Modern India — Prelims· Prelims
The Movement, 1929-1942: Civil Disobedience to the Cripps Mission
From Purna Swaraj to Cripps: Dandi, the Gandhi-Irwin Pact, Round Table Conferences, Poona Pact, the 1935 Act, Congress ministries and Bose.
The years 1929 to 1942 are the most crowded stretch of the freedom struggle, and the most rewarding for the preliminary examination. In these thirteen years the Congress moved from asking for dominion status to demanding complete independence, launched the Civil Disobedience Movement with a pinch of salt, sat down with the British at three Round Table Conferences, watched the Communal Award divide the electorate by community, saw the Government of India Act of 1935 give Indians provincial ministries, and then watched those ministries resign when India was dragged into the Second World War. The story ends with the Cripps Mission of 1942, whose failure set the stage for Quit India.
What holds this crowded period together is a single rhythm that Gandhi called struggle, truce and struggle: a mass movement, a negotiation, a pause for consolidation, and then a movement again. The Civil Disobedience Movement of 1930 to 1934 is the heart of the chapter, and its details, the Dandi March, the Gandhi-Irwin Pact, the Karachi session, the Round Table Conferences, the Poona Pact and Gandhi's Harijan campaign, are asked about year after year. The later part of the chapter, the debates inside the Congress, the working of provincial ministries from 1937 to 1939, the rise of Subhas Chandra Bose, and the responses to the war, is equally rich in facts.
This article follows the chapter in order: the run-up to Civil Disobedience, the movement itself and its regional spread, the Gandhi-Irwin Pact and the Round Table Conferences, the Communal Award and the Poona Pact, the post-movement debates, the Government of India Act of 1935, Congress rule in the provinces, Bose and the war years, and finally the August Offer, Individual Satyagraha and the Cripps Mission.
Run-up to the Civil Disobedience Movement
The Calcutta Session of 1928 approved the Nehru Report, but the younger leaders, Jawaharlal Nehru, Subhas Chandra Bose and Satyamurthy, were unhappy and demanded purna swaraj, complete independence. Senior leaders like Gandhi and Motilal Nehru favoured dominion status. They first proposed a two-year grace period for dominion status to be granted, then reduced it to one year under pressure from the younger elements. The Congress resolved to demand complete independence if dominion status was not accepted by the end of the year.
The year 1929 was a year of preparation. Gandhi travelled extensively to prepare the public for action, encouraging youth involvement, organising village work and drawing inspiration from the Bardoli agitation of 1928. A foreign cloth boycott campaign began in March 1929 in Calcutta, with the Congress Working Committee forming a Foreign Cloth Boycott Committee. Tensions ran high: the Meerut Conspiracy Case opened in March, Bhagat Singh and B.K. Dutt bombed the Central Legislative Assembly on April 8, 1929, and in May a minority Labour government took office in England, with Ramsay MacDonald as Prime Minister and Wedgewood Benn as Secretary of State for India.
The Irwin Declaration of October 31, 1929 was a joint effort by the Labour government and the Conservative Viceroy, Lord Irwin, to restore faith in British policy. It stated that dominion status was the eventual goal of India's constitutional progress, as envisioned in the 1917 Declaration, but it gave no specific timeline. Irwin also promised a Round Table Conference after the Simon Commission's report. The declaration offered no immediate or revolutionary change.
The Delhi Manifesto of November 2, 1929, issued by national leaders, demanded that the Round Table Conference act as a constituent assembly to implement dominion status, that the Congress have majority representation, and that political prisoners be given amnesty. In December 1929, Gandhi, Motilal Nehru and others met Lord Irwin, who rejected these demands, saying the conference's purpose was not to draft a constitutional scheme.
