Modern India — Prelims· Prelims
Indian National Movement, 1905-1918
Partition of Bengal, Swadeshi and Boycott, the Surat Split, Morley-Minto Reforms, revolutionary activities, the Ghadar Party, Home Rule, the Lucknow Pact and Montagu's Declaration.
Between 1905 and 1918 the freedom struggle stopped being a conversation among educated men and became a movement of the people. It began with Lord Curzon's Partition of Bengal, which turned a province into a battlefield of petitions, boycotts and bonfires of foreign cloth. It produced the Swadeshi movement, the split at Surat, the first separate electorates, a generation of revolutionaries who picked up the bomb and the pistol, the Ghadar party across the Pacific, and, during the First World War, the Home Rule Leagues, the Lucknow Pact and the first British promise of responsible government.
This chapter is dense with dates and names that the exam loves: 7 August 1905, 16 October 1905, the Morley-Minto Reforms of 1909, the annulment of the Partition in 1911, the Ghadar Party of 1913, the Komagata Maru incident of 1914, the two Home Rule Leagues of 1916, the Lucknow Pact, and Montagu's Declaration of August 1917. Learn them in sequence and they tell one story, of a movement growing bolder every year.
Partition of Bengal (1905)
In July 1905, Lord Curzon announced the partition of the undivided Bengal Presidency, and it was implemented on October 16, 1905. The proposal divided Bengal into two provinces: Western Bengal, with Bihar and Orissa, and Eastern Bengal, with Assam. The capitals were Calcutta for Bengal and Dacca for Eastern Bengal. The official justification was that Bengal's population of 78 million made administration difficult, and the development of Assam was also cited as a reason for partition.
The real motives were different. First, to weaken Indian nationalism: Bengal, the nerve centre of Indian nationalism, was to be weakened by splitting it into two provinces. Second, to create linguistic and religious divisions: the Bengali population was reduced to a minority, creating a Hindu-majority western region and a Muslim-majority eastern region. Third, the British strategy of divide and rule: the partition was a deliberate attempt to divide and rule by fostering communal divisions between Hindus and Muslims. Its significance was that it intensified nationalist sentiments and catalysed the Swadeshi Movement, which became a key part of India's freedom struggle, unifying Indians against British imperialism.
The partition had immediate effects. Anti-partition agitation produced massive protests across Bengal. The Swadeshi Movement began an economic boycott of British goods, symbolising nationalist defiance. Extremism rose, sparking a more aggressive stance within the Indian National Movement. And the partition sowed the seeds of communal politics, leading to the formation of the Muslim League (1906). Lord Curzon also tried to appeal to Muslims: by making Dacca the capital of the Muslim-majority province, he aimed to secure Muslim support.
The Swadeshi and Boycott Movement (1903-1905)
Swadeshi and Boycott were adopted as methods of struggle for the first time during the agitation against the Partition of Bengal, a fact asked in UPSC 2016. The movement emerged in response to the British decision to partition Bengal, announced in December 1903, also asked in UPSC 2016. Officially, the partition aimed at improving administrative efficiency, but the real motive was to weaken Bengal, a hub of Indian nationalism, by dividing it along religious and linguistic lines. Key leaders were Surendranath Banerjea, K.K. Mitra and Prithwishchandra Ray. Methods of protest included petitions, public meetings and newspapers such as Hitabadi, Sanjibani and Bengalee. Despite the opposition, the partition was officially announced in July 1905, leading to massive protests.
The formal launch came on August 7, 1905, when the Boycott Resolution was passed, marking the formal proclamation of the Swadeshi Movement, asked in UPSC 2023. On October 16, 1905, Bengal was officially partitioned. On this day, Indians expressed mourning by fasting, bathing in the Ganges, singing Bande Mataram, the theme song of the movement, and tying symbolic unity bands. Rabindranath Tagore composed the song Amar Sonar Bangla, which later became Bangladesh's national anthem. Note that 7 August is observed as National Handloom Day, first observed in 2015, because the Swadeshi Movement was launched on that day in 1905, a fact asked in UPSC 2023.
