Polity and Governance
#1Independence of the Election Commission
Context
The independence of the Election Commission of India returned to public debate in October, triggered by two separate developments around the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls. In Goa, the Commission told the Bombay High Court that a name missing from the draft revision roll had not been deleted at all, because the roll was being prepared afresh and there was no earlier roll from which a name could be struck off.
More about the news
The case concerned six members of one family whose names vanished after their Form 8 applications for a change of address were rejected. The bench asked why Form 8 was not accepted during the revision; the Commission replied that with no reference roll in existence mid-revision, a correction form had nothing to correct. It said non-inclusion in the draft could be cured by filing Form 6, the application used by new voters, during the claims and objections window. The verdict was reserved.
In parallel, former Supreme Court judge Justice Kurian Joseph argued at a Kochi discussion that the appointment and service conditions of the Election Commission should be written into the Constitution itself rather than left to Parliament, saying a constitutional provision would protect the body's integrity more strongly than any statute.
The legal frame is familiar. Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the Commission. Under the 2023 law, the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners are chosen by a committee of the Prime Minister, a Union Cabinet minister and the Leader of the Opposition, and the Chief Election Commissioner can be removed only in the manner of a Supreme Court judge.
Significance
The debate now is whether that statutory shield is enough, or whether the Supreme Court's Anoop Baranwal ruling of 2023, which first proposed an independent selection panel, points toward constitutional entrenchment as the unfinished step.
Concerns
He warned of a perception that high institutions neither bark nor bite, and a former Kerala High Court judge at the same forum said roll deletions during the revision violated natural justice.
| Prelims |
|
|---|---|
| Mains | Mains angle: GS-2 (constitutional bodies and electoral integrity) — whether statutory safeguards under the 2023 Act are enough for the Election Commission's independence, or whether constitutional entrenchment, as argued after Anoop Baranwal, is the necessary next step. |