Economy — Prelims· Prelims
National Income Accounting
GDP, GNP, NNP and national income, the three methods of calculation, factor cost versus market price, nominal versus real GDP, CPI, WPI, PPI, IIP and the limits of GDP as a measure of welfare.
Every number in the news about the Indian economy, the growth rate, the size of GDP, the inflation figure, traces back to one discipline: national income accounting. It is the system that measures what a country produces, what it earns, and what its people can spend, and prelims tests it every year, often with the same traps: GDP against GNP, market price against factor cost, nominal against real, and the CPI against the GDP deflator. This chapter walks through those ideas in the order the books present them, from the circular flow of income to the limits of GDP as a measure of welfare.
The subject itself is young. Macroeconomics emerged as a separate branch only after the British economist John Maynard Keynes published his celebrated book The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money in 1936, in response to the Great Depression of the 1930s. Before Keynes, the classical school believed that all labourers ready to work would find employment and all factories would work at full capacity. The Depression broke that belief, and Keynes answered by studying aggregate variables and the interrelationships among the different sectors of an economy.
Macroeconomics views an economy as households, firms, government and the external sector, all interacting in a circular flow. The rest of this chapter is the accounting of that flow: how production is valued, how the value is split into incomes, how prices change the picture, and what the numbers leave out.
The economic players
Four players move the money. Firms, private entrepreneurs, hire wage labour, use capital and land, and produce goods and services for profit. Government, the state, enforces laws, provides public infrastructure, runs schools and delivers public services, and may also undertake production and taxation. Households consist of individuals or groups that make consumption decisions, save and pay taxes, earning income through work in the form of wages, salaries or profits. The external sector trades with the rest of the world. Together they form the circular flow that the next sections measure.
Basic concepts: final goods, intermediate goods, stocks and flows
Final goods are products meant for ultimate consumption that do not undergo further transformation in the economic process, for example food, tea leaves and clothing. Final goods divide into consumption goods, goods consumed directly, and capital goods, durable goods used in production. Intermediate goods are products used by producers as inputs in the production of other commodities, such as steel sheets used for making automobiles and copper used for making utensils. Only final goods are counted in GDP, because the value of final goods already includes the value of all the inputs consumed in their production; counting intermediates too would double-count.
A few more distinctions keep the accounting clean. Consumption goods are goods consumed as and when purchased by the ultimate consumer, such as food, clothing and services like recreation. Consumer durables are meant for consumption but do not get used up in a short term, they have a long life and undergo normal wear and tear, for example a television or a radio. Capital goods are goods of durable character used to facilitate production and to transform other goods, but they are not themselves transformed, for example machinery and implements.
Stocks are assets or goods existing at a specific point in time, while flows represent quantities over a period. Capital goods such as machinery are stocks, while changes in capital goods over time are flows. Salary and profit are flow variables, defined over a period of time, while buildings or machines in a factory are stock variables, defined at a point in time. Inventory, a stock variable, is the stock of unsold finished goods, semi-finished goods or raw materials which a firm carries from one year to the next.
Money is used as a common measuring rod to quantify the total value of final goods and services produced in an economy, allowing the monetary value of different goods and services to be aggregated into one number.
Gross investment is the total expenditure made by businesses, governments and households on acquiring or producing new capital assets within a specific period, including capital goods and infrastructure like machinery, buildings, roads and bridges. It is that part of final output that comprises capital goods, and economic growth generally occurs in a country if there is capital formation there. Depreciation is an annual allowance for the wear and tear of capital goods over their useful life, the deduction made from gross investment as capital equipment is used through the year. Net investment is gross investment minus depreciation, showing how much new capital is being added after accounting for wear and tear.
Two ratios describe how efficiently capital turns into output. The capital output ratio is the amount of capital needed to produce one unit of output, and it depends on technological progress and the prices of capital goods and machinery. In India, a high capital ratio is among the reasons for subdued growth rates: despite being a high saving economy, capital formation may not result in a significant increase in output due to a high capital to output ratio. The incremental capital output ratio (ICOR) is the additional unit of capital or investment needed to produce an additional unit of output, and a higher ICOR means a country production is less efficient.
