Modern India — Prelims· Prelims
Rise of Nationalism in India, 1858-1905
How nationalism grew after 1857: the press, the pre-Congress associations, the founding of the Congress, its great sessions, and the Moderate and Extremist phases.
After 1857, India changed its mind about the British. The revolt had failed, but the grievances that caused it did not go away, and a new generation of educated Indians began to organise. They started with associations and petitions, built a press, rediscovered India's past, and in December 1885 founded the Indian National Congress. Within twenty years that Congress had moved from loyal resolutions to the demand for Swaraj, and the movement had split into Moderates who trusted petitions and Extremists who trusted the masses.
This chapter is the bridge between 1857 and the mass movements of the 20th century. The exam asks the phases of the movement, the pre-Congress associations, the theories behind the Congress's formation, the important Congress sessions and their presidents, and the difference between Moderates and Extremists. Every one of those is covered here, with the book's tables kept intact.
Phases of the national movement
The national movement falls into three phases. The early phase, the Moderate Phase (1885-1905), was led by the educated middle class, influenced by Western liberal ideas, with a vague vision for reform. The second phase, the Extremist Phase (1905-1918), expanded to social, cultural, economic and political upliftment, with aspirations for self-government, or Swaraj, and revolutionary methods gained popularity. The final phase, the Gandhian Phase (1919-1947), focused on Purna Swaraj, complete independence, led by Mahatma Gandhi through non-violent non-cooperation.
Factors in the growth of modern nationalism
Press and literature came first. By 1877, 169 regional newspapers, such as The Bengalee, Kesari and The Hindu, circulated 100,000 copies, advocating self-governance. Writers like Bankim Chandra Chatterjee and Bharatendu Harishchandra spread nationalist ideas. The rediscovery of India's past mattered just as much: scholars like Max Mueller, Monier Williams and Swami Vivekananda debunked colonial myths, emphasising India's rich heritage. Reform movements such as the Brahmo Samaj, Arya Samaj and Ramakrishna Mission promoted unity and nationalism.
Reactionary policies pushed educated Indians into opposition: Lord Lytton's reduction of the ICS age limit in 1876, the Delhi Durbar of 1877, the Vernacular Press Act of 1878 and the Arms Act of 1878 all sparked opposition. Western thought shaped the new nationalism, with influences from thinkers like Milton, Shelley, J.S. Mill and Rousseau. And there was global influence: Indian leaders like Naoroji and Tilak drew inspiration from global movements such as Italian unification and Irish Home Rule.
Political associations before the Indian National Congress
Before the Congress, Indians built a ladder of political associations, each one a little more ambitious than the last. Their founders and contributions are a favourite of the exam.
Year and name | Founders and key persons | Important contribution |
|---|---|---|
1836, Bangabhasha Prakasika Sabha, Calcutta | Associates of Raja Rammohan Roy: Prasanna Kumar Thakur, Kalinath Chowdhury, Dwarakanath Tagore, Gouri Sankar Bhattacharya, Durga Prasad Tarka Panchanan | Advocated administrative reforms, Indian participation in governance, and educational advancement |
1837, Zamindari Association (Landholders' Society), Calcutta | Dwarkanath Tagore, Radhakant Deb, Prasanna Kumar Tagore, Rajkamal Sen, Bhabani Charan Mitra | Protected landlord interests; first to initiate constitutional agitation in India |
1843, Bengal British India Society, Calcutta | George Thompson, Dwarkanath Tagore, Chandra Mohan Chatterjee, Parmananda Maitra | Collected information on welfare issues and promoted responsible citizenship |
1851, British Indian Association, Calcutta | President: Radhakant Deb; General Secretary: Debendranath Tagore | Merged Landholders Society and Bengal British India Society; demanded legislative reforms, separate legislature, separation of executive-judicial functions, reduction of salaries and taxes; petitioned for universities in three Presidencies (UPSC 2017) |
