Polity — Prelims· Prelims
Constitutional Bodies: CAG, Election Commission, UPSC, Finance Commission and More
How the CAG, Election Commission, UPSC, Attorney General, national commissions and Finance Commission are appointed, how long they serve and how they can be removed.
A constitutional body is different from every other body in the Indian state because the Constitution itself creates it and defines its powers. That single fact decides how its members are appointed, how long they serve, how they can be removed, and whose money pays them, and prelims tests exactly those comparisons.
This article works through the main constitutional bodies in the order the book presents them: the types of bodies in India, the big comparison of the CAG, Election Commission, UPSC and State Public Service Commissions, the Joint State Public Service Commission, the Attorney General and Advocate General, the commissions for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes, and the Finance Commission, GST Council and Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities, closing with the new law on appointing election commissioners.
Types of bodies and authorities in India
Type of body | Formation | Examples | Powers |
|---|---|---|---|
Constitutional Bodies | Established by the Constitution itself | Election Commission, Finance Commission, UPSC, CAG | Powers defined in the Constitution |
Extra or Non-Constitutional Bodies | Created by administrative decisions | National Development Council, various advisory bodies | Varies based on the governing framework |
Statutory Bodies | Established by an Act of Parliament or state legislature | Reserve Bank of India, Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) | Powers defined by the enabling statute |
Judicial Bodies | Established under the Constitution or legislation | Supreme Court, High Courts, Subordinate Courts | Adjudicative powers; interprets laws and resolves disputes |
Executive Bodies | Established by the Constitution or legislation | Council of Ministers, various ministries | Executes laws and administers governance |
Quasi-Judicial Bodies | Created by statutes or regulations | Central Administrative Tribunal, State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissions | Limited judicial powers; can make decisions based on law and facts |
CAG, Election Commission, UPSC and SPSC compared
The four bodies most often compared in prelims are the Comptroller and Auditor General, the Election Commission, the Union Public Service Commission and the State Public Service Commissions. Their articles, heads, terms and removal procedures differ in small ways that the exam probes, so the comparison is given here as a table, exactly as the book sets it out.
Category | Comptroller and Auditor General | Election Commission | Union Public Service Commission | State Public Service Commission |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Articles and Acts | Articles 148 to 151, Part V | Article 324, Part XV | Articles 315 to 323, Part XIV | Articles 315 to 323, Part XIV |
Head | Comptroller General | Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) | Chairman | Chairman |
Members | Single member | Number determined by the President (Article 324(2)), currently 2 Election Commissioners, asked in UPSC 2017 | Strength left to the discretion of the President, presently 10 members: 1 chairman plus 9 members (Article 318) | Strength not fixed; determined by the Governor |
Appointment | President | President | President | Governor |
Qualification | Not specified | Not specified | 50 percent must hold 10 years of service in the Government of India or a State | 50 percent must hold 10 years of service in the Government of India or a State |
Term | 6 years or till 65 years | 6 years or till 65 years | 6 years or till 65 years | 6 years or till 62 years |
Resign to | President | President | President | Governor |
Renewal | Not allowed | Not allowed | Not allowed | Not allowed |
Future employment | Not allowed | If an Election Commissioner is appointed as Chief Election Commissioner, his or her term shall not be more than six years in aggregate as Election Commissioner and Chief Election Commissioner | Members not eligible for reappointment but can become Chairman of UPSC | Members not eligible for reappointment but can become Chairman of UPSC or SPSC |
Expenses | Charged on the Consolidated Fund of India; salary equal to a Supreme Court Judge | Charged on the Consolidated Fund of India; salary equal to a Supreme Court Judge | Charged on the Consolidated Fund of India; salary determined by the President | Charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State; salary determined by the Governor |