The movement spread quickly beyond Bengal, to Poona, Bombay, Punjab, Delhi and Madras. In the Indian National Congress session of 1905 at Benaras, chaired by Gopal Krishna Gokhale, the partition was condemned and the Swadeshi Movement was endorsed. In the Calcutta session of 1906, chaired by Dadabhai Naoroji, the INC declared Swaraj (self-government) as its goal for the first time. Disputes between the Moderates and Extremists over methods led to the Surat split in 1907, asked in UPSC 2015. Key leaders across India were Ashwini Kumar Dutta in Bengal, V.O. Chidambaram Pillai in Madras, Syed Hyder Reza in Delhi, T. Prakasam and Krishna Rao in Andhra, Lala Lajpat Rai and Ajit Singh in Punjab, and Bal Gangadhar Tilak in Bombay and Poona. The Swadeshi Movement contributed to the revival of indigenous artisan crafts and industries, and the National Council of Education was established as a part of the Swadeshi Movement, asked in UPSC 2019.
The movement invented new forms of struggle. Boycott of foreign goods: mass actions like burning foreign textiles and abstaining from foreign products gained widespread support. Public gatherings mobilised masses and fostered unity through processions. Corps of Volunteers, or Samitis: local organisations like the Swadesh Bandhab Samiti and Swadeshi Sangam spread nationalist ideas through cultural events and social work. Festivals: Tilak's Ganapati and Shivaji Festivals became platforms for swadeshi propaganda. Atma-Shakti promoted self-reliance, national pride, and social reforms like the abolition of caste discrimination and dowry. Swadeshi education: Bengal National College and National Schools promoted indigenous education, and the National Council of Education (August 15, 1906) focused on nationalist education. Swadeshi enterprises: indigenous industries like textile mills and the Swadeshi Steam Navigation Company reduced dependency on British goods, asked in UPSC 2019.
The movement's impact on culture was deep. Nationalist songs by Rabindranath Tagore and Dwijendralal Ray inspired Indian nationalism, and Tagore's Amar Sonar Bangla motivated Bangladesh's liberation struggle. In art, Abanindranath Tagore challenged Victorian naturalism, drawing inspiration from traditional Indian art, while Nandalal Bose significantly impacted Indian art through the Indian Society of Oriental Art. In science, Jagdish Chandra Bose showcased India's potential for scientific innovation. Traditional crafts were revived, promoting handwoven textiles and craftsmanship. And Desher Katha by S.G. Deuskar, a book summarising the works of M.G. Ranade and D. Naoroji, warned against the British hypnotic conquest of the mind and inspired Swadeshi plays and songs, asked in UPSC 2020.
Mass participation was wide but uneven. Students led picketing against foreign goods, and faced punitive actions: disaffiliation, job disqualification, scholarships revoked, fines, expulsion, arrest and physical punishment. Women engaged in protests, processions and picketing. The urban middle class shifted to public activism in the national struggle. There was active support from Maulana Azad, but many upper and middle-class Muslims distanced themselves due to Hindu-centric symbols, and Nawab Salimullah backed the East Bengal partition for Muslims. The British promoted the All India Muslim League (1906), deepening divisions. There were strikes in 1905-1908: the Burn Company Clerks' Strike (1905) in Howrah, the East Indian Railway Strike (1906), the Jute Mills Strikes (1906-1908) and the Rawalpindi Strike, led by Lala Lajpat Rai and Ajit Singh, plus foreign mill strikes led by Subramaniya Siva and Chidambaram Pillai.
The movement dissipated slowly, because of government repression, internal divisions and limited reach beyond Bengal. Muslim support was hindered by communal divisions and the formation of the All India Muslim League (1906), and lack of organisation, directionless energy and communal riots further weakened its effectiveness.
The Surat Split (1907)
The Swadeshi Movement contributed to a split in the Indian National Congress, resulting in the emergence of Moderates and Extremists, asked in UPSC 2015. The Congress split into Moderate and Extremist factions during its session in Surat in December 1907. The reason was the Extremists' lack of faith in the capacity of the Moderates to negotiate with the British Government, asked in UPSC 2016. After the split, the Congress was primarily controlled by Moderates, focusing on self-government through constitutional means.
From 1907 to 1911 the British government enacted strict laws to crush the movement: the Seditious Meetings Act (1907), the Criminal Law Amendment Act (1908), the Incitement to Offences Act (1908), the Explosive Substances Act (1908) and the Indian Press Act (1910).