1852, Bombay Association, Bombay | Jagannath Shankarsheth | Petitioned for legislative reforms and Indian role in administration; revived in 1876 by Dadabhai Naoroji; later overshadowed by newer groups |
1852, Madras Native Association (MNA), Madras | Gajula Lakshminarasu Chetty | First political association of Madras Presidency; addressed grievances of landed classes and opposed missionary activities and the Lex Loci Act |
1866, East India Association, London | Dadabhai Naoroji | Influenced British public opinion on Indian issues; expanded to branches in India; promoted welfare of Indians |
1867, Poona Sarvajanik Sabha, Poona | G.V. Joshi, S.H. Sathe, S.H. Chiplonkar; M.G. Ranade joined in 1871 | Represented public opinion; mediated between government and people; promoted political participation and social reform |
1875, Indian League, Calcutta | Sisir Kumar Ghosh | Promoted nationalism and political education; aimed to extend political participation beyond elites |
1876, Indian Association (Indian National Association), Calcutta | Surendranath Banerjee, Ananda Mohan Bose | Led campaigns for ICS reform, Indianisation of services, and protests against repressive laws; organised the All-India Conference (1883); published the Indian Association's Journal (UPSC 2017) |
1883, All-India Conference, Calcutta | Indian Association of Calcutta | First attempt at all-India political coordination; later merged with INC in 1886 |
1884, Madras Mahajan Sabha, Madras | M. Veeraraghavachari, P. Ananda Charlu, G. Subramania Iyer | Advocated Indian representation in councils; coordinated regional political activities; led push for separation of judiciary and revenue functions |
1885, Bombay Presidency Association, Bombay | Pherozshah Mehta, K.T. Telang, Badruddin Tyabji | Formed in response to Lytton's policies and Ilbert Bill controversy; promoted political rights in Bombay; maintained strong ties with Poona Sarvajanik Sabha |
1885, London Indian Society, London | Dadabhai Naoroji | Platform for Indian students in London to raise political issues; later absorbed into East India Association (1866) |
Two of these associations carry extra weight. The British Indian Association (1851) was asked about in UPSC 2017, and the Indian Association (1876) of Surendranath Banerjee and Ananda Mohan Bose was also asked in UPSC 2017, for its campaigns on ICS reform, the Indianisation of services, protests against repressive laws, and the All-India Conference of 1883.
Pre-Congress campaigns
The associations did not just meet, they campaigned. They protested the import duty on cotton in 1875, campaigned for the Indianisation of government service in 1878-79, opposed Lytton's Afghan adventure, the Arms Act and the Vernacular Press Act of 1878, advocated for the right to join volunteer corps, opposed plantation labour and the Inland Emigration Act of 1881-82, supported the Ilbert Bill of 1883, which would have allowed Indian judges to try British criminals, campaigned in Britain for pro-India parties, and led the Indian Civil Service agitation of 1877-80 against the reduction of the age limit for ICS exams.
They also took up peasant issues, supporting the Indigo Riots in Bengal, the Deccan Riots in Poona, and water tax protests in the Chenab Canal Colony in Punjab. Social work by groups like the Poona Sarvajanik Sabha connected peasants to nationalist movements.
Surendranath Banerjee once described the British Empire as a banyan tree giving shelter, but after the 1905 Partition of Bengal he famously declared it now shelters only serpents. The remark marked his disillusionment with British rule and his transformation into a vocal critic of imperial policies.
Indian National Congress: foundation and the Moderate Phase
A.O. Hume, a retired British civil servant, played a key role in founding the INC, collaborating with leaders like Dadabhai Naoroji, Dinshaw Wacha and Womesh Chandra Bonnerjee. The First Congress Session (December 1885) was held at Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College, Bombay, with 72 delegates, mostly lawyers. Lord Dufferin was the British Viceroy at the time. The session focused on loyalty to the British Crown while advocating for Indian welfare and representation. Annual meetings were then held in December each year across India.