The Lahore Congress and Purna Swaraj, December 1929
The Lahore Congress of December 1929 was a turning point. Jawaharlal Nehru became Congress President with Gandhi's support, despite opposition. Nehru declared an open conspiracy for independence and advocated a socialist, republican India, rejecting kings and industrial power structures. The session took three key decisions: to boycott the Round Table Conference, to declare complete independence, Purna Swaraj, as the Congress's goal, a decision asked in UPSC 2012-2014, and to authorise civil disobedience including non-payment of taxes, urging legislators to resign.
January 26, 1930, was fixed as the first Independence (Swarajya) Day. On December 31, 1929, Nehru hoisted the tricolour at the River Ravi with slogans of Inquilab Zindabad, Long Live Revolution. There is a detail about that flag worth remembering: the flag Nehru hoisted on the banks of the Ravi on December 31, 1929, was the red-green-white tricolour with the charkha at the centre, not the saffron-white-green design adopted later.
The Independence Pledge of January 26, 1930, was recited at meetings across the country. It declared the inalienable right to freedom, said British rule had caused economic, political, cultural and spiritual ruin, blamed economic deterioration on heavy revenue demands, the destruction of village industries and British manipulation of currency and trade, and spoke of the denial of political rights and free association and the spiritual emasculation of India through compulsory disarmament. It ended with a commitment to civil disobedience and Purna Swaraj under the Congress's guidance.
Gandhi's Eleven Demands, 1930
Before launching the movement, Gandhi presented the British government with eleven demands covering political, economic and social reforms. They were meant to address national grievances, including those of the bourgeoisie and the peasants, and he set a deadline of January 31, 1930, for their acceptance. The British ignored the ultimatum, and the Civil Disobedience Movement followed.
Issue of general interest | Specific bourgeois demands | Specific peasant demands |
|---|---|---|
Implement a 50 percent reduction in expenditure on the Army and civil services. | Decrease the rupee-sterling exchange ratio to 1s 4d. | Slash land revenue by 50 percent. |
Enforce total prohibition. | Introduce textile protection. | Abolish the salt tax and the government's salt monopoly. |
Institute reforms in the Criminal Investigation Department (CID). | Reserve coastal shipping for Indians. | No further demand in this group. |
Amend the Arms Act to enable popular control over the issuance of firearms licences. | No further demand in this group. | No further demand in this group. |
Release political prisoners. | No further demand in this group. | No further demand in this group. |
Approve the Postal Reservation Bill. | No further demand in this group. | No further demand in this group. |
The context explains why the demands took this shape. The Lahore Congress of 1929 had empowered the Congress Working Committee to initiate a civil disobedience programme, particularly focusing on actions like non-payment of taxes, and had urged all members of legislatures to resign. In February 1930, at Sabarmati Ashram, the Working Committee gave Gandhi full authority to launch the movement whenever he deemed fit, trusting his judgement as an expert in leading mass struggles.
The Civil Disobedience Movement and the Dandi March
Gandhi initiated the Civil Disobedience Movement on March 12, 1930, and broke the salt laws on April 6, 1930, leading 78 followers from Sabarmati Ashram to Dandi Beach to produce salt illegally. During the movement Gandhi said, Sedition has become my religion, a remark asked in UPSC 2025. Subhas Chandra Bose likened the march to Napoleon's return from Elba. British reactions were mixed: Mr. Brailsford called it a kindergarten stage of revolution, while The Statesman sarcastically questioned its effectiveness. Despite the scepticism, the movement's moral impact pushed the number of Satyagraha volunteers past 60,000.
Gandhi chose salt as the movement's central symbol deliberately. After his ultimatum to Lord Irwin was ignored, he needed a grievance that touched everyone, and the salt tax represented British exploitation in a way every Indian could feel. Its abolition became a powerful rallying cry that led to the Salt March and the broader civil disobedience.
