Polity· Prelims · GS-II
The Government as owner, trader and litigant: Articles 294 to 300 and 361
The Union and the States own property, run businesses, sign contracts and get sued. Articles 294 to 300 and 361 set the rules: what the government inherited, what it owns offshore, how its contracts bind it, and why the President and Governors cannot be sued like everyone else.
The state is not only a law-maker. It owns property, runs businesses, signs contracts and gets sued. Part XII, on finance, property, contracts and suits, and Part XIX, on miscellaneous provisions, set the rules for the government in those roles. Articles 294 to 300 and 361 answer four questions: what the government inherited, what it owns, how it deals, and how far it can be taken to court.
What the government inherited: Articles 294 to 296
Article 294 deals with succession from the Dominion and the Provinces. The assets and liabilities of the Dominion of India and of the Governor’s Provinces immediately before the commencement of the Constitution passed to the Union and to the corresponding States. Article 295 does the same for the princely states: their pre-Constitution assets and liabilities passed to the Union or to the Part B States.
Article 296 covers property with no owner. Property that accrues by escheat, by lapse or as bona vacantia, that is, ownerless property, vests in the State if it is situated in a State, and in the Union in any other case, including a Union Territory.
Article 297: the sea belongs to the Union
Article 297 vests in the Union all lands, minerals and other things of value underlying the ocean within the territorial waters, on the continental shelf, and in the Exclusive Economic Zone. The point is a monopoly: a coastal State cannot claim ownership of offshore oil, gas or seabed minerals; they are held for Union purposes. Parliament specifies the limits of the territorial waters, the continental shelf, the Exclusive Economic Zone and other maritime zones by law, and the provision is operationalised by the Territorial Waters, Continental Shelf, Exclusive Economic Zone and Other Maritime Zones Act, 1976.
Article 298: the government as trader
Article 298 extends the executive power of the Union and of each State to carrying on any trade or business, and to the acquisition, holding and disposal of property, and to making contracts for any purpose. The Union’s power is subject to legislation by Parliament, and a State’s power is subject to legislation by the State Legislature, and by Parliament where the matter falls outside State legislative competence.
No separate legislative entry is needed: the government can enter a commercial business even without a specific entry in the Union or State Lists, subject to the Fundamental Rights, including Article 19(1)(g), and to statutory limits. Article 298 is the constitutional basis for government companies, commercial undertakings and the state’s property dealings generally.
Article 299: how the government signs
Article 299 lays down the form a government contract must take. All contracts made in the exercise of the executive power of the Union or of a State must be expressed to be made by the President or the Governor, executed on their behalf, and executed by such persons and in such manner as the President or Governor directs. Neither the President nor the Governor, nor the officer who executes the contract, is personally liable on it.
Compliance with Article 299(1) is mandatory. A contract that does not follow the form is generally unenforceable against the government, subject only to limited restitution principles under the Indian Contract Act. And no estoppel can help: the doctrine of promissory estoppel cannot be used to bypass the mandatory formalities of the article.
Article 300: suing and being sued
Article 300 gives the government its names in court. The Government of India sues and is sued as the Union of India, and a State Government sues and is sued in the name of the State. The liability is subject to laws made by Parliament or the State Legislature, and the article also carried over pending proceedings, substituting the Union and the States for the Dominion, the Provinces and the Indian States.
The courts draw one line that examiners love: between sovereign and non-sovereign functions. The state has often been held immune in tort for sovereign functions, and liable for the torts of its servants in non-sovereign or commercial functions. Parliament and the State Legislatures can enact laws defining the state’s liability in tort.
Article 361: the shield around the President and Governors
Article 361, in Part XIX, protects the President and the Governors personally. The President or a Governor is not answerable to any court for the exercise and performance of the powers and duties of office, or for any act done or purporting to be done in the exercise of those powers. No criminal proceedings can be instituted or continued against the President or a Governor in any court during the term of office, and no process for arrest or imprisonment can issue from any court during the term.
Civil proceedings are narrower still. Proceedings for personal acts, whether done before or during the term, require two months’ written notice, and no such proceedings can be instituted during the term. But the shield is personal, not institutional: it does not bar judicial review of the validity of government or executive actions, and the President’s conduct may be reviewed by a body appointed by either House of Parliament for investigating charges under Article 61, the impeachment provision.
Articles 294 to 300 and 361 at a glance
The provisions, in the order the Constitution states them:
- Article 294: Succession; assets and liabilities of the Dominion and the Governor’s Provinces pass to the Union and the corresponding States.