Three theories explain why the Congress was founded. The Safety Valve Theory was proposed by William Wedderburn in his 1913 biography of Hume. In 1878, Hume discovered secret reports revealing significant discontent among the lower classes and plans to overthrow British rule. Concerned, he met with Lord Dufferin to create a platform for educated Indians. Lala Lajpat Rai and R.P. Dutt supported the theory, but modern historians reject it. The Lightning Conductor Theory came from Gokhale: Gopal Krishna Gokhale suggested that the British would not have tolerated a revolutionary movement initiated by Indians, so A.O. Hume's involvement was crucial. While Hume viewed the INC as a means to manage political discourse, Indian leaders sought to use it as a lightning conductor to channel nationalist sentiments. Bipan Chandra's perspective noted the dual vision: while the British hoped to control dissent, Indian leaders aimed to leverage this platform for greater nationalistic awakening.
The formation of the INC was the culmination of political awakening dating back to the 1860s and 1870s, gaining momentum by the late 1870s and early 1880s. The INC served as a platform for national unity and political representation against colonial rule, driven by a desire for political education and national engagement, inspired by contemporary movements. Over time its objectives shifted, from moderate petitions to assertive demands for self-rule. In the early years the INC was divided into two factions: the Moderates, led by figures like Gopal Krishna Gokhale, who sought gradual reforms through petitions and collaboration with British officials; and the Extremists, led by Bal Gangadhar Tilak and others, who advocated for Swaraj and were willing to adopt more aggressive tactics, including boycotts and protests.
Women were part of the Congress from its earliest years. Long before women's rights movements, Kadambini Ganguly and Anandibai Joshi broke barriers as India's first women doctors and became among the earliest women to attend Indian National Congress sessions between 1885 and 1905, marking their crucial role in women's participation in national politics. And in 1892, Dadabhai Naoroji made history as the first Indian MP in the British Parliament, delivering a powerful speech calling India bleeding under your drain. His words exposed the economic exploitation of India by the British, shocking MPs and raising awareness of the colonial drain of wealth.
Important Congress sessions
The Congress sessions are a single long table in the exam's memory, and the presidents are the usual question. The sessions from 1885 to 1946 are given here together, since the book presents them as one reference table.
Year, location, president | Key resolutions and events |
|---|---|
1885, Bombay, W.C. Bonnerjee | First session of the Indian National Congress, attended by 72 delegates |
1886, Calcutta, Dadabhai Naoroji | Merger of INC with the National Conference, strengthening the INC's foundation; Naoroji presided over the INC three times (1886, 1893, 1906) |
1887, Madras, Badruddin Tyabji | First Muslim President of INC; appeal to Muslims to join INC (UPSC 2015) |
1888, Allahabad, George Yule | First Englishman (non-Indian) to become INC President |
1896, Calcutta, Rahimatullah M. Sayani | Vande Mataram sung for the first time by Rabindranath Tagore in a Congress session |
1905, Benaras, Gopal Krishna Gokhale | Formal proclamation of the Swadeshi Movement against the British; boycott of foreign goods, promotion of Swadeshi goods and Indian industries |
1906, Calcutta, Dadabhai Naoroji | Resolutions on Swaraj (Self-Government), Boycott Movement, Swadeshi, and National Education adopted |
1907, Surat, Rash Behari Ghosh | Split between Moderates and Extremists within INC; session adjourned |
1910, Allahabad, Sir William Wedderburn | M.A. Jinnah criticised the separate electorate system introduced by the Indian Councils Act, 1909 |
1911, Calcutta, B.N. Dhar | Jana Gana Mana sung for the first time in a Congress session, marking the beginnings of national unity |
1915, Bombay, Sir S.P. Sinha | Congress constitution altered to admit delegates from the extremist section, reflecting internal shifts within the INC |
1916, Lucknow, A.C. Majumdar | Unity between Moderates and Extremists in INC; Lucknow Pact signed with the Muslim League |
1917, Calcutta, Annie Besant | First female President of INC (UPSC 2015, 2013) |
1918, Bombay (Special session), Syed Hasan Imam | Special session to deliberate on the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms and INC's participation in British reforms |