Key Congress sessions of the period
Benaras (1905), presided over by Gopal Krishna Gokhale, saw the emergence of Moderate-Extremist differences on extending the Swadeshi Movement, and a mild resolution condemning the partition of Bengal was passed to avert an immediate split, asked in UPSC 2016. Calcutta (1906), presided over by Dadabhai Naoroji: the Moderates proposed Naoroji as president while the Extremists favoured Tilak or Lajpat Rai. Swarajya, or self-government, was mentioned for the first time, but undefined. The Moderates preferred caution and focused on council reforms, while the Extremists advocated passive resistance and boycott. Surat (1907), presided over by Ras Behari Ghosh: the Extremists aimed to have Tilak or Lajpat Rai as president and pushed for radical resolutions, the Moderates insisted on excluding Tilak to drop radical agendas, and firm stances led to an inevitable split.
The Simla Deputation (1906) ran alongside these sessions. A group of Muslim elites, led by Agha Khan, met Lord Minto to demand a separate electorate for Muslims. This group took over the Muslim League, initially formed by Nawab Salimullah and others, aiming to maintain loyalty to the British and draw the Muslim intelligentsia away from the Congress.
Morley-Minto Reforms of 1909
The Morley-Minto Reforms, formally known as the Indian Councils Act of 1909, aimed to address the demands of both Moderates and Muslims amidst rising nationalist sentiments in India. Their key provisions were: expansion of legislative councils, with increased Indian representation, yet the majority remained British officials, ensuring British control; separate electorates for Muslims, allowing Muslims to elect representatives, marking a significant acknowledgment of communal divisions; increased elected membership in both Imperial and Provincial Legislative Councils, although some were still nominated; lower qualifications for Muslims, who received representation exceeding their population share, with lower income qualifications for voters compared to Hindus; indirect elections, with members elected indirectly through local bodies, creating a complex electoral process; empowered legislatures, which could pass resolutions and vote on budget items, but not the budget as a whole; and Indian representation in the Executive Council, with Satyendra Sinha becoming the first Indian member of the Viceroy's Executive Council.
The Delhi Durbar of 1911 followed. In 1911, Lord Hardinge organised a Durbar in Delhi, attended by the British Monarch King George V and Queen Mary. Its announcements were that the Bengal Partition was revoked, asked in UPSC 2014, and that British India's capital shifted from Calcutta to Delhi. The Delhi Conspiracy Case followed: Rash Bihari Bose and Sachindra Nath Sanyal, extremist revolutionaries, tried to throw a bomb on Hardinge. Sachindra Nath Sanyal was jailed, during which he wrote Bandi Jeevan.
The annulment of the Partition in 1911 was formally proclaimed when King George V abrogated Curzon's Act at the Royal Durbar in Delhi in 1911, asked in UPSC 2014. In 1911, the British government, under Viceroy Lord Hardinge, annulled the Partition of Bengal (1905) due to increasing unrest and pressure from the Swadeshi and Boycott Movement. Officially, the annulment was justified as an administrative necessity, claiming better governance for a unified Bengal.
Revolutionary activities in India
Revolutionary nationalism came in two phases. The first phase followed the decline of the Swadeshi Movement and ran until 1917. The second phase arose after the Non-Cooperation Movement. The factors behind it were the decline of moderate leadership, particularly under Lord Curzon, and weak post-Swadeshi leadership, which led to disillusionment and prompted young nationalists to adopt revolutionary tactics for independence.
The revolutionaries used several methods: acts of heroism, organising assassinations of unpopular officials and informers within their ranks; Swadeshi dacoities, robberies conducted to raise funds for revolutionary activities; and military conspiracies, since during the First World War some revolutionaries planned military actions with the hope of support from Britain's enemies. Their activities showed themselves as violent uprisings, such as the Kakori Train Robbery in 1924 and the Chittagong Armory Raid in 1930, political assassinations of unpopular British officials in India and abroad, and secret societies such as the Hindustan Republican Association and Jugantar, which organised bombings and assassinations.
Barindra Ghosh, the brother of Aurobindo Ghosh, published the seditious manual Mukti Kon Pathe, meaning Which Way Freedom, in 1906. Within just 48 hours of publication, the British banned it. Despite this, hundreds of copies circulated covertly, with Chandernagore, the French territory, serving as a key base.