Functions | Audits expenditures from the Consolidated and Contingency Funds of India and the States, along with public accounts; audits government transactions related to debt; issues reports to the President and Parliament; guides the Public Accounts Committee of Parliament, asked in UPSC 2012 | Determines boundaries based on the Delimitation Commission Act; election management including notifications, scrutiny of nominations and recognising political parties; conduct of elections, including cancelling polls due to irregularities and advising on disqualifications; publicity, including managing publicity rosters for political parties | Ensures merit-based recruitment; recommendations on civil service recruitment methods, candidate suitability and disciplinary matters; submits reports to the President, which are then presented to Parliament | Consulted by the Governor for state judicial service appointments; submits annual reports to the Governor for presentation to the state legislature |
Limitations | Secret Service expenditure limits the CAG's auditing role; the CAG has no authority over the issuance of money from the Consolidated Fund | Not applicable | Excluded from reservations, tribunal selections, and Group C and D services; temporary appointments; UPSC cannot select for temporary appointments exceeding one year | Excluded from reservations, tribunal selections, and Group C and D services; temporary appointments |
Removal | By the President on the basis of a resolution passed by both Houses of Parliament with a special majority, either on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity | The CEC is removed in the procedure similar to that of a Supreme Court Judge; the other Election Commissioners are removed on the recommendation made by the CEC | By the President on grounds of insolvency, infirmity or misbehaviour, with the Supreme Court's advice binding | By the President on grounds of insolvency, infirmity or misbehaviour, with the Supreme Court's advice binding |
One note to the table: the Election Commission resolves disputes relating to splits and mergers of recognised political parties, asked in UPSC 2017. Another quiet change sits behind the CAG's work: in 1976, India split the CAG's role. While the CAG remained the nation's chief auditor for both the Union and the states, the Union's accounting work moved to the Controller General of Accounts, yet the CAG still keeps the accounts for many states, wearing two hats even today.
Joint State Public Service Commission
A Joint State Public Service Commission (JSPSC) is created by Parliament on the request of state legislatures. Its origin lies in the Government of India Act, 1935, and its status is statutory, not constitutional. The Chairman and members are appointed by the President, and their conditions of service are determined by the President. They resign to the President, serve for six years or until the age of 62 years, and the Commission reports annually to the governors of the states concerned.
Attorney General and Advocate General compared
Category | Attorney General | Advocate General |
|---|---|---|
Articles and Acts | Article 76, Part V. Part of the Union Executive. Highest law officer in the country. | Article 165, Part VI. Part of the State Executive. Highest law officer in the state. |
Head | Attorney General | Advocate General |
Members | Single member | One per State |
Appointment | President | Governor |
Qualification | Qualified to be a Judge of the Supreme Court: citizen of India; must have been a judge of some High Court for 5 years, or an advocate of some High Court for 10 years, or an eminent jurist in the opinion of the President | Qualified to be a Judge of a High Court: citizen of India; must have been in the judicial service of the State for 10 years, or an advocate of a High Court for 10 years |
Term | Pleasure of the President | Pleasure of the Governor |
Resign to | President, asked in UPSC 2022 | Governor |
Renewal | Allowed | Allowed |
Future employment | Allowed | Allowed |
Tenure extension | Allowed | Allowed |
Expenses | Not charged on the Consolidated Fund of India | Not charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State |
Independence | Cannot be varied | Cannot be varied |
Functions | Chief legal advisor to the Union | Chief legal advisor to the state |
Limitations | Can practise law, but not against the Government of India | Can practise law, but not against the State Government |
Removal | Resignation to the President. Conventionally, he or she resigns when the government, the Council of Ministers, resigns or is replaced, asked in UPSC 2022 | Resignation to the Governor. Conventionally, he or she resigns when the government, the Council of Ministers, resigns or is replaced |
The Attorney General and the Advocate General both possess the right to participate in the proceedings of the legislature, or their committees of which they are a member. However, they do not enjoy the right to vote in such proceedings. They also enjoy the privileges and immunities available to members of legislatures, asked in UPSC 2013. Unlike the Attorney General, the Solicitor General and Additional Solicitors General are not constitutional offices. They exist by statute and practice, created simply to assist the Attorney General, powerful advocates of the Union yet written nowhere in the Constitution.