On March 2, 1930, Gandhi wrote to Viceroy Lord Irwin, describing British rule as a curse that had impoverished the masses through exploitation, reduced Indians to political serfdom, sapped their cultural foundations and degraded their spiritual well-being. He announced his plan to defy the salt laws starting on March 12 with his ashram colleagues, expecting arrest but encouraging mass participation in civil disobedience. The plan was to march 240 miles through Gujarat to Dandi and violate the salt law by collecting salt from the beach. Before the march, thousands gathered at the ashram, where Gandhi outlined the next steps: initiate civil disobedience of the salt law, picket foreign liquor and cloth shops, refuse to pay taxes, have lawyers abandon their practice, boycott law courts, and have government servants resign. All actions were to follow truth and non-violence to achieve swaraj, and local leaders were told to maintain discipline after Gandhi's likely arrest. The breaking of the salt law at Dandi on April 6, 1930, marked the official start of the Civil Disobedience Movement.
The defiance spread across India at once. After Nehru's arrest in April 1930, significant demonstrations erupted in Madras, Calcutta and Karachi. On May 4, 1930, Gandhi was arrested while planning to lead a raid on the Dharasana Salt Works. In response, the Congress sanctioned non-payment of revenue in ryotwari areas, a no-chowkidari-tax campaign in zamindari areas, and violation of forest laws in the Central Provinces. The colonial rulers declared the Indian National Congress illegal following the mass breaking of the salt law, a fact asked in UPSC 2019.
Regional spread of the movement
The movement looked different in every region, and the examination tests these regional details closely. In Tamil Nadu, C. Rajagopalachari led a salt march in April 1930 from Tiruchirapalli to Vedaranniyam, with picketing of foreign cloth and an anti-liquor campaign in Coimbatore, Madura and Virudhunagar; there was police repression at Choolai Mills and riots in Bodinayakanur, a detail asked in UPSC 2015. In Malabar, K. Kelappan, known for the Vaikom Satyagraha, led a salt march, and P. Krishna Pillai defended the national flag at Calicut beach. In Andhra, salt marches took place in Godavari, Krishna and Guntur, though with less mass support than the 1921-22 Non-Cooperation movement. In Orissa, Gopalbandhu Chaudhuri led effective salt satyagraha in Balasore, Cuttack and Puri.
In Assam, internal conflicts limited success, but students struck against the Cunningham Circular, which banned students' participation in politics in May 1930, and Chandraprabha Saikiani incited the breaking of forest laws in December 1930. In Bengal the Congress was split between Bose and J.M. Sengupta, there was unrest in Midnapur, Arambagh, Dacca and Kishoreganj, and Surya Sen raided armouries and declared a provisional government. In Bihar there was salt satyagraha in Champaran and Saran, symbolic salt-making in Patna under Ambika Kant Sinha, and a no-chaukidari tax agitation. In Chhotanagpur, Bonga Majhi and Somra Majhi led the Gandhian movement in Hazaribagh, and Santhals distilled liquor illegally while local zamindars gave mixed support.
In Peshawar, Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan, also known as Frontier Gandhi, founded the Khudai Khidmatgars, the Red Shirts. After Congress leaders were arrested, the Garhwal Rifles refused to fire on crowds. In Sholapur the response to Gandhi's arrest was the fiercest anywhere: textile workers struck from May 7, and residents burnt liquor shops and symbols of government authority such as railway stations, police stations, municipal buildings and law courts, and the activists established a virtual parallel government. At Dharasana, on May 21, 1930, Sarojini Naidu along with Manilal Gandhi and Imamsahib led a raid on the salt works. In Gujarat the no-tax campaign hit Anand, Borsad, Nadiad and Bardoli. In Maharashtra, Karnataka and the Central Provinces the resistance took the form of defying forest laws on grazing, timber and forest produce. In the United Provinces there were no-revenue and no-rent campaigns against loyalist zamindars, active in Agra and Rai Bareilly. In Manipur and Nagaland, Rani Gaidinliu initiated revolts and was given life imprisonment.