1919, Amritsar, Motilal Nehru | Support for the Khilafat Movement; condemnation of the Jallianwala Bagh massacre |
1920, Calcutta (Special session), Lala Lajpat Rai | Non-Cooperation Movement resolution moved by Mahatma Gandhi, aiming at non-violent resistance against British rule |
1920, Nagpur, C. Vijayaraghavachariar | Reorganisation of Congress on linguistic grounds; M.A. Jinnah left the INC |
1922, Gaya, C.R. Das | Formation of the Swaraj Party after breaking away from INC, reflecting ideological differences |
1924, Belgaum, M.K. Gandhi | Only session presided over by Mahatma Gandhi, emphasising his leadership within INC |
1925, Kanpur, Sarojini Naidu | First Indian woman President of INC |
1927, Madras, Dr. M.A. Ansari | Resolution passed against using Indian troops overseas and boycott of the Simon Commission; resolution on Purna Swaraj |
1928, Calcutta, Motilal Nehru | Formation of the All India Youth Congress to engage younger generations; acceptance of Nehru Report recommending Dominion status |
1929, Lahore, Jawaharlal Nehru | Poorna Swaraj resolution passed; decision to launch Civil Disobedience Movement; 26 January 1930 declared as Independence Day |
1931, Karachi, Vallabhbhai Patel | Endorsement of the Gandhi-Irwin Pact; resolutions on Fundamental Rights and National Economic Programme |
1934, Bombay, Rajendra Prasad | Amendment in the Constitution of Congress, signalling the need for an updated organisational framework |
1936, Lucknow, Jawaharlal Nehru | Emphasis on socialist principles in Congress policies, marking a shift toward left-wing economic ideas |
1937, Faizpur, Jawaharlal Nehru | First Congress session held in a village, emphasising a connection to grassroots and rural India |
1938, Haripura, Subhas Chandra Bose | National Planning Committee established for India's economic development post-independence |
1939, Tripuri, Subhas Chandra Bose, then Rajendra Prasad | Subhas Chandra Bose re-elected but resigned after disputes; Rajendra Prasad took over; formation of the Forward Bloc by Bose |
1940, Ramgarh, Abul Kalam Azad | Decision to leave the final call on launching the Civil Disobedience Movement to Mahatma Gandhi |
1946, Meerut, J.B. Kripalani | Last session before Indian independence; J.B. Kripalani was the INC president at the time of independence |
Moderates (1885-1905) and the Extremist Phase (1905-1919)
The difference between the two wings of the Congress is best seen side by side.
Aspect | Moderates (1885-1905) | Extremists (1905-1919) |
|---|---|---|
Social base | Wealthy landowners, upper-middle classes, educated professionals | Educated middle and lower-middle classes, masses in rural areas |
Ideological inspiration | Western liberal philosophy, parliamentary principles, belief in British justice, gradual reforms | Inspired by Indian history, cultural heritage, self-rule (Swaraj), rejection of British rule |
Views on British rule | Believed Britain had a divinely ordained mission to rule India; colonial rule beneficial in some ways | Rejected British rule as exploitative, unjust; viewed British authority as illegitimate |
Involvement of masses | Movement confined to educated middle class; felt masses were politically unaware | Faith in the masses' ability to engage in political activism; advocated widespread participation |
Key demands | Constitutional reforms, increased Indian representation, civil service Indianisation, legislative elections, Indian members to the Viceroy's Executive Council (No Taxation without Representation); administrative changes including raising the ICS exam age limit, conducting exams in India, reducing defence costs; economic reforms | Swaraj (self-rule): complete independence from British rule, empowering Indian masses, expanding Congress's social base; economic self-reliance, indigenous industries, Swadeshi, national education |
Methods of struggle | Petition, prayer, propaganda, constitutional agitation through petitions, resolutions, press, public meetings | Boycotts, passive resistance, protests, militant agitation, direct confrontation with British, use of traditional festivals for political mobilisation, volunteer organisations (Samitis) |
Nature of patriotism | Patriotic, focused on reforming the colonial system, relied on British fairness and liberal ideals | Passionate patriots, willing to endure sacrifices and confront British oppression for independence |
Economic reforms | Critiqued colonial economic policies, advocated industrial development, reduction in land taxes, fiscal policies benefiting Indians | Advocated self-reliance in economic matters, promotion of indigenous industries, banks, local businesses |