National Commissions for SCs, STs and BCs
Category | National Commission for SCs (NCSC) | National Commission for STs (NCST) | National Commission for BCs (NCBC) |
|---|---|---|---|
Articles and Acts | Article 338, Part XVI | Article 338A, Part XVI | Article 338B, Part XVI |
Background | Originally Article 338 provided for Special Officers for SCs and STs. 1978: non-statutory multi-member commission for SCs and STs through a resolution. 1987: commission renamed as National Commission for SCs and STs through a resolution. 65th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1990: multi-member National Commission for SCs and STs with constitutional status. 89th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2003: single commission separated into NCSC (Article 338) and NCST (Article 338A). The separate commissions came into existence in 2004. | Same history as NCSC until the 89th Amendment of 2003 separated them; the separate National Commission for STs came into existence in 2004. | Originally NCBC was set up in 1993 as a statutory body according to the Mandal case judgement of the Supreme Court (1992). 102nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2018: accorded constitutional status with the insertion of new Article 338B, asked in UPSC 2023. |
Head and members | Chair plus Vice-Chair plus 3 members | Chair plus Vice-Chair plus 3 members | Chair and Vice-Chair, 5 members |
Appointment | President | President | President |
Qualification | Not specified | Not specified | Not specified |
Term | 3 years | 3 years | 3 years, not specified in the Constitution but in the NCBC Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson and Members (Conditions of Service and Tenure) Rules, 2018 |
Removal | By the President | By the President | By the President |
Renewal | Not allowed | Not allowed | Not allowed |
Future employment | Not allowed | Not allowed | Not allowed |
Tenure extension | Not allowed | Not allowed | Not allowed |
Expenses | Consolidated Fund of India | Consolidated Fund of India | Consolidated Fund of India |
Independence | Cannot be varied | Cannot be varied | Cannot be varied |
Functions | Safeguards the rights of SCs | Safeguards the rights of STs | Safeguards the rights of OBCs |
Other aspects | Power of a civil court in certain matters; power to regulate its own procedure; discharges similar functions regarding the Anglo-Indian Community; till 2018, it was also required to discharge similar functions with regard to OBCs, and was relieved by the creation of NCBC (Article 338B) | Power of a civil court in certain matters; power to regulate its own procedure; measures for the implementation of the PESA Act, 1996; reduce and eliminate the shifting cultivation practice by tribals; improve relief and rehabilitation measures; prevent alienation of tribal people; conferring ownership rights in respect of minor forest produce | Power of a civil court in certain matters; power to regulate its own procedure; participate and advise on the socio-economic development of Socially and Educationally Backward Classes |
Finance Commission, GST Council and Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities
Category | Finance Commission, asked in UPSC 2011 | GST Council | Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities |
|---|---|---|---|
Article and Act | Article 280, Part XII | Article 279A, Part XII | Article 350B, Part XVII |
Establishment | Quasi-judicial body, created every 5 years | 101st Constitutional Amendment Act (2016) | 7th Constitutional Amendment Act (1956) |
Head | Chairman | Union Finance Minister | Commissioner for Linguistic Minorities |
Members | Chairman plus 4 members | State Finance Ministers and Union Minister of State for Finance | Assistant Commissioners in regional offices |
Appointment | By the President | By Presidential Order | By the President |
Term | 5 years | Not applicable | Not specified |
Resign to | The President | Not applicable | Not specified |
Renewal | Eligible for reappointment | Not applicable | Not specified |
Future employment | Not allowed | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Expenses | Not specified in the table | State and Central Government | Central Government |
Independence | Cannot be varied | Not applicable | Ministry of Minority Affairs |
Quorum | Not applicable | 50 percent of total members | Not applicable |
Decision-making | Advisory capacity only | Three-fourths majority of members present and voting | Not applicable |
Vote weight | Not applicable | Centre: one-third; States: two-thirds | Not applicable |
Functions | Allocation of tax proceeds between the Centre and States; recommends principles for grants to States from the Consolidated Fund of India; suggests measures to augment a State's Consolidated Fund based on State Finance Commission recommendations; advises on financial issues referred by the President | Recommendations on taxes, cesses and surcharges that should be merged into GST; proposing special rates to raise additional resources during natural calamities or disasters; making special provisions for certain north-eastern and hilly states, including Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Jammu and Kashmir and others | Safeguards the rights of linguistic minorities |
Reporting | Submits report to the President | Recommendations to the Centre and States | Submits reports to the President through the Union Minority Affairs Minister |
Limitations | Recommendations are advisory | Not applicable | Not specified |
Removal | By the President | Not applicable | Not specified |
Location of headquarters | Not specified | New Delhi | New Delhi, with regional offices in Belgaum, Chennai and Kolkata |
Special provisions | Constitutionally mandated | Special provisions for hilly and north-eastern states | Not applicable |
Other aspects | Balances fiscal federalism | Permanent invitee: Chairperson of the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs, CBIC, non-voting | Oversees compliance with constitutional provisions for linguistic minorities |
Additional facts about the Finance Commission: the first Finance Commission's Chairperson in 1951 was K. C. Neogy, and the 15th Finance Commission's Chairperson in 2021 was N. K. Singh. The qualifications for members are fourfold: a judge of a High Court or one qualified to be appointed as one; a person who has specialised knowledge of finance and accounts of the government; a person who has wide experience in financial matters and in administration; and a person who has special knowledge of economics. The criteria for devolution of the 15th Finance Commission, asked in UPSC 2023, were 12.5 percent weightage to demographic performance, 45 percent to income, 15 percent each to population and area, 10 percent to forest and ecology, and 2.5 percent to tax and fiscal efforts.
Appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners
Under the previous system, the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners were appointed by the President on the Central Government's recommendation. In Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023), the Supreme Court recommended an independent Selection Committee for the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners, based on the Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990) and the Law Commission's 255th Report (2015), comprising the Prime Minister, the Chief Justice of India, and the Leader of the Opposition, or the largest opposition party in the Lok Sabha.
The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service, and Term of Office) Act, 2023 replaces the Election Commission Act (1991), covering appointments, salaries and dismissal procedures. Under it, the President appoints the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners based on a three-member Selection Committee of the Prime Minister, a Union Minister, and the Leader of the Opposition. A Search Committee headed by the Cabinet Secretary suggests five candidates to the Selection Committee, which can consider other names.
A related reform belongs here too. The Supreme Court, in Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India (2024), struck down the entire Electoral Bond Scheme as unconstitutional. The judgment was a major reform on the ground of the voter's right to know the source of political funding, as part of the Right to Information under Article 19(1)(a).
Prelims practice
0 of 5 answered · 0 correct
Consider the following statements: 1. The term of the Chairman of the Union Public Service Commission is six years or till the age of 65 years. 2. The term of the Chairman of a State Public Service Commission is six years or till the age of 62 years. 3. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India can be removed only by the President on a resolution of both Houses of Parliament with a special majority. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
The National Commission for Backward Classes was accorded constitutional status by which amendment?
Who appoints the Attorney General of India, and under which Article?
What was the weightage given to income tax devolution criteria by the 15th Finance Commission?
Under the 2023 Act, the Selection Committee for appointing the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners consists of the Prime Minister, a Union Minister and which third member?
Frequently asked questions
Is the Joint State Public Service Commission a constitutional body?
No. A Joint State Public Service Commission is statutory, not constitutional. It is created by Parliament on the request of state legislatures, its Chairman and members are appointed by the President, and they serve six years or until the age of 62.
Can the Attorney General vote in Parliament?
No. The Attorney General and the Advocate General can participate in the proceedings of the legislature or its committees of which they are members, and they enjoy the privileges and immunities of members, but they do not have the right to vote.
When did the separate National Commissions for SCs and STs come into existence?
The 89th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2003 separated the single commission into the National Commission for Scheduled Castes under Article 338 and the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes under Article 338A, and the separate commissions came into existence in 2004.
What is the GST Council's voting arrangement?
The GST Council decides by a three-fourths majority of members present and voting. The Centre holds one-third of the vote weight and the states hold two-thirds, and the quorum is 50 percent of total members.
Who selects the Chief Election Commissioner under the 2023 Act?
The President appoints the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners on the recommendation of a three-member Selection Committee comprising the Prime Minister, a Union Minister and the Leader of the Opposition, with a Search Committee headed by the Cabinet Secretary suggesting five candidates.
What did the Supreme Court decide on electoral bonds in 2024?
In Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India (2024), the Supreme Court struck down the entire Electoral Bond Scheme as unconstitutional, holding that the voter's right to know the source of political funding is part of the Right to Information under Article 19(1)(a).