Skip to content

Friday, 20 November 2026 · New Delhi

Polity· Prelims · GS-II

Public Services: Articles 308 to 312 and the Making of the All-India Services

The Constitution gives the government its servants and then protects them from the government. Articles 308 to 312 set the rules: who recruits, who holds office at pleasure, what safeguards a civil servant gets before dismissal, and how new All-India Services are born.

By Sujit20 November 2026Updated 20 November 202612 min readbasic
Public Services: Articles 308 to 312 and the Making of the All-India Services | UPSC

The Constitution gives the government its servants, and then protects them from the government. Part XIV runs from Article 308 to Article 323, and its first five articles, 308 to 312, set the rules of the service itself: who recruits, who holds office at pleasure, what safeguards a civil servant gets before dismissal, and how a new All-India Service is born.

Article 308: the interpretation clause that quietly expired

Article 308 does only one thing: it defines the expression State for the purposes of Part XIV. The original text said that in Part XIV, State does not include the State of Jammu and Kashmir. The reason was history: Jammu and Kashmir enjoyed special autonomy under Article 370 and had its own Constitution, so its state civil services and administrative rules were kept separate from the rest of India.

That exclusion is now spent. The Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 2019 made all provisions of the Constitution applicable to Jammu and Kashmir, and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019 reorganised the State into two Union Territories. Part XIV now applies uniformly across India, and the All India Services (Cadre) Rules apply to the new Union Territories just as they do elsewhere. Article 308 creates no rights and no institutions; it is a gateway provision, fixing the territory over which the machinery of the articles that follow operates.

Article 309: who makes the service rules

Article 309 answers the first practical question: who regulates recruitment and conditions of service for persons serving the Union or a State? The answer is the legislature. Parliament regulates the Union services and a State Legislature regulates the services of the State. Until the legislature passes a law, the President, for the Union, or the Governor, for a State, may make rules on the subject, and those rules have the force of law.

The hierarchy matters. Executive rules under the proviso are subject to any Act of the legislature and to the Constitution itself, including the Fundamental Rights. Conditions of service is a wide phrase: it covers pay, seniority, promotion, leave, discipline and pension. Two further rules complete the picture. The government may amend service rules retrospectively, but it cannot impair rights that have already accrued or vested. And the relationship between the government and its servants is statutory, not contractual, so executive instructions cannot override rules made under Article 309.

Article 310: the doctrine of pleasure, and its limits

Article 310 states the doctrine of pleasure, borrowed from British common law: civil and defence personnel hold office during the pleasure of the Crown. In India the pleasure belongs to the President for Union servants and to the Governor for State servants, so the executive can in theory dismiss a civil servant at any time.

Unlike in Britain, the doctrine is not absolute in India. It is heavily restricted by the safeguards in Article 311, which require a proper inquiry and a hearing before dismissal. Certain high offices are expressly outside the doctrine altogether: the President or Governor cannot dismiss them at will. They include judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts, the Comptroller and Auditor-General, the Chief Election Commissioner, and the chairmen and members of the Union and State Public Service Commissions. And the pleasure itself is not arbitrary: the Supreme Court has held that it must be exercised in public policy and public interest, not with malafide intent, and courts can strike down an arbitrary dismissal. The leading authority is the Tulsiram Patel case of 1985.

Article 311: the two safeguards, and the three exceptions

Article 311 is the counterweight to Article 310. It applies only to civil servants of the Union, a State or an All-India Service; it does not apply to defence personnel. It gives two safeguards. First, the appointing-authority rule in clause (1): a civil servant cannot be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to the one that appointed him. Second, the right to inquiry in clause (2): no dismissal, removal or reduction in rank can occur without a proper inquiry, in which the employee is informed of the charges and given a reasonable opportunity of being heard, in accordance with the principles of natural justice.

The inquiry can be bypassed, and the employee summarily dismissed, in three cases only: where the dismissal follows conduct that led to conviction on a criminal charge; where the empowered authority records in writing that it is not reasonably practicable to hold an inquiry, for instance because witnesses are being intimidated; and where the President or the Governor is satisfied that holding an inquiry is not expedient in the interest of the security of the State.

Two amendments of the story matter. The 42nd Amendment of 1976 removed the employee’s right to a second opportunity, to make a representation against the specific penalty proposed; the defence is now confined to the inquiry stage. And in Tulsiram Patel (1985), the Supreme Court held that bypassing the inquiry under the three exceptions is itself subject to judicial review, so a dismissal founded on malafide or arbitrary reasons can be struck down. The safeguards generally do not cover purely temporary or contractual staff, unless the termination order is expressly penal or stigmatising in nature.