The movement invented its own forms of mobilisation: prabhat pheris, morning processions to spread awareness; Vanar Senas, monkey brigades, and Manjari Senas, flower brigades, that engaged youth; and pamphlets and magic lantern shows that carried information to villages. Participation cut across society. Women protested at liquor shops and foreign cloth stores. Students and youth boycotted foreign goods. Muslims engaged unevenly, but in the NWFP participation was high. Merchants and petty traders were very enthusiastic, and traders' associations and commercial bodies actively implemented the boycott, especially in Tamil Nadu and Punjab. Tribals took part in the Central Provinces, Maharashtra and Karnataka. Workers participated in Bombay, Calcutta, Madras and Sholapur. Peasants were active in the United Provinces, Bihar and Gujarat.
The government alternated between repression, lathi charges and restrictions, and concessions. In July 1930, Viceroy Lord Irwin proposed a Round Table Conference, but it failed over demands for secession rights. Written during the Civil Disobedience Movement, Rabindranath Tagore's Char Adhyay sharply criticised the participation of women in violent revolutionary politics: Tagore condemned what he saw as unfeminine involvement in assassination and armed nationalism.
The Gandhi-Irwin Pact, March 5, 1931
On January 25, 1931, Gandhi and all members of the Congress Working Committee were released unconditionally from prison. The Gandhi-Irwin Pact, also known as the Delhi Pact, was signed on March 5, 1931, and the Working Committee had empowered Gandhi to negotiate with the Viceroy. The signing of the pact in Delhi was asked in UPSC 2020.
Irwin agreed to: the immediate release of all non-violent political prisoners, a point asked in UPSC 2020; remission of unpaid fines; return of unsold lands to their original owners; lenient treatment for government servants who had resigned; the right to make salt in coastal villages for personal consumption, not for sale; permission for peaceful picketing; and withdrawal of the emergency ordinances related to the Civil Disobedience Movement, also asked in UPSC 2020.
Irwin rejected two of Gandhi's demands: a public inquiry into police excesses during the movement, and the commutation of the death sentences of Bhagat Singh and his comrades. In return, Gandhi agreed to suspend the civil disobedience movement and to participate in the Second Round Table Conference to discuss constitutional reforms, focusing on federation and Indian responsibilities.
The Karachi Congress Session, March 29, 1931
The Karachi Congress Session of March 29, 1931, was held to endorse the Gandhi-Irwin Pact, and it met six days after the execution of Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru, which sparked protests over Gandhi's failure to secure their clemency. Its key resolutions were: a tribute to the martyrs, condemning political violence but honouring their bravery and sacrifice; endorsement of the Gandhi-Irwin Pact, agreeing to a temporary halt of the Civil Disobedience Movement; reaffirmation of Purna Swaraj as the Congress's ultimate aim; a Fundamental Rights Resolution, guaranteeing free speech and free press, the right to form associations and assemble peacefully, universal adult franchise, equal legal rights irrespective of caste, creed or gender, state neutrality in religion, free and compulsory primary education, and protection of minority culture, language and script; and a National Economic Programme Resolution, supporting peasants and workers through rent and revenue reduction, exemption from rent for uneconomic landholdings, relief from agricultural debt, control over usury and exploitation, improved working conditions, union rights for workers and peasants, and state control over key industries, mines and transport.
The Round Table Conferences
The conferences were initiated by Lord Irwin and Ramsay MacDonald because the Simon Commission's report was inadequate. The First Round Table Conference was held in London from November 1930 to January 1931, opened by King George V and chaired by Ramsay MacDonald. The Congress and key leaders boycotted it. Participants included the princely states, represented by the Maharajas of Alwar, Baroda and Patiala and others; the Muslim League, led by Aga Khan III and including Jinnah and Maulana Mohammad Ali; the Hindu Mahasabha, represented by B.S. Moonje and M.R. Jayakar; Sikhs, Parsis and women, including Sardar Ujjal Singh, Phiroze Sethna and Begum Jahanara Shahnawaz; the depressed classes, represented by B.R. Ambedkar and Rettamalai Srinivasan; labour and others, including N.M. Joshi, B. Shiva Rao and K.T. Paul for Indian Christians; and the Government of India, represented by Narendra Nath Law and Bhupendra Nath Mitra. The outcome was that India was to develop into a federation, with safeguards for defence and finance and other departments transferred, but there were limited achievements and no major implementation, and civil disobedience continued.