Case, organisation (year) and place | Associated people and description |
|---|---|
Anushilan Samiti (1902), Bengal | Founded by Promotha Mitter and others, including Jatindranath Banerjee and Barindra Kumar Ghosh; published journals Yugantar and Sandhya Prakash; advocated revolutionary activities like Swadeshi dacoities, physical training and moral education |
Attempt on Sir Fuller's life (1907), Bengal | An attempt by Yugantar on Sir Fuller, Lt. Governor of Eastern Bengal and Assam; Fuller eventually resigned from his post |
Muzaffarpur Case (1908) and Alipore Conspiracy Case, or Manicktolla Bomb Conspiracy (1908), Bengal | Prafulla Chaki and Khudiram Bose attempted to kill Muzaffarpur Magistrate Kingsford; Aurobindo Ghosh was acquitted in the Alipore Conspiracy Case; Khudiram Bose was hanged for the attempt; Barindra Kumar Ghosh was sentenced to life imprisonment |
Barrah Dacoity (1908), Bengal | Carried out by Dacca Anushilan under Pulin Das to fund revolutionary activities |
Delhi Conspiracy Case (1912), Delhi | Attempt by Rash Behari Bose and Sachindra Sanyal to assassinate Viceroy Hardinge; the conspiracy aimed at detonating a bomb near the Viceroy's procession |
German Plot, or Zimmerman Plan (1916-17), Bengal | Led by Jatindranath Mukherjee (Bagha Jatin) and Yugantar to plan an armed insurrection during World War I; the plan included importing German arms to provoke rebellion in India; activities involved Swadeshi dacoities and boat dacoities to raise funds |
Ramosi Peasant Force (1879), Maharashtra | Organised by Vasudev Balwant Phadke to instigate an armed revolt against British authorities |
Chapekar Brothers Case (1897), Maharashtra | Damodar and Balkrishna (Chapekar brothers) assassinated Plague Commissioner Rand and Lt. Ayerst as revenge for repressive plague policies |
Mitra Mela (1899), Maharashtra | Founded by V.D. Savarkar and his brother; merged with Abhinav Bharat in 1904, influenced by Mazzini's Young Italy |
Killing of District Magistrate of Nasik (1909), Maharashtra | Anant Lakshman Kanhere, a member of Abhinav Bharat, killed A.M.T. Jackson, the Collector of Nashik; resulted in Kanhere's execution and Savarkar's imprisonment |
Punjab extremism, Punjab | Lala Lajpat Rai initiated Punjabee and Anjuman-i-Mohisban-i-Watan in Lahore; revolutionaries included Lala Hardayal, Bhai Parmanand and Syed Haider Raza; shifted from grievances to extremism after British repression |
Assassination of Robert Ash (1911), Madras | Vanchi Iyer assassinated Robert Asch, the District Collector of Tirunelveli |
Bharat Swashashan Samiti, or Indian Home Rule Society (India House) (1905), London | Founded by Shyamji Krishnavarma as a revolutionary hub for Indian nationalists; key figures included Savarkar and Hardayal, who published The Indian Sociologist; inspired revolutionaries in Paris, Geneva and London |
Assassination of Curzon-Wyllie (1909), London | Madanlal Dhingra assassinated Curzon-Wyllie in London, protesting British rule |
The Ghadar Party (1913), San Francisco (North America) | Founded by Sohan Singh Bhakna, Lala Hardayal, Ramchandra, Bhawan Singh, Kartar Singh Saaraba, Barkatullah and Bhai Premchand; aimed at sparking an all-India uprising, with support from Germany during World War I (UPSC 2022); involved organising assassinations, anti-imperialist literature and procuring arms for rebellion |
Berlin Committee for Indian Independence (1915), Berlin (Germany) | Led by Virendranath Chattopadhyaya, Bhupendranath Dutta and Lala Hardayal, with German support under the Zimmerman Plan; aimed at organising rebellion and provoking an armed invasion of British India |
Missions to Baghdad, Persia, Turkey and Kabul | Led by revolutionaries Raja Mahendra Pratap Singh, Barkatullah and Obaidullah Sindhi; attempted to form an Indian government in Kabul, with support from Afghanistan's Crown Prince Amanullah |
Singapore Mutiny (15 February 1915), Singapore | Led by Jamadar Chisti Khan, Jamadar Abdul Gani and Subedar Daud Khan, involving the 5th Light Infantry and 36th Sikh Battalion; the mutiny was suppressed, resulting in executions and life sentences |
At just 18 years old, Khudiram Bose became India's youngest martyr, hanged by the British in 1908 for his involvement in the Muzaffarpur Conspiracy. British newspapers dubbed him the boy who smiled at the gallows, cementing his place in history as a symbol of youthful defiance against colonial rule. Note that the second phase of revolutionary activities, in the 1920s, is covered in the chapter on the movement of 1922-1929.