Article 312: how a new All-India Service is born

Article 312 is the only route to a new All-India Service, common to the Union and the States. Parliament can create one only if the Rajya Sabha first passes a resolution declaring it necessary in the national interest, by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting. Giving the initiative to the Council of States is deliberate: it ensures the States have a voice before central administrative machinery is expanded.

The Indian Administrative Service and the Indian Police Service were deemed to be created under this article at the commencement of the Constitution. The Indian Forest Service was created later, in 1966, using this route. Article 312 also permits the creation of an All-India Judicial Service, but it cannot include posts below the rank of District Judge, and it remains unimplemented for want of consensus among the States and the High Courts.

The machinery is the All-India Services Act, 1951, which regulates recruitment and conditions of service and empowers the Central Government to frame rules after consulting the State Governments. One procedural curiosity: a law creating the All-India Judicial Service may amend Part VI, on subordinate courts, to facilitate it, and that amendment is not treated as a constitutional amendment under Article 368.

The footnotes: Articles 312A, 313 and 314

Article 312A, added by the 28th Amendment of 1972, gives Parliament the power to vary or revoke the conditions of service of persons who belonged to the former Indian Civil Service. Article 313 is transitional: pre-Constitution service laws continue until they are formally replaced. Article 314 is gone: it was repealed by the same 28th Amendment, removing the special protections the Constitution had originally given to officers of the Indian Civil Service.

Articles 308 to 314 at a glance

The six provisions, in the order the Constitution states them:

  • Article 308: Interpretation; defines “State” for Part XIV; the Jammu and Kashmir exclusion is now redundant.
  • Article 309: Recruitment and conditions of service; Parliament or the State Legislature by law, the President or Governor by rules until then.
  • Article 310: Doctrine of pleasure; Union servants hold office during the President’s pleasure, State servants during the Governor’s.
  • Article 311: Safeguards against dismissal, removal or reduction in rank; inquiry and hearing, with three exceptions.
  • Article 312: New All-India Services; Rajya Sabha resolution by two-thirds majority; includes the All-India Judicial Service.
  • Articles 312A, 313 and 314: Parliament’s power to vary ICS conditions; transitional continuance; Article 314 repealed by the 28th Amendment, 1972.

Prelims practice

Q1Prelims practice
  • Which article defines the expression “State” for the purposes of Part XIV of the Constitution?

(a) Article 308 (b) Article 309 (c) Article 310 (d) Article 311

Q2Prelims practice

Consider the following statements about Article 309:

  1. 1. Rules made by the President or the Governor under the proviso to Article 309 have the force of law.
  2. 2. Executive instructions can override rules made under Article 309.
  3. 3. “Conditions of service” includes pay, seniority, promotion, leave, discipline and pension.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Q3Prelims practice
  • The doctrine of pleasure under Article 310 does NOT apply to

(a) a member of the Union Public Service Commission (b) a civil servant of the Union (c) a member of the defence services (d) a member of an All-India Service

Q4Prelims practice

Consider the following statements about Article 311:

  1. 1. A civil servant cannot be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to the one that appointed him.
  2. 2. An inquiry can be dispensed with if the President or the Governor is satisfied that it is not expedient in the interest of the security of the State.
  3. 3. Article 311 applies to defence personnel.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Q5Prelims practice
  • A new All-India Service can be created only if

(a) the Lok Sabha passes a resolution by simple majority (b) the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution by a two-thirds majority of members present and voting (c) the President issues an order (d) Parliament amends the Constitution under Article 368

Answer key

  • Q1 (a): Article 308 defines “State” for Part XIV.
  • Q2 (b): Statements 1 and 3 are correct. Executive instructions cannot override Article 309 rules; the service relationship is statutory, not contractual.
  • Q3 (a): The chairmen and members of the Public Service Commissions are expressly outside the doctrine of pleasure, as are Supreme Court and High Court judges, the CAG and the CEC.
  • Q4 (b): Statements 1 and 2 are correct. Article 311 does not apply to defence personnel.
  • Q5 (b): Article 312 requires a Rajya Sabha resolution, by not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting, declaring the service necessary in the national interest.

Mains Practice question

Q. “The doctrine of pleasure in India is not absolute.” Discuss this statement with reference to Articles 310 and 311. (150 words)

  • Open with the origin: the doctrine comes from British common law, and Article 310 vests the pleasure in the President and the Governors.
  • Then the limits: Article 311’s inquiry and hearing, the express exclusion of judges, the CAG, the CEC and PSC members, and judicial review of arbitrary pleasure in Tulsiram Patel.
  • Close: the balance the two articles strike between executive control and security of tenure.