Educational reforms | Focused on expanding modern education, raising political consciousness, emphasising English and Western-style education | Supported national education promoting indigenous culture, languages and values, establishing national institutions |
Cultural impact | Less emphasis on cultural revival, focused more on political and administrative reform | Strong emphasis on cultural revivalism, use of Hindu mythology, traditions, festivals for political mobilisation |
Relations with the press | Used press for political discourse, raising public awareness, criticising British policies | Used press with a radical tone, promoting nationalism and resistance against colonial rule |
Role of women and other groups | Limited involvement of women and marginalised groups, mostly educated elites | Encouraged active participation of women, students, workers, and expanded activism to a wider base |
Leaders | Dadabhai Naoroji, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Pherozeshah Mehta, R.C. Dutt, Womesh Chandra Bonnerjee, Mahadev Govind Ranade, Surendranath Banerjee, Badruddin Tyabji, Rash Behari Ghosh | Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal, Lala Lajpat Rai, Aurobindo Ghosh, Subramania Bharati, Veer Savarkar, Chidambaram Pillai, Rash Behari Bose, C.R. Das |
Evaluation of the Moderate Phase (1885-1905)
The Moderate Phase laid the foundation for India's independence movement, advocating reforms within British rule. Its key achievements were the Public Service Commission (1886), which enabled Indian civil service participation; the Indian Councils Act (1892), which expanded councils and introduced indirect elections but offered limited power; the House of Commons Resolution (1893), which recognised Indian participation in administration; and the Welby Commission (1895), which supported critiques of British economic policies, acknowledging India's economic burdens.
The economic critique was the Moderates' lasting contribution. Dadabhai Naoroji's Drain of Wealth Theory argued that British policies depleted India's wealth. British imports led to deindustrialisation, harming local industries and increasing poverty. The Zamindari system exploited peasants with high rents, causing agrarian distress, while infrastructure mainly served British interests, neglecting Indian welfare. The reform goals were Indianising the civil services, establishing judicial independence, decentralising finances and improving education.
Causes for the rise of Extremism (1905)
Extremism rose because the Moderate method had run its course. Colonial exploitation was exposed by the Drain Theory, in key works such as Naoroji's Poverty and Un-British Rule, Ranade's Essays on Indian Economics and Dutt's Economic History of India. The crisis of 1896-1900, famines, plagues and unrest, highlighted British failures. Nationalist dissatisfaction grew as the Indian Councils Act (1892) failed and leaders like the Natu brothers were deported. The Bengal Partition (1905) symbolised divide and rule, spurring protests. Global anti-imperialist influence helped: Japan's victory in 1905 over Russia and Boer War defeats of 1899-1902 inspired militancy. Militant leaders such as Tilak, Lajpat Rai, Aurobindo Ghosh and Bipin Chandra Pal advocated Swaraj and direct action. And Curzon's policies added fuel: the Calcutta Corporation Act (1899), the Delhi Durbar (1902), the Indian Universities Commission (1902) and the Indian Official Secrets Act (1904).
Evaluation of the Extremist Phase
The Extremist Phase changed the character of the movement. National awakening: it ignited a strong sense of nationalism, shifting the Indian freedom struggle from elite petitions to mass demands for Swaraj. Swadeshi and Boycott: it launched the Swadeshi Movement and encouraged the boycott of British goods, promoting economic self-reliance. Cultural revival: it fostered pride in India's heritage, countering British claims of cultural superiority. Youth mobilisation: it successfully inspired the youth to engage in the struggle, adding a dynamic element to the movement. Revolutionary ideas: it introduced concepts of armed resistance, fostering a spirit of defiance against colonial rule. Its legacy is that it laid the groundwork for future strategies, especially under Gandhi, and emphasised the importance of inclusive political engagement that addressed the social, economic and cultural dimensions of the movement.
Chandernagore, a French colony, became a secret base for revolutionary activities. Due to its exemption from British rule, it was used for printing Vande Mataram pamphlets and arms plans, playing a pivotal role in India's freedom struggle from foreign oppression.