The Ghadar Revolution
The Ghadar Party was a revolutionary group headquartered in San Francisco, with branches in the Far East and along the US coast. Its weekly newspaper, The Ghadar, spearheaded its activities, asked in UPSC 2014. The party was formed in May 1913 by Lala Har Dayal and others, and aimed to fight British rule in India through armed revolt, not petitions. The Hindi Association was established, leading to the launch of The Ghadar and the founding of the Yugantar Ashram in San Francisco. Key figures were Sohan Singh Bhakna, Lala Hardayal, Kartar Singh Sarabha and Bhagwan Singh, who led extensive propaganda efforts. Kartar Singh Sarabha and Raghubar Dayal Gupta returned to India to lead the revolt.
The first issue of The Ghadar appeared in November 1913, featuring bold critiques of British rule and calls for a second revolt. The paper serialised Savarkar's The First War of Indian Independence, 1857, and referenced leaders like Tilak and Aurobindo. Ghadar di Goonj, a collection of revolutionary poems, urged unity across religions and encouraged armed rebellion. The poems were recited at gatherings, transforming Punjabi immigrants from loyalists into revolutionaries. The newspaper spread globally, reaching Indian communities in Asia, the Malay States and Trinidad, igniting revolutionary fervour. The Komagata Maru incident and the First World War further accelerated the push for immediate action.
The Komagata Maru Incident (1914) was the turning point. Sikh and Punjabi Muslim immigrants, led by Gurdit Singh, were denied entry to Canada. After a standoff, the ship returned to Calcutta, and 22 passengers died in a confrontation at Budge Budge. This event fuelled anti-British sentiment and inspired the Ghadar Movement. The ship had been chartered to challenge discriminatory laws, and activists spread revolutionary ideas in Japan. After being denied entry, the ship returned, inciting protests during the First World War. The incident led to the Ailan-e-Jung, the Proclamation of War. Leaders like Mohammed Barkatullah and Kartar Singh Sarabha rallied support, but British intelligence foiled the plan.
The Ghadar Rebellion (1915) saw activists plan revolts in Ferozepur, Lahore and Rawalpindi, but the plot was betrayed. Rashbehari Bose and Sachin Sanyal organised the uprising and led political dacoities targeting moneylenders to raise funds. Women like Gulab Kaur, known as Ghadri Gulab Kaur, Bhikaji Cama, Agnes Smedley, Kartar Kaur, Rani Bhagwan Kaur, Sushila Mohan, Bhagwati Giri and Janki Devi played crucial roles in the Ghadar Party, organising support, spreading revolutionary ideas, providing safe houses, raising funds and raising international awareness for India's independence, a fact asked in UPSC 2022. The British suppressed the movement: the Ingress into India Ordinance arrested returning revolutionaries, and under the Defence of India Rules (1915), rebellious regiments were disbanded, 45 leaders were hanged, and others were arrested and deported. Rashbehari Bose fled to Japan, Sachin Sanyal was transported for life, and pan-Islamists like the Ali brothers, Maulana Azad and Hasrat Mohani were interned. Lala Hardayal was seen as unsuited for organisational leadership, and the movement failed due to lack of mass support in Punjab, ending with executions.
First World War and the nationalist response
The First World War revitalised the Indian nationalist movement, presenting opportunities for political progress amid the challenges faced by Britain. The war saw two factions: the Allies, Britain, France, Russia, USA, Italy and Japan, and the Central Powers, Germany, Austria-Hungary and Turkey. Indian responses differed. The Moderates supported British efforts as a duty. The Extremists, led by figures like Bal Gangadhar Tilak, hoped for self-governance as a reward for loyalty. The Revolutionaries aimed for immediate independence, viewing the war as an opportunity to challenge British rule.
British repression intensified the mood: suppression of anti-colonial publications and internment of leaders such as the Ali brothers and Maulana Azad intensified anti-imperialist sentiments among the Young Party. The war also strained India financially: it depleted troop numbers, reducing white soldiers to around 15,000, while opening possibilities for support from Germany and Turkey. The war's onset re-energised nationalism, drawing on the earlier Swadeshi Movement, and various factions emerged: Ghadar revolutionaries in North America sought violent rebellion, while Home Rule Leagues led by Annie Besant and Lokmanya Tilak campaigned for Swaraj.