The Second Round Table Conference ran in London from September to December 1931. Indian Liberal Party members, including Tej Bahadur Sapru and C.Y. Chintamani, had urged Gandhi to negotiate with the Viceroy, leading to the Gandhi-Irwin Pact, and now Gandhi represented the Indian National Congress, along with A. Rangaswami Iyengar and Madan Mohan Malaviya. The princely states sent the Maharajas of Alwar, Baroda and Bhopal; the Muslim League was led by Aga Khan III, Jinnah and Maulana Shaukat Ali; the Hindu Mahasabha sent M.R. Jayakar and B.S. Moonje; the Liberals sent Tej Bahadur Sapru, Srinivasa Sastri and C.Y. Chintamani; the depressed classes were represented by B.R. Ambedkar and Rettamalai Srinivasan; industry and labour by G.D. Birla, N.M. Joshi and V.V. Giri; women by Sarojini Naidu, Begum Jahanara Shahnawaz and Radhabai Subbarayan; and the Government of India by C.P. Ramaswami Iyer, Narendra Nath Law and M. Ramachandra Rao.
Three things shaped the second conference. Leadership had changed: Lord Irwin was replaced by Lord Willingdon, and a National Government had taken charge in Britain, with Conservatives demanding stronger governance in India. Gandhi's demands were a partnership based on equality between Britain and India, the immediate establishment of responsible government at the centre and in the provinces, and opposition to separate electorates for minorities, including Muslims and the depressed classes. And the conference deadlocked on minority issues: separate electorates were demanded by Muslims, the depressed classes, Anglo-Indians and Christians, who formed a Minorities' Pact, and Gandhi strongly opposed this, leading to a stalemate.
MacDonald made some announcements: two Muslim-majority provinces, the North-West Frontier Province (NWFP) and Sindh; the formation of an Indian Consultative Committee; three expert committees for finance, franchise and states; and the prospect of a British Communal Award if no Indian consensus was reached. No significant agreements were reached on India's constitutional future. Gandhi returned to India on December 28, 1931, with the fundamental demand for freedom still unmet.
The resumption of the Civil Disobedience Movement (1931-1934) followed at once. On December 29, 1931, the Congress Working Committee decided to resume the movement. During the truce period of March to December 1931, the United Provinces Congress had led efforts for rent reduction and against summary evictions; in the NWFP there was brutal repression against the Khudai Khidmatgars and peasants protesting harsh tax collection; and in Bengal the government used draconian ordinances and mass detentions in the name of terrorism, with a firing incident on political prisoners in Hijli Jail in September 1931. British officials now felt that the Delhi Pact of 1931 had boosted the political standing of the Congress and demoralised British authority, so their new strategy was to prevent Gandhi from reigniting a mass movement, to gain the confidence of pro-British elements such as government loyalists, and to prevent the national movement from consolidating in rural areas. When the Congress resumed the movement, Viceroy Willingdon refused to meet Gandhi on December 31, 1931, and on January 4, 1932, Gandhi was arrested.
The government enacted repressive ordinances, creating what was called a Civil Martial Law: outlawing the Congress at all levels, arresting leaders, activists and sympathisers, confiscating properties and occupying Gandhi's ashrams, intensifying press censorship, banning nationalist literature, and subjecting women to particularly severe repression. Despite being unprepared, the movement gained momentum, with about 80,000 satyagrahis jailed in the first four months, mostly from impoverished backgrounds. Protest methods included picketing of liquor shops and foreign cloth, non-violent demonstrations, national day celebrations, symbolic hoisting of the national flag, non-payment of taxes like the chowkidari tax, salt satyagraha and violations of forest laws, and even the establishment of a secret radio transmitter near Bombay. Uprisings occurred in princely states such as Kashmir and Alwar. In April 1934, Gandhi withdrew