- Article 295: Succession; assets and liabilities of the Indian princely states pass to the Union or the Part B States.
- Article 296: Escheat, lapse and bona vacantia; ownerless property vests in the State, or in the Union if it is not situated in a State.
- Article 297: Maritime resources; lands, minerals and things of value in the territorial waters, continental shelf and Exclusive Economic Zone vest in the Union.
- Article 298: Power to carry on trade or business and to acquire, hold and dispose of property.
- Article 299: Government contracts; expressed in the name of the President or Governor, with no personal liability.
- Article 300: Suits and proceedings; the government sues and is sued as the Union of India or in the name of the State.
- Article 361: Protection of the President and Governors; no criminal proceedings during the term, civil suits only on two months’ notice.
Prelims practice
- Property accruing by escheat, lapse or as bona vacantia, if situated in a State, vests in the
(a) Union (b) State (c) President (d) Consolidated Fund of India
Consider the following statements about Article 297:
- 1. All minerals and things of value in the territorial waters and on the continental shelf vest in the Union.
- 2. All resources within the Exclusive Economic Zone vest in the Union.
- 3. Parliament specifies the limits of the territorial waters, the continental shelf and the Exclusive Economic Zone by law.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
- Contracts made in the exercise of the executive power of the Union must be expressed to be made by the
(a) Prime Minister (b) President (c) Cabinet Secretary (d) Attorney-General
Consider the following statements:
- 1. The Government of India sues and is sued in the name of the “Union of India”.
- 2. Criminal proceedings can be instituted against the President during the term of office.
- 3. Civil proceedings against a Governor for personal acts require two months’ written notice.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
- The constitutional basis for government companies and commercial undertakings is
(a) Article 298 (b) Article 299 (c) Article 300 (d) Article 301
Answer key
- Q1 (b): Under Article 296, ownerless property situated in a State vests in the State; it vests in the Union only if it is not situated in a State.
- Q2 (d): All three statements are correct. Article 297 vests maritime resources in the Union and leaves the limits of the zones to Parliament by law.
- Q3 (b): Article 299 requires Union contracts to be expressed in the name of the President, and State contracts in the name of the Governor.
- Q4 (b): Statements 1 and 3 are correct. No criminal proceedings can be instituted or continued against the President during the term of office.
- Q5 (a): Article 298 extends executive power to carrying on trade or business and acquiring, holding and disposing of property.
Mains Practice question
Q. Discuss the scope of the Union’s ownership of maritime resources under Article 297, and its significance for Centre-State relations. (150 words)
- The vesting: territorial waters, continental shelf and Exclusive Economic Zone, all in the Union.
- The limit-setting: Parliament fixes the zones by law, operationalised by the 1976 Act.
- The federal point: coastal States cannot claim offshore oil, gas or seabed minerals.
Q. Article 361 protects the President and the Governors, but not the governments they head. Examine the scope and limits of this immunity. (250 words)
- The shield: no answerability for official acts, no criminal proceedings and no arrest during the term, civil suits only on two months’ notice.
- The limit: immunity is personal; judicial review of government action survives, and the President’s conduct can be investigated under Article 61.
- The rationale: the head of state must be free from litigation while in office, without placing the executive above the Constitution.
Frequently asked questions
Can the government be sued?
Yes. Under Article 300 the Government of India sues and is sued as the Union of India, and a State Government sues and is sued in the name of the State, subject to laws made by Parliament or the State Legislature.
Who owns offshore oil and gas?
The Union. Article 297 vests all lands, minerals and things of value in the territorial waters, on the continental shelf and in the Exclusive Economic Zone in the Union, and coastal States cannot claim them.
What happens if a government contract is not made in the President’s name?
It is generally unenforceable against the government. Compliance with Article 299(1) is mandatory, and the doctrine of promissory estoppel cannot be used to get around the required form.
Can criminal proceedings be started against a Governor?
Not during the term of office. Article 361 bars the institution or continuance of criminal proceedings, and the issue of any process for arrest or imprisonment, against the President or a Governor while in office.
What is escheat?
Escheat is the vesting of property in the state when its owner dies without heirs or a will. Under Article 296, property accruing by escheat, lapse or as bona vacantia vests in the State where it is situated, and in the Union otherwise.
Does Article 361 protect the government’s decisions from the courts?
No. Article 361 protects the President and the Governors personally. It does not bar judicial review of the validity of government or executive actions.