Two Congress sessions marked the shift. In December 1914, the Congress session in Madras openly supported the British war efforts, marking the first time a Governor attended a Congress session. In 1916, a joint session of the Congress and Muslim League in Lucknow saw Jinnah and Ambika Charan Majumdar presiding over unified discussions.
Home Rule League Movement
The primary goal of the Home Rule League movement was self-government, or home rule, for India within the British Empire, inspired by similar demands in Ireland. The most prominent leaders were Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Annie Besant, asked in UPSC 2013. Others included G.S. Khaparde, Joseph Baptista, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Motilal Nehru, Jawaharlal Nehru, Bhulabhai Desai, Chittaranjan Das, K.M. Munshi, B. Chakravarti, Saifuddin Kitchlew, Madan Mohan Malaviya, Tej Bahadur Sapru, Lala Lajpat Rai and Sir S. Subramania Iyer, who renounced his knighthood. The movement attracted moderate Congress members and some from Gokhale's Servants of India Society. However, Anglo-Indians, many Muslims and non-Brahmins in the South did not participate, due to concerns of potential Hindu-majority rule. In 1920, the All India Home Rule League changed its name to Swarajya Sabha, asked in UPSC 2018.
Two separate leagues emerged in 1916. Tilak's League was founded in April 1916, headquartered in Poona, and covered Maharashtra except Bombay, Karnataka and the Central Provinces. Besant's League was founded in September 1916 in Madras, and covered the rest of India, including Bombay City. The factors leading to the movement were disillusionment with the Morley-Minto Reforms and dissatisfaction with British governance, economic hardships due to the war, with high taxes, rising prices and poverty, the shattering of the myth of white superiority after the First World War, which exposed imperialism's vulnerabilities, and Tilak's leadership after his release in 1914, when he adopted a more conciliatory stance toward the British while advocating for Swarajya.
Tilak's Home Rule League: Tilak's release in June 1914 enabled him to assume leadership and make conciliatory gestures towards the government and Moderates. He aimed for reform in administration and urged cooperation with the British government in times of crisis. The league was established in April 1916. Tilak held his first Home Rule meeting at Belgaum, Poona was the headquarters, the first President was Joseph Baptista and the Secretary was N.C. Kelkar. Its coverage was restricted to Maharashtra excluding Bombay city, Karnataka, Central Provinces and Berar, and it had six branches. Its demands were Swarajya (self-rule), the formation of linguistic states and vernacular education. Its methods were publishing pamphlets in regional languages, engaging in village education, and emphasising linguistic states and vernacular education. Its key message was that India was mature enough for self-rule, and the focus was on linguistic equality.
Besant's Home Rule League: inspired by the Irish Home Rule Leagues, Annie Besant, an Irish theosophist in India since 1896, expanded her activities to build a movement for home rule. It was established in September 1916 in Madras, now Chennai, asked in UPSC 2013. The Secretary was George Arundale, and it covered the rest of India, including Bombay City, with 200 branches. Its objectives were similar to those demanded for the white colonies: self-government for India after the war. She campaigned through her newspapers, New India and Commonweal, and through public meetings and conferences. The organisational structure was loosely organised. Key figures were George Arundale as organising secretary, and B.W. Wadia and C.P. Ramaswamy Aiyar, who played significant roles in the league.
The government responded with repression, imposing restrictions, especially in Madras, and banning students from political activities. In June 1917, Annie Besant and her associates were arrested, leading to nationwide protests. The League movement ended by 1919, for several reasons: weak organisation, with a lack of solid structure and coordination; sectarian unrest, with religious conflicts in 1917-18 diverting attention; appeasing Moderates, since promises of reforms in Montagu's 1917 statement and Besant's release pacified moderates; extremist influence, since the Extremists' call for passive resistance discouraged moderate involvement; the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms of 1918, which divided nationalist leaders; and a leadership vacuum, since Tilak's absence and Besant's indecision left the movement leaderless. In 1920, Gandhi transformed Besant's Home Rule League into the Swarajya Sabha, aligning it with the Indian National Congress, asked in UPSC 2018. On Besant's internment, Montagu remarked that Shiva cut his wife into fifty-two pieces only to discover that he had fifty-two wives, and this is what happens to the Government of India when it interns Mrs Besant.