Q. Examine the safeguards available to a civil servant against dismissal, removal or reduction in rank under Article 311, and the circumstances in which they can be bypassed. (250 words)

  • The two safeguards: the appointing-authority rule in clause (1) and the inquiry with reasonable opportunity of being heard in clause (2).
  • The three exceptions: criminal conviction, recorded impracticability, and the security of the State.
  • The qualifiers: the 42nd Amendment’s removal of the second opportunity, and judicial review of the bypass in Tulsiram Patel (1985).
  • The boundary: the safeguards cover civil servants, not defence personnel, and generally not purely temporary staff.

Frequently asked questions

What is the doctrine of pleasure?

It is the rule in Article 310 that civil and defence servants hold office during the pleasure of the President, for Union servants, or the Governor, for State servants. In India it is not absolute: Article 311 requires an inquiry and a hearing before dismissal, and certain offices are entirely outside it.

Can a civil servant be dismissed without an inquiry?

Only in the three cases in the provisos to Article 311(2): dismissal on conduct that led to a criminal conviction; where the authority records in writing that an inquiry is not reasonably practicable; or where the President or Governor is satisfied that an inquiry is not expedient in the interest of the security of the State.

Who can create a new All-India Service?

Parliament, and only after the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution by a two-thirds majority of members present and voting declaring the service necessary in the national interest. The Indian Forest Service was created this way in 1966.

What is the All-India Judicial Service, and why does it not exist?

Article 312 permits Parliament to create an All-India Judicial Service, but it cannot include posts below the rank of District Judge. It has never been created, for want of consensus among the States and the High Courts.

Does Article 311 protect temporary government employees?

Generally no. The safeguards are for civil servants holding a substantive post. Purely temporary or contractual staff fall outside them, unless the termination order is expressly penal or stigmatising.

Why does Article 308 still mention Jammu and Kashmir?

It is a spent exclusion. The original text kept Jammu and Kashmir outside Part XIV because of its special autonomy under Article 370. The 2019 Order applying the whole Constitution to Jammu and Kashmir, and the Reorganisation Act that followed, made the exclusion redundant.

polityindian-constitutionupsc-prelimsgs-paper-2explained

Related articles

Continue your preparation with more on this topic.

Special provisions for certain classes: Articles 330 to 342A, seats, services and commissions | UPSCPolitySpecial provisions for certain classes: Articles 330 to 342A, seats, services and commissionsThe Constitution reserves seats, protects claims in services and creates commissions for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Anglo-Indians and Backward Classes. Articles 330 to 342A are the full map, from reservation in legislatures to the lists only Parliament can change.The Government as owner, trader and litigant: Articles 294 to 300 and 361 | UPSCPolityThe Government as owner, trader and litigant: Articles 294 to 300 and 361The Union and the States own property, run businesses, sign contracts and get sued. Articles 294 to 300 and 361 set the rules: what the government inherited, what it owns offshore, how its contracts bind it, and why the President and Governors cannot be sued like everyone else.Uttar Pradesh Cabinet: Chief Minister, Deputy Chief Ministers and the Full Council of Ministers | UPSCPolityUttar Pradesh Cabinet: Chief Minister, Deputy Chief Ministers and the Full Council of MinistersUttar Pradesh Council of Ministers as of November 2026: Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, 2 Deputy Chief Ministers, 20 Cabinet Ministers, 16 Ministers of State with independent charge and 21 Ministers of State, with every portfolio.Union Cabinet: Council of Ministers, Portfolios and the 15 Percent Cap | UPSCPolityUnion Cabinet: Council of Ministers, Portfolios and the 15 Percent CapThe Union Council of Ministers as of November 2026: Prime Minister Narendra Modi, 29 Cabinet Ministers, 5 Ministers of State with independent charge and 34 Ministers of State, with every portfolio and the constitutional rules that shape the Council.State Legislature: Assembly, Council, Money Bills and the State Budget | UPSCPolityState Legislature: Assembly, Council, Money Bills and the State BudgetEvery State has a Legislature, and six States have two Houses. This guide explains the Assembly and the Legislative Council, Articles 168 to 212, Money Bills, the State Budget, and the facts examiners test most often.Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, BNSS and BSA: India's new criminal codes, 2023 | UPSCPolityBharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, BNSS and BSA: India's new criminal codes, 2023On 1 July 2024 the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam replaced the IPC, the CrPC and the Indian Evidence Act. Structure, new provisions, timelines and exam facts for UPSC Prelims and GS-2.