Prelims practice
Consider the following statements: 1. The first session of the Indian National Congress was held in December 1885 at Bombay with 72 delegates. 2. The first session was presided over by Dadabhai Naoroji. 3. Lord Dufferin was the Viceroy at the time of the first session. Which of the statements given above are correct?
The Safety Valve Theory about the formation of the Indian National Congress was proposed by:
Who was the first Muslim President of the Indian National Congress?
In which Congress session were the resolutions on Swaraj, Boycott, Swadeshi and National Education adopted?
Consider the following pairs: 1. Vande Mataram first sung in a Congress session: Calcutta, 1896. 2. Jana Gana Mana first sung in a Congress session: Calcutta, 1911. 3. First Indian woman President of INC: Sarojini Naidu, Kanpur, 1925. 4. Only session presided over by Mahatma Gandhi: Belgaum, 1924. Which of the pairs given above are correctly matched?
Answer key
1. (b) - The first session was held in December 1885 at Bombay with 72 delegates and Lord Dufferin was Viceroy, but it was presided over by W.C. Bonnerjee, not Dadabhai Naoroji. 2. (b) - William Wedderburn proposed the Safety Valve Theory in his 1913 biography of A.O. Hume. 3. (b) - Badruddin Tyabji presided at Madras in 1887, the first Muslim president of the Congress. 4. (b) - The Calcutta session of 1906, presided over by Dadabhai Naoroji, adopted the resolutions on Swaraj, Boycott, Swadeshi and National Education. 5. (d) - All four pairs are correct: Vande Mataram at Calcutta 1896, Jana Gana Mana at Calcutta 1911, Sarojini Naidu at Kanpur 1925, and Gandhi's only presidency at Belgaum 1924.
Frequently asked questions
When and where was the Indian National Congress founded?
The Indian National Congress was founded in December 1885. Its first session was held at Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College, Bombay, with 72 delegates, mostly lawyers, and W.C. Bonnerjee as president. A.O. Hume, a retired British civil servant, played a key role in its founding, working with leaders like Dadabhai Naoroji, Dinshaw Wacha and Womesh Chandra Bonnerjee, while Lord Dufferin was Viceroy.
What is the Safety Valve Theory?
The Safety Valve Theory was proposed by William Wedderburn in his 1913 biography of A.O. Hume. It holds that Hume, after discovering secret reports in 1878 of discontent among the lower classes and plans to overthrow British rule, met Lord Dufferin to create a platform for educated Indians that would release political pressure. Lala Lajpat Rai and R.P. Dutt supported it, but modern historians reject the theory.
What was Dadabhai Naoroji's Drain of Wealth theory?
Naoroji argued that British policies systematically depleted India's wealth, with British imports causing deindustrialisation, harming local industries and increasing poverty. His key work was Poverty and Un-British Rule. In 1892 he became the first Indian MP in the British Parliament, where he described India as bleeding under the drain of wealth.
How did the Moderates differ from the Extremists?
The Moderates (1885-1905) were wealthy landowners, upper-middle classes and educated professionals who believed in Western liberal philosophy and gradual reform through petitions, prayer and propaganda. The Extremists (1905-1919) drew on educated middle and lower-middle classes and the rural masses, rejected British rule as exploitative, demanded Swaraj, and used boycotts, passive resistance, protests and traditional festivals for mobilisation.
Who were the first women associated with the Congress?
Kadambini Ganguly and Anandibai Joshi, India's first women doctors, were among the earliest women to attend Indian National Congress sessions between 1885 and 1905. Annie Besant became the first woman president of the Congress at Calcutta in 1917, and Sarojini Naidu became the first Indian woman president at Kanpur in 1925.
What did the Moderate Phase achieve?
The Moderate Phase secured the Public Service Commission (1886), which enabled Indian civil service participation, the Indian Councils Act (1892), which expanded councils and introduced indirect elections, the House of Commons Resolution (1893) recognising Indian participation in administration, and the Welby Commission (1895), which acknowledged India's economic burdens. Its deeper achievement was building the political platform and the economic critique on which later movements stood.