Lucknow Session of the Indian National Congress (1916)
The Lucknow Session (1916), presided over by Ambika Charan Majumdar, reunited Moderates and Extremists after a ten-year split. The key developments were the readmission of Extremists, with Bal Gangadhar Tilak and his followers reintegrated. The factors were diminished old controversies, recognition of political stagnation, efforts by Annie Besant and Tilak for reconciliation, and Tilak's support for administrative reforms. The passing of leaders also mattered: the deaths of Gopal Krishna Gokhale and Pherozeshah Mehta removed opposition to the Extremists.
Lucknow Pact (1916)
The Lucknow Pact (1916) was an alliance between the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League to present unified demands to the British. The key factors were Muslim dissatisfaction over the refusal to aid Turkey, the annulment of the Bengal Partition in 1911, and the denial of Aligarh University affiliation; a shift in the League's leadership, since the 1912 Calcutta Session saw a move towards self-government; the impact of the First World War, since repression fuelled anti-imperialist sentiment; and key leaders, with Lokmanya Tilak and Mohammad Ali Jinnah emphasising Hindu-Muslim unity.
Its main clauses were: self-government as the goal; one-third Muslim representation in the central government; separate electorates; the weightage system in legislative representation; a Central Legislative Council of 150 members; four-fifths of provincial legislators elected; adult franchise for direct elections; veto power on community bills; and separation of the executive and judiciary. Bal Gangadhar Tilak celebrated the historic Congress-Muslim League Lucknow Pact by stating that better two united fists than a thousand scattered fingers. His dictum captured the strategic imperative of Hindu-Muslim solidarity, positioning the Pact as a powerful counterweight to colonial divide-and-rule tactics.
Montagu's Declaration of August 1917
Montagu's Declaration marked a shift in British stance, acknowledging India's desire for self-governance and moving away from previous reform stances. It emphasised the progressive realisation of responsible government, where rulers would be accountable to elected Indian representatives rather than solely to the British.
Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms (Government of India Act, 1919)
The Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms of 1919, led by Edwin Montagu, Secretary of State for India, and Lord Chelmsford, the Viceroy, aimed to introduce constitutional changes in India, culminating in the Government of India Act of 1919, asked in UPSC 2016. The Government of India Act of 1919 clearly defined the jurisdiction of the central and provincial governments, asked in UPSC 2015.
Its key features, asked in UPSC 2015, began with the provincial government and the introduction of dyarchy. Dyarchy means the division of the subjects delegated to the provinces into two categories, asked in UPSC 2017. It introduced a dual system of governance at the provincial level. Executive authority was divided into reserved and transferred subjects: reserved subjects, such as law and order and finance, were under the control of the governor and his executive council of bureaucrats, while transferred subjects, such as education and health, were administered by ministers nominated from elected members of the legislative council, responsible to the legislature, asked in UPSC 2022. There was no responsibility of executive councillors to the legislature. The governor could take over the administration of transferred subjects in case of failure of constitutional machinery, and the Secretary of State and Governor-General could interfere in reserved subjects only.
The provincial legislature was expanded to 70% elected members, consolidated the system of communal and class electorates, and granted voting rights to women, asked in UPSC 2021. The legislature could initiate legislation but required the governor's assent, and the governor had veto power and authority to restore rejected budgets. At the centre there was no responsible government: no provision for responsible government at the all-India level, the Governor-General remained the chief executive authority, there were central and provincial lists for administration, the Viceroy's executive council included three Indian members, the Governor-General retained control over reserved subjects in provinces, and the Governor-General had powers to restore budget cuts, certify bills and issue ordinances.
The central legislature became bicameral, with the Central Legislative Assembly (145 members) and the Council of State (60 members). The Council of State had a five-year tenure, consisting only of male members. The Central Legislative Assembly had a three-year tenure. Legislators had limited control over the budget, with 75% of the budget non-votable. There was some Indian representation in important committees, including finance. And the Government of India Act, 1919 made an important change: the Secretary of State for India was henceforth to be paid out of the British exchequer.
The Congress reaction was sharp. The Congress Party, led by Hasan Imam, deemed the reforms disappointing and unsatisfactory, calling for effective self-government. Tilak called them unworthy and disappointing, a sunless dawn. Annie Besant called them unworthy of England to offer and India to accept.