Physical capital and intangible capital
Physical capital refers to the tangible, man-made assets used in the production process, tools, machinery, buildings and raw materials that enhance productivity. The substitution of steel for wooden ploughs in agricultural production is an example of capital-augmenting technological progress. Physical capital divides into two types.
Fixed capital: assets that can be used repeatedly in the production process over a long period, such as machines, tools, buildings, vehicles and computers. These are not consumed or exhausted during production but provide long-term value.
Working capital: resources used up in the production process that need to be replenished regularly, such as raw materials, money in hand, fuel and intermediate goods. These are directly consumed in production or for short-term operational requirements.
Intangible capital covers investments that are not physical in nature, such as patents, trademarks, copyrights and human capital. Brand recognition, intellectual property and a mailing list of clients have no physical form, but they can generate value for a business by enhancing its reputation, innovation and customer loyalty, and they are often associated with higher productivity and growth in companies, sectors and economies.
The circular flow of income
The circular flow of income connects production and consumption. Firms pay income to the factors of production, land, labour, capital and entrepreneurship, which enables individuals to purchase goods and services, and the production process generates factor payments, wages, profits, rents and interest, which create purchasing power for consumers.
In the simplest model there is no government, no external trade and no saving. Households receive income from firms for their productive activities, and there are four types of contributions: labour earns a wage, capital earns interest, entrepreneurship earns profit, and natural resources earn rent. Households spend their entire income on goods and services produced by domestic firms, so the entire income of the economy comes back to the producers in the form of sales revenue, and firms use this revenue to pay for factor services again, and the loop continues.
The full economy adds leakages and injections. Households save part of income, pay taxes to the government, and buy imports; firms invest, the government spends, and exports bring income in. In the diagram the flows are: investment (I) as spending on goods and services, savings (S) leaking out of households, government spending (G) flowing in, taxes (T) flowing to government, exports (X) and imports (M), with wages, rent, interest and profit flowing from firms to households in return for the factors of production.
Public spending carries a multiplier, and the Economic Survey 2024-25 estimates the capital expenditure (capex) multiplier at around 2, significantly higher than the revenue expenditure multiplier, estimated at merely 0.9, which highlights the effectiveness of public capital expenditure in stimulating economic growth.
GDP and the three methods of calculation
National income accounting is the method used to measure and analyse a country overall economic activity, the total income generated within an economy, the value of its production, and how resources are allocated. Its two main indicators are Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and National Income (NI).
GDP is the total market value of all final goods and services produced within a country borders over a specific period, usually a year. It includes output by both domestic and foreign companies operating within the country. National Income represents the total income earned by residents and businesses of a country, regardless of where they operate. Unlike GDP, national income excludes the income earned by foreign companies within the country borders but includes income earned abroad by domestic entities.
An example makes the difference plain. If an American company operates in India and generates revenue of Rs 500 crore, this revenue is part of India GDP because it is produced within India, but it is not included in India national income because the earnings belong to a foreign entity. Conversely, if an Indian company operates in the USA and earns Rs 300 crore, this revenue is included in India national income but not in India GDP because it was produced outside India.
Three methods calculate GDP, and they must agree, because the value of what is produced equals the value of what is spent on it, which equals the incomes earned in producing it.
Product or value added method: GDP is the sum of the value added by all firms in the economy. Each firm value added is the difference between the value of its output and the value of its intermediate goods. A farmer produces wheat worth Rs 100, and a baker uses Rs 50 worth of this wheat to produce bread worth Rs 200. The value added by the farmer is Rs 100, and by the baker is Rs 150, so gross value added is Rs 250. Formula: GDP equals the sum of value added of all firms.
Expenditure method: GDP is total spending in the economy, consumption (C), investment (I), government spending (G), and net exports (X minus M). If consumers spend Rs 500 on domestic goods, firms invest Rs 200, the government spends Rs 300, exports are Rs 150 and imports are Rs 50, then GDP equals C + I + G + (X minus M), which is 500 + 200 + 300 + (150 minus 50), equal to Rs 1,100.
Income method: GDP is the sum of all incomes earned by residents and businesses, wages, interest, profits and rent. Formula: GDP equals the sum of wages plus profits plus interest plus rent.
In the product method, the aggregate value of goods and services produced by all firms is the gross value added (GVA). If depreciation is reduced from GVA to account for normal wear and tear of capital, it becomes net value added (NVA). After adjusting GVA for relevant product taxes and subsidies, GDP is obtained. The expenditure method adds final consumption expenditure by households, final investment expenditure by firms, government expenditure on final goods and services, and export revenues. The income method works because revenues earned by firms must be distributed among the factors of production as salaries, wages, profits, interest earnings and rents.
In India, the most highlighted measure of national income had long been GDP at factor cost, and the Central Statistics Office (CSO) reported GDP at factor cost and at market prices. In its revision in January 2015, the CSO replaced GDP at factor cost with GVA at basic prices, and GDP at market prices, now called simply GDP, became the most highlighted measure.
Prices: factor cost, basic price and market price
The same output can be valued at three prices, and prelims loves the conversions. Factor cost (FC) is the cost of production excluding taxes and subsidies, representing the income received by producers, and it includes wages, rent, interest and profits. Basic price includes factor cost plus production taxes, like property taxes on factories, minus production subsidies, such as government assistance for factory operations. If a factory factor cost is Rs 200 crore, with Rs 10 crore in production taxes and Rs 5 crore in subsidies, the basic price is 200 + 10 minus 5, equal to Rs 205 crore.
Market price (MP) includes basic price plus product taxes, like VAT or sales tax, minus product subsidies, reflecting the final price consumers pay. If a good basic price is Rs 100, with Rs 10 in product taxes and Rs 3 in subsidies, the market price is 100 + 10 minus 3, equal to Rs 107. Formula: market price equals basic price plus product taxes minus product subsidies.
The two kinds of taxes are different. Net production taxes are production taxes minus production subsidies, paid or received in relation to production and independent of the volume of production, such as land revenues and registration fees. Net product taxes are product taxes minus product subsidies, paid or received per unit of product, such as excise tax, service tax, and export and import duties. So GVA at basic price equals GVA at factor cost plus net production taxes, and GVA at market price equals GVA at basic price plus net product taxes.
The measures follow from these prices. GDP at factor cost is the total value of goods and services produced measured at factor cost. GDP at market prices equals GDP at factor cost plus production taxes plus product taxes minus production subsidies minus product subsidies. NDP at factor cost is GDP at factor cost minus depreciation, and NDP at market prices is GDP at market prices minus depreciation.
GNP, NNP, national income and personal income
Gross National Product (GNP) is the total market value of all final goods and services created by the citizens of a nation, usually over a year, both inside and outside the domestic territory. It excludes money made by foreign nationals inside the country and includes income earned by citizens abroad, so GNP equals GDP plus net factor income from abroad (NFIA), where NFIA is factor income earned by domestic factors employed in the rest of the world minus factor income earned by foreign factors employed in the domestic economy. A closed economy is an economy in which neither exports nor imports take place.
Net National Product (NNP) is GNP minus depreciation, because depreciation does not contribute to anyone income, so it is deducted to obtain a more accurate measure of income.
National Income (NI) is NNP at factor cost. Market prices include indirect taxes, which accrue to the government, so indirect taxes must be deducted from NNP at market prices, and subsidies granted by the government must be added back, for example petrol is heavily taxed in India whereas cooking gas is subsidised. So NI equals NNP at market prices minus net indirect taxes, where net indirect taxes are indirect taxes minus subsidies, and it represents the income that accrues to the factors of production within the country.
Personal Income (PI) is the income received by households from national income. It is calculated by deducting undistributed profits, corporate tax and net interest payments made by households, and adding transfer payments received from the government and firms. Undistributed profits are the part of profit earned by firms and government enterprises that is not distributed among the factors of production. Transfer payments such as pensions, scholarships and prizes are added. Formula: PI equals NI minus undistributed profits minus net interest payments made by households minus corporate tax plus transfer payments to households.
Personal Disposable Income (PDI) is the income available to households after deducting personal tax payments such as income tax and non-tax payments such as fines from personal income, the income households have at their disposal for consumption or savings.
Two more aggregates complete the picture. National Disposable Income is net national product at market prices plus other current transfers from the rest of the world, such as gifts and aid, and it gives an idea of the maximum amount of goods and services the domestic economy has at its disposal. Private income is the total of all factor and transfer incomes that the private sector, households and corporations, receives from all sources, within and outside the country: factor income from net domestic product accruing to the private sector, plus national debt interest, plus net factor income from abroad, plus current transfers from government, plus other net transfers from the rest of the world.
The chain from GDP to disposable income runs like this: GDP, plus net factor income from abroad, gives GNP; minus depreciation gives NNP at market prices; minus indirect taxes plus subsidies gives national income, which is NNP at factor cost; minus undistributed profits, net interest payments by households and corporate tax, plus transfers to households, gives personal income; minus personal tax payments and non-tax payments gives personal disposable income.
Nominal GDP, real GDP and the GDP deflator
Nominal GDP is the total value of goods and services produced in an economy at current market prices, and it does not account for changes in prices over time. Suppose a country only produces bread. In the year 2000 it produced 100 units of bread at Rs 10 per bread, so GDP at current prices was Rs 1,000. In 2001 the same country produced 110 units at Rs 15 per bread, so nominal GDP in 2001 was Rs 1,650.
Real GDP evaluates goods and services at constant, base year prices, allowing comparison of production volumes across years. Real GDP in 2001 calculated at the price of the year 2000, the base year, is 110 multiplied by Rs 10, equal to Rs 1,100. Real GDP eliminates the impact of price changes, so it is the useful tool for assessing actual changes in economic production, and changes in real GDP over years are only due to changes in the real volume of production. Formula: real GDP equals nominal GDP divided by the GDP deflator, multiplied by 100.
The GDP deflator is an index that measures the average change in prices of all goods and services included in GDP over time. It is calculated as the ratio of nominal GDP to real GDP, expressed as a percentage, so GDP deflator equals nominal GDP divided by real GDP, multiplied by 100. A GDP deflator of 150 percent implies that prices have increased by 50 percent compared with the base year.
Price indices: CPI, WPI, PPI and IIP
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) measures changes in the prices of a fixed basket of goods and services typically purchased by a representative consumer, and it quantifies the inflation experienced by consumers at the retail level. It is expressed as a percentage change in prices from a base year: CPI equals the cost of the basket in the current year divided by the cost of the basket in the base year, multiplied by 100.
Type of CPI | Description | Base year | Frequency | Released by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
CPI for Industrial Workers (CPI-IW) | Measures inflation for industrial workers | 2016 | Monthly | Labour Bureau, Ministry of Labour |
CPI for Agricultural Labourers (CPI-AL) | Measures inflation for agricultural labourers | 1986-87 | Monthly | Labour Bureau, Ministry of Labour |
CPI for Rural Labourers (CPI-RL) | Measures inflation for rural labourers | 1986-87 | Monthly | Labour Bureau, Ministry of Labour |
CPI Combined (CPI-C) | Measures overall retail inflation (urban plus rural) | 2012 | Monthly | National Statistical Office (NSO), Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI) |
The combined CPI carries weights that prelims can ask about. Food and beverages weigh 45.86 percent, housing 10.07 percent, clothing and footwear 6.53 percent, fuel and light 6.84 percent, and miscellaneous items such as health, education and transport weigh 30.70 percent.
The CPI differs from the GDP deflator in three ways. First, the goods purchased by consumers do not represent all the goods produced in a country, whereas the GDP deflator takes into account all such goods and services. Second, the CPI includes prices of goods consumed by the representative consumer, hence it includes prices of imported goods, but the GDP deflator does not include prices of imported goods. Third, the weights are constant in the CPI, but they differ according to the production level of each good in the GDP deflator.
The Wholesale Price Index (WPI) tracks changes in the prices of goods at the wholesale level and is used to assess inflation in the early stages of production and distribution. It is released by the Office of Economic Adviser, Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), Ministry of Commerce and Industry, monthly, with base year 2011-12. Its main components are primary articles at 22.62 percent, fuel and power at 13.15 percent, and manufactured products at 64.23 percent.
The Producer Price Index (PPI) measures the average change over time in the selling prices received by domestic producers for their goods and services. In India, the WPI acts as a proxy for PPI, as the PPI system is not yet fully adopted. A working group led by Ramesh Chand is tasked with revising the WPI base year to 2022-23 and creating a roadmap for a full transition to PPI. The Economic Survey noted that PPI is a superior GDP deflator because it includes services, eliminates double counting, and excludes indirect taxes, providing a pure supply-side measure of production health.
The Index of Industrial Production (IIP) measures the growth rate of industrial production over a given period and acts as a barometer for industrial activity. It is released monthly by the National Statistical Office (NSO), Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, with base year 2011-12, and it measures short-term industrial growth trends. Its components are manufacturing at 77.63 percent, mining at 14.37 percent, and electricity at 7.99 percent.
Core industry | Weightage (percent) |
|---|---|
Refinery products | 28.04 |
Electricity | 19.85 |
Steel | 17.92 |
Coal | 10.33 |
Crude oil | 8.98 |
Natural gas | 6.88 |
Cement | 5.37 |
Fertilizers | 2.63 |
These eight core industries carry the weights above in the IIP. The IIP is published monthly by the Central Statistics Office, which is part of the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, and its current base year is 2011-12.
GDP and welfare: what the number leaves out
Using GDP as the sole indicator of the welfare of a country people has its limitations. First, income distribution: GDP measures total economic output but says nothing about how that output is distributed. If GDP increases but the gains are concentrated in the hands of a few, the majority may not experience improved welfare, and unequal distribution can lead to disparities in well-being.
Second, non-monetary exchanges: many valuable activities are not monetised or included in GDP, such as domestic work performed at home, volunteer activities and barter exchanges where goods and services are directly swapped without money. This omission can underestimate economic activity and well-being. The Economic Survey 2024 highlights that women unpaid care and domestic work contributes massively to the economy, yet remains outside official GDP numbers, an invisible engine keeping growth alive.
Third, externalities: GDP does not consider the unintended side effects of economic activities, positive or negative. A factory may contribute to GDP growth but pollute a nearby river, harming local communities and ecosystems, and that harm is not reflected in GDP, so welfare may be overestimated by not accounting for negative externalities like pollution and environmental degradation. Conversely, positive externalities such as education and research may enhance well-being but are not directly captured in GDP.
Several alternative measures try to fill the gap. Green GDP subtracts environmental degradation and resource depletion from GDP to account for the cost of environmental damage. Green National Account is a framework that integrates environmental considerations into national accounting frameworks. The Human Development Index (HDI), developed by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), is a composite measure that considers a country health, education and income. Gross National Happiness (GNH) is Bhutan approach, prioritising well-being, cultural preservation and environmental conservation over GDP. The Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) is an American metric that considers environmental and social factors such as crime, poverty and the cost of ozone depletion.
India has its own measure too. The Social Progress Index (SPI), released by the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM), measures well-being through 12 components across three dimensions: Basic Human Needs, Foundations of Wellbeing, and Opportunity. The Economic Survey uses the SPI to show that high GDP does not always equal social progress, noting that states like Goa, Puducherry and Lakshadweep outperform larger economies in social outcomes.
Summary of national income aggregates
Aggregate | Meaning and formula |
|---|---|
GDP at market prices (GDP MP) | Market value of all final goods and services produced within the domestic territory of a country in a year. All production by national residents or non-residents is included. GDP MP equals C + I + G + X minus M. |
GDP at factor cost (GDP FC) | GDP at market prices less net product taxes. GDP FC equals GDP MP minus net indirect taxes (NIT). |
Net domestic product at market prices (NDP MP) | GDP MP minus depreciation. It shows how much the country has to spend just to maintain its current GDP. |
NDP at factor cost (NDP FC) | Income earned by the factors in the form of wages, profits, rent, interest within the domestic territory. NDP FC equals NDP MP minus net product taxes minus net production taxes. |
Gross national product at market prices (GNP MP) | Value of all final goods and services produced by the normal residents of India, whether within the national boundary or abroad. GNP MP equals GDP MP plus NFIA. |
GNP at factor cost (GNP FC) | Value of output received by the factors of production belonging to a country in a year. GNP FC equals GNP MP minus net product taxes minus net production taxes. |
Net national product at market prices (NNP MP) | GNP MP minus depreciation. NNP MP equals NDP MP plus NFIA. |
NNP at factor cost (NNP FC), or National Income (NI) | Sum of income earned by all factors in production, wages, profits, rent and interest, belonging to a country during a year. NI equals NNP MP minus net product taxes minus net production taxes, which equals NDP FC plus NFIA. |
GVA at market prices | GDP equals GVA plus indirect taxes minus subsidies. |
GVA at basic prices | GVA MP minus net product taxes. |
GVA at factor cost | GVA at basic prices minus net production taxes. |
Prelims practice
0 of 5 answered · 0 correct
With reference to national income accounting, consider the following statements: 1. GDP includes the output of foreign companies operating within the country. 2. National income includes the income earned abroad by domestic entities. 3. GNP equals GDP plus net factor income from abroad. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
If a factory has a factor cost of Rs 200 crore, production taxes of Rs 10 crore and production subsidies of Rs 5 crore, what is its basic price?
A country produces only bread. In 2000 it produced 100 units at Rs 10 each. In 2001 it produced 110 units at Rs 15 each. What is the real GDP of 2001 at 2000 prices?
Consider the following statements about the Consumer Price Index: 1. CPI includes the prices of imported goods consumed by the representative consumer. 2. The GDP deflator includes the prices of imported goods. 3. The weights in the CPI are constant, while in the GDP deflator they vary with production levels. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Which of the following is the largest component of the Wholesale Price Index by weight?
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between GDP and GNP?
GDP is the total market value of all final goods and services produced within a country borders, including output by foreign companies operating there. GNP is the value of all final goods and services produced by the country citizens, wherever they are located, so GNP equals GDP plus net factor income from abroad. An American company revenue in India counts in India GDP but not in its national income, while an Indian company earnings in the USA count in India national income but not in its GDP.
Why are intermediate goods excluded from GDP?
Because the value of final goods already includes the value of all inputs consumed in producing them. Counting steel sheets and the car made from them would count the steel twice. The value added method avoids this by counting, for each firm, only the difference between the value of its output and the value of its intermediate goods.
How is market price different from factor cost?
Factor cost is what producers receive, wages, rent, interest and profits, with no taxes or subsidies. Basic price adds net production taxes to factor cost. Market price adds net product taxes to the basic price, so it is the final price consumers pay. In January 2015 the CSO replaced GDP at factor cost with GVA at basic prices as the headline measure, while GDP at market prices remains the most highlighted measure.
What is the difference between personal income and personal disposable income?
Personal income is the part of national income received by households, after deducting undistributed profits, corporate tax and net interest payments made by households, and adding transfer payments like pensions and scholarships. Personal disposable income is personal income minus personal tax payments such as income tax and non-tax payments such as fines, the income households actually have at their disposal for consumption or saving.
Why is GDP not a good sole measure of welfare?
GDP says nothing about how output is distributed, so growth concentrated in a few hands may not improve most people welfare. It leaves out non-monetary work such as domestic services and barter, and it ignores externalities, so a polluting factory adds to GDP while the harm it causes is not subtracted. Alternatives such as Green GDP, the Human Development Index, Gross National Happiness and the Social Progress Index try to capture what GDP misses.
What is the GDP deflator, and how does it differ from the CPI?
The GDP deflator is the ratio of nominal GDP to real GDP multiplied by 100, and it measures the average change in prices of all goods and services included in GDP. The CPI measures the price of a fixed basket bought by a representative consumer. The CPI includes imported goods and uses constant weights, while the deflator excludes imports and its weights vary with production levels.
Asked in the prelims
Previous-year MCQs from this topic
How UPSC has tested this topic in the prelims — pick an option to test yourself.
- 2024Prelims
1.With reference to physical capital in Indian economy, consider the following pairs: Items : Category 1. Farmer’s plough : Working capital 2. Computer : Fixed capital 3. Yarn used by the weaver : Fixed capital 4. Petrol : Working capital How many of the above pairs are correctly matched?
- 2019Prelims
2.Consider the following statements: 1.Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) exchange rates are calculated by comparing the prices of the same basket of goods and services in different countries. 2.In terms of PPP dollars, India is the sixth largest economy in the world. Which of the statements given above is/ are correct?
- 2018Prelims
3.Increase in absolute and per capita real GNP do not connote a higher level of economic development, if