.
- The Concurrent List contains tax entries only in the case of GST.
- In case of a conflict between a central and a state law on a Concurrent subject, the state law always prevails.
Select the correct answer using the code given below: (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: (a) On a Concurrent subject the central law prevails unless the state law received the President's assent, and even then Parliament can override it later.
- The Inter-State Council was established under which Article of the Constitution?
(a) Article 262 (b) Article 263 (c) Article 280 (d) Article 312
- Consider the following statements:
- Parliament can redraw the boundaries of a state without that state's consent.
- A surcharge levied by Parliament is shared with the states on the Finance Commission's recommendation.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 1 only (b) 2 only (c) Both 1 and 2 (d) Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: (a) Surcharges under Article 271 go entirely to the Centre and are not shared.
Answer key
- (a): Article 1 describes India as a Union of States, not a Federation of States.
- (b): Article 248 vests residuary powers in Parliament.
- (a): On a Concurrent subject the central law prevails unless the state law received the President's assent, and even then Parliament can override it later.
- (b)
- (a): Surcharges under Article 271 go entirely to the Centre and are not shared.
Mains Practice question
Q. Indian federalism is often described as a unitary state with subsidiary federal features. Critically examine this view in light of recent Centre-state frictions. *(250 words)*
Framing hintStructure the answer around the unitary tilt (Article 3, emergency provisions, governors) versus the federal safeguards (Finance Commission, GST Council, judicial review). Use 2025 flashpoints, the governor-assent rulings and language and delimitation debates, as evidence.
Asked in the mains
Previous-year questions from this topic
How UPSC has actually asked this topic — with the year and marks for each question.
- 202615 marks
How far has the Indian federal framework been successful in accommodating regional and cultural diversities? Highlight the role of asymmetric federalism and suggest measures to make dispute resolution mechanisms more effective.
- 202010 marks
How far do you think cooperation, competition and confrontation have shaped the nature of federation in India? Cite some recent examples to validate your answer
- 202015 marks
Indian constitution exhibits centralising tendencies to maintain unity and integrity of the nation. Elucidate in the perspective of the Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897; The Disaster Management Act, 2005 and recently passed Farm Acts.
- 202215 marks
While the national political parties in India favour centralisation, the regional parties are in favour of State autonomy." Comment.
- 201310 marks
Many State Governments further bifurcate geographical administrative areas like Districts and Talukas for better governance. In light of the above, can it also be justified that more number of smaller States would bring in effective governance at State level? Discuss.
- 201310 marks
Constitutional mechanisms to resolve the inter-state water disputes have failed to address and solve the problems. Is the failure due to structural or process inadequacy or both? Discuss.
In current affairs
This topic in the news