Nationalist resurgence post-World War I (1919)
After the First World War, India's nationalism surged due to economic distress, unfulfilled promises and global ideological shifts. Economic hardships, with industrial downturn, unemployment and high taxes, burdened workers, peasants and returning soldiers. Political betrayal: wartime contributions led to unmet political promises, fuelling discontent. Global anti-imperial sentiment: disillusionment after the Paris Peace Conference and the Russian Revolution of 1917 inspired resistance movements. Nationalist revival: economic, political and global factors sparked India's renewed independence struggle.
Prelims practice
Consider the following statements about the Partition of Bengal: 1. It was announced by Lord Curzon in July 1905 and implemented on 16 October 1905. 2. Bengal was divided into Western Bengal (with Bihar and Orissa) and Eastern Bengal (with Assam). 3. The official justification was that Bengal's population of 78 million made administration difficult. Which of the statements given above are correct?
The Swadeshi Movement was formally proclaimed on 7 August 1905 with the passing of the Boycott Resolution. 7 August is now observed in India as:
Which of the following was a key provision of the Morley-Minto Reforms of 1909?
The Ghadar Party, founded in May 1913, was headquartered in which city?
Consider the following statements: 1. Tilak's Home Rule League was founded in April 1916 with headquarters at Poona. 2. Annie Besant's Home Rule League was founded in September 1916 at Madras. 3. The Lucknow Pact of 1916 was an alliance between the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Answer key
1. (d) - All three statements are correct: Curzon announced the partition in July 1905, it took effect on 16 October 1905, Bengal was split into Western Bengal with Bihar and Orissa and Eastern Bengal with Assam, and the official reason given was the 78 million population. 2. (b) - 7 August is observed as National Handloom Day, first observed in 2015, because the Swadeshi Movement was launched on that day in 1905. 3. (b) - The Morley-Minto Reforms introduced separate electorates for Muslims; dyarchy came with the Government of India Act, 1919, the capital shift was announced at the Delhi Durbar of 1911, and adult franchise was a clause of the Lucknow Pact. 4. (c) - The Ghadar Party was headquartered in San Francisco, with branches in the Far East and along the US coast. 5. (d) - All three statements are correct: Tilak's League in April 1916 at Poona, Besant's League in September 1916 at Madras, and the Lucknow Pact of 1916 between the Congress and the Muslim League.
Frequently asked questions
Why did Lord Curzon partition Bengal in 1905?
The official reason was administrative: Bengal's population of 78 million made it hard to govern, and Assam needed development. The real motives were to weaken Bengal, the nerve centre of Indian nationalism, by splitting it, to divide Hindus and Muslims by creating a Hindu-majority west and a Muslim-majority east, and to use divide and rule to counter the Congress and growing nationalism.
What were Swadeshi and Boycott?
Swadeshi (use of indigenous goods) and Boycott (rejection of British goods) were adopted as methods of struggle for the first time during the agitation against the Partition of Bengal. The Boycott Resolution was passed on 7 August 1905, formally proclaiming the Swadeshi Movement, and the movement spread from Bengal to Poona, Bombay, Punjab, Delhi and Madras, with new forms of struggle including samitis, festivals, national education and indigenous enterprises.
What caused the Surat Split of 1907?
The Congress split at Surat in December 1907 because the Extremists had lost faith in the capacity of the Moderates to negotiate with the British Government. The immediate disputes were over extending the Swadeshi Movement and over who should preside: the Extremists wanted Tilak or Lajpat Rai as president, while the Moderates insisted on excluding Tilak and dropping radical resolutions.
What was the significance of the Lucknow Pact of 1916?
The Lucknow Pact was an alliance between the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League to present unified demands to the British. Its clauses included self-government as the goal, one-third Muslim representation in the central government, separate electorates, weightage in legislative representation, a 150-member Central Legislative Council, four-fifths elected provincial legislators, adult franchise, veto power on community bills, and separation of the executive and judiciary. Tilak called it better two united fists than a thousand scattered fingers.
What did Montagu's Declaration of August 1917 promise?
Montagu's Declaration marked a shift in British stance, acknowledging India's desire for self-governance. It promised the progressive realisation of responsible government in India, where rulers would be accountable to elected Indian representatives rather than solely to the British. It led to the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms and the Government of India Act, 1919.
What was dyarchy under the Government of India Act, 1919?
Dyarchy divided provincial subjects into two categories. Reserved subjects, such as law and order and finance, stayed under the governor and his executive council of bureaucrats. Transferred subjects, such as education and health, were administered by ministers nominated from elected members of the legislative council, responsible to the legislature. Provincial legislatures became 70% elected, and women were granted voting rights.