Polity — Prelims· Prelims
System of Government: Parliamentary, Federal and the Indian Model
Unitary, federal and confederate systems; parliamentary, presidential and semi-presidential forms compared; why India chose Parliament, and how its quasi-federal model works.
Every question about the Indian system of government really asks one thing: who answers to whom. In a parliamentary system the executive answers to the legislature, in a presidential system it does not, and India chose the parliamentary path for reasons that still shape its politics. This chapter sets out the types of government, compares the three great forms, and then shows how India's own model mixes federal and unitary features in a way no textbook example quite matches.
Start with the words themselves. The State is a political institution that represents a sovereign people organised under one independent government within a definite territory and subject to no outside control, a community of persons permanently occupying a definite territory, independent of external control and possessing an organised government, asked in UPSC 2021. A government is the group exercising authority over a territory and its people, responsible for creating and enforcing laws, managing public affairs and providing essential services. The system of government defines the division of authority between the legislature and executive, determining a country's governance structure.
Types of government
Unitary System: a central government holds all power, with regional authorities deriving their authority from it. Unitary systems mostly have a single strong government and may have a written (France) or unwritten (Britain) constitution, a supreme (Japan) or non-supreme (Britain) constitution, a rigid (France) or flexible (Britain) constitution, and a bicameral (Britain) or unicameral (China) legislature.
Federal System: powers are divided between a central government and regional governments, each with constitutionally defined autonomy. Examples: US, Switzerland, Australia, Canada, Russia, Brazil, Argentina and Germany.
Confederate System: regional governments maintain most power, with a weak central authority that relies on voluntary compliance. It features a flexible constitution. Examples given are the former Soviet Union and Switzerland's canton system.
A constitutional government is one that operates within the limitations set by a country's constitution, serving as the supreme law of the land, asked in UPSC 2020 and 2021. It places effective restrictions on the authority of the State in the interest of individual liberty, asked in UPSC 2014. The Constitution is the ultimate source of all governmental powers and delineates critical limitations that protect the fundamental rights of citizens, asked in UPSC 2023 and 2014. A key aspect is its role in constraining sovereign governments in their ruling capacity, establishing a limited government structure, asked in UPSC 2020.
Forms of government compared
Feature | Parliamentary System | Presidential System | Semi-Presidential System |
|---|---|---|---|
Executive Authority | Prime Minister leads; derives authority from Parliament. | President is both head of state and government; elected independently. | Dual executive: President and Prime Minister share authority. |
Relationship with Legislature | The Prime Minister can be removed by a vote of no confidence. | President cannot be easily removed; serves fixed terms. | The President is elected; the Prime Minister is accountable to the legislature. |
Cabinet Composition | Cabinet members are typically from the legislature. | Cabinet members are appointed by the President; may not be part of the legislature. | The Cabinet includes members from both the President and the legislature. |
Legislative Role | Legislature plays a crucial role in governance and policy making. | Legislature has limited influence over the President's decisions. | The Legislature has significant power but also shares it with the President. |
Stability | Can be unstable; the government can change frequently. | More stable; fixed terms provide consistency. | Stability can vary; dependent on the balance of power. |
Decision-Making | Quick decision-making due to close ties between executive and legislature. | Slower decision-making; President may face opposition from Congress. | Decision-making can be efficient but may face conflicts. |
Constitutional Flexibility | Often more flexible due to the evolving nature of Parliamentary practices. | Generally rigid; fixed terms are defined in the constitution. | Can be both flexible and rigid, depending on the balance of power. |
Example Countries | United Kingdom, India, Canada | United States, Brazil, Mexico | France and Ukraine |
Merits and demerits
The parliamentary system offers harmony between legislature and executive, a responsible government answerable to Parliament (asked in UPSC 2020), power that is not centralised because the Council of Ministers ensures collective authority, an opposition that can serve as an alternative if the ruling party loses its majority, and a Council of Ministers that reflects wide representation of diverse sections in governance. Its demerits are that loss of majority can lead to frequent government changes, new governments often alter existing policies, a strong Cabinet can centralise power, separation of powers is blurred, and ministers may not be specialists, limiting effective governance.
The presidential system offers a stable government, definiteness in policies, separation of powers, government by experts, and a direct mandate from the electorate that enhances legitimacy. Its demerits are conflict between legislature and executive, a non-responsible government, a risk of autocracy, narrow representation, and difficulties in achieving consensus.
The semi-presidential system combines the strengths of both systems, with flexible power distribution, encouragement of cooperation, stable leadership because Parliament can remove an unpopular Prime Minister, checks and balances, and alignment with development through an independent Prime Minister who fosters political and economic growth. Its demerits are potential conflict between President and Prime Minister leading to inefficiencies, unclear responsibility for policy outcomes, votes of confidence that may disrupt the legislative process, and unpopular policies that can be deflected to the Prime Minister, obscuring true accountability.
System of government in India
The Constitution of India provides for a parliamentary form of government, the executive being responsible to the legislature for its policies and acts, both at the Centre and in the states, asked in UPSC 2017. Parliamentary government is also known as Cabinet government, Responsible government and the Westminster model of government, and is prevalent in Britain, Japan, Canada and India, among others. It is defined by Articles 74 and 75 at the Centre and Articles 163 and 164 in the States.
The framers chose the parliamentary system for four reasons. First, familiarity: they were acquainted with the parliamentary system from British rule, making it a natural choice. Second, responsibility: Dr. B.R. Ambedkar emphasised the need for a democratic executive to ensure stability and responsibility. Third, avoiding conflicts: the parliamentary system helps prevent conflicts between the legislature and executive, which mattered greatly for a young democracy like India. Fourth, representation: given India's diverse society, the parliamentary system ensures representation of various sections and interests through small constituencies.
Features of the parliamentary system in India
Nominal and Real Executives: the President is the nominal head (de jure, Article 74), while the Prime Minister is the real head (de facto, Article 75).
Majority Party Rule: the party with the majority in the Lok Sabha forms the government. The President appoints the Prime Minister (Article 75) and ministers on the Prime Minister's advice.
Collective Responsibility: ministers are collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha (Article 75), which can remove them through a no-confidence motion, asked in UPSC 2015.
Double Membership: ministers belong to both the executive and the legislature (Article 75).
Dissolution of Lok Sabha: the President, on the Prime Minister's advice, can dissolve the Lok Sabha before its term (Article 85).
Secrecy: ministers maintain confidentiality in their decisions and proceedings (Article 75).
Distinction between the Indian and British models
Indian model | British model |
|---|---|
Republican system with an indirectly elected President as head of State. | Monarchical system with a hereditary King or Queen as Head of State. |
Based on Constitutional Supremacy. | Based on Parliamentary Sovereignty (UPSC 2021). |
The Prime Minister may be a member of any House (Lok Sabha or Rajya Sabha). | The Prime Minister must be a member of the Lower House (House of Commons). |
Non-Parliament members can be appointed as ministers for six months. | Ministers are usually members of Parliament only. |
No system of legal responsibility; ministers do not countersign official acts. | Ministers have a system of legal responsibility; they must countersign acts. |
No institution of Shadow Cabinet. | Shadow Cabinet formed by the opposition to balance the ruling cabinet and prepare future ministers. |
A shadow cabinet is a group of senior politicians from the opposition party in a parliamentary system, appointed to mirror the roles of the actual cabinet members of the ruling party.
Courts have sometimes had to act where no law existed. With no law in place, Vishakha (1997) saw the Supreme Court step onto the global stage, importing standards from CEDAW to create binding workplace harassment norms, a striking example of courts translating international law into domestic rights.
The Indian Constitution and the federal system
The USA, the first and oldest federation in the world, was formed in 1787 following the American Revolution (1775-1783). The Constitution of India establishes a federal system of government, although the term federation is not explicitly mentioned. Unlike the USA, Indian federalism did not arise from agreements among states; it is modelled after the Canadian system. Indian federalism is not the result of an agreement among the federating units, asked in UPSC 2017.
India is described as a Union of States (Article 1), reflecting its sociocultural diversity and large size. This structure allows for a quasi-federal system that accommodates regional autonomy while maintaining a strong central authority. Indian federalism represents a compromise between two conflicting considerations: the normal division of powers under which states enjoy autonomy within their own spheres, and the need for national integrity and a strong Union government under exceptional circumstances. The S.R. Bommai case (1994) affirmed federalism as a basic structure: states possess supreme authority within their sphere, recognising practical realities.
Unlike the US, India constitutionally mandates a Finance Commission that periodically enforces rules-based tax sharing with states, making Indian fiscal federalism more predictable, redistributive and distinctly state-centric than America's. History also warns that legality does not always mean liberty: under the Weimar Constitution, Nazi Germany used emergency powers written into the Constitution to destroy democracy, a warning that shaped India's carefully designed emergency provisions in Part XVIII of the Constitution.
How political scientists describe Indian federalism
Paul Appleby: describes the Indian system as extremely federal.
Morris Jones: refers to it as bargaining federalism, indicating negotiations among different levels of government.
Ivor Jennings: characterises it as a federation with a strong centralising tendency, noting that the Indian Constitution has unique safeguards to enforce national unity and growth.
Alexandrowicz: states that India is a case sui generis, emphasising its unique character.
Granville Austin: calls Indian federalism cooperative federalism, describing it as a new kind of federation tailored to meet India's specific needs.
K.C. Wheare: considers India a semi-federal or quasi-federal state, highlighting its mixed characteristics.
K. Santhanam: points out the unitary bias of the system due to central financial dominance.
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar: emphasises that India's federation is indestructible and not formed by agreements among states, stating that the Indian Constitution is a Federal Constitution with a dual polity, and both the Union and the states derive their authority from the Constitution.
Federal and unitary features of the Indian Constitution
Federal features | Unitary features |
|---|---|
Dual Polity: Union handles national matters, States handle local issues (Article 246). | Strong Centre: Union has more important subjects (Articles 248 and 249) and overriding power on the Concurrent List. |
Written Constitution: world's longest constitution with clear Centre-State jurisdictions. | Single Constitution: same constitution for Centre and States. |
Division of Powers: Centre and States legislate on concurrent subjects, but Centre prevails in conflicts (UPSC 2017). | No Equal State Representation: Rajya Sabha representation is population-based (UPSC 2017). |
Supremacy of Constitution: it is the supreme law, enforced by judicial review (Article 13). | States Not Indestructible: Parliament can change state boundaries (Article 3). |
Rigid Constitution: federal structure amendments need special procedures (Article 368). | Flexible Constitution: most provisions amended by Parliament alone (Article 368). |
Bicameralism: Rajya Sabha represents States; Lok Sabha represents people (Article 79). | Emergency Provisions: Centre gains complete control during emergencies (Articles 352, 356 and 360). |
Independent Judiciary: Supreme Court settles Centre-State disputes and guards constitutional supremacy (Articles 131, 32 and 136; UPSC 2017 and 2021). | Single Citizenship: equal rights nationwide (Articles 5-11). |
Federal features as above. | Integrated Judiciary: Supreme Court oversees both Central and State laws (Article 141). |
Federal features as above. | All-India Services: centrally controlled services (IAS, IPS, IFS) under Article 312. |
Federal features as above. | Integrated Audit: CAG audits both Centre and States (Article 148). |
Federal features as above. | Governor's Appointment: by the President, acting as the Centre's representative (Articles 155-156). |
Federal features as above. | Parliament's Authority: can legislate on the State List if necessary (Article 249). |
Federal features as above. | Veto Over State Bills: Governor can refer bills to the President (Article 200). |
Comparison of the Indian Constitution with the world
Feature | India | United Kingdom | United States | Canada | France | Japan | South Africa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Type of Constitution | Written and lengthy | Unwritten, based on statutes, conventions and treaties | Written and codified | Written and codified | Written and codified | Written and codified | Written and codified |
Fundamental Rights | Yes, detailed in Part III | Not explicitly stated; rights derived from common law and statutes | Yes, Bill of Rights (first ten amendments) | Yes, in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms | Yes, in the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen | Yes, guaranteed under Article 11 of the Constitution | Yes, in the Bill of Rights (Chapter 2 of the Constitution) |
Amendment Process | Rigid and flexible (different procedures) | Not formalised; based on parliamentary sovereignty | Rigid; requires supermajority in Congress and state ratification | Flexible; requires a majority in Parliament | Rigid; requires a majority in both houses and approval by referendum | Rigid; requires a majority in both houses and a majority vote | Rigid; requires a two-thirds majority in Parliament |
Separation of Powers | Yes, clear separation among Executive, Legislature and Judiciary | No strict separation; Parliament holds supreme authority | Yes, clear separation among Executive, Legislature and Judiciary | Yes, clear separation, with parliamentary system | Yes, clear separation among Executive, Legislature and Judiciary | Yes, clear separation among Executive, Legislature and Judiciary | Yes, clear separation among Executive, Legislature and Judiciary |
Judicial Review | Yes, the Supreme Court has the power of judicial review | No formal judicial review; Parliament is sovereign | Yes, power of judicial review established in Marbury v. Madison | Yes, the Supreme Court has judicial review authority | Yes, Constitutional Council ensures compliance with the Constitution | Yes, the Supreme Court can review laws for constitutionality | Yes, the Constitutional Court has the power of judicial review |
System of Government | Parliamentary system (Quasi-federal) | Parliamentary system (Unitary with devolved powers) | Federal system | Federal system | Semi-presidential system (Unitary, but regions have some autonomy) | Parliamentary system (Unitary system but recognises local autonomy) | Parliamentary republic (Unitary system) |
Head of State | President (Ceremonial role) | Monarch (Ceremonial role) | President (Executive role) | Monarch (Ceremonial role) | President (Executive role) | Emperor (Ceremonial role) | President (Executive role) |
Party System | Multi-party system | Two-party system | Two-party system | Multi-party system | Multi-party system | Multi-party system | Multi-party system |
Emergency Powers | President can declare national emergency | Government can declare state of emergency | President can declare national emergency | Prime Minister can declare national emergency | President can declare state of emergency | Prime Minister can declare state of emergency | President can declare state of emergency |
Official Language | Hindi and English | English | No formally recognised official language at the federal level | English and French | French | Japanese | English and Afrikaans |
Prelims practice
0 of 5 answered · 0 correct
Which of the following is a feature of the parliamentary system in India? 1. The President is the nominal head under Article 74. 2. Ministers are collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha under Article 75. 3. The Prime Minister must be a member of the Lok Sabha only.
In the S.R. Bommai case (1994), the Supreme Court affirmed that:
Who described Indian federalism as cooperative federalism?
Which of the following is a unitary feature of the Indian Constitution?
Consider the following statements: 1. In India, the Prime Minister may be a member of either House of Parliament. 2. In Britain, the Prime Minister must be a member of the House of Commons. 3. India has a system of legal responsibility under which ministers countersign official acts. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a State and a government?
The State is a political institution representing a sovereign people organised under one independent government within a definite territory, subject to no outside control. A government is the group exercising authority over that territory and its people, creating and enforcing laws, managing public affairs and providing essential services.
Why did India adopt the parliamentary system?
The framers were familiar with it from British rule, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar stressed a democratic executive for stability and responsibility, it helps prevent conflicts between the legislature and executive in a young democracy, and it ensures representation of diverse sections through small constituencies.
How does the Indian parliamentary model differ from the British model?
India is a republic with an indirectly elected President and constitutional supremacy, while Britain is a monarchy with parliamentary sovereignty. India's Prime Minister may belong to either House, non-members can be ministers for six months, ministers do not countersign acts, and India has no shadow cabinet.
What makes Indian federalism quasi-federal?
It has federal features such as a dual polity, division of powers, a written constitution and an independent judiciary, but also strong unitary features: a strong Centre, a single constitution and citizenship, an integrated judiciary, All-India Services, Governors appointed by the President, and emergency provisions that give the Centre complete control.
What did the S.R. Bommai case decide?
In S.R. Bommai (1994) the Supreme Court affirmed federalism as a basic structure of the Constitution, holding that states possess supreme authority within their sphere, while recognising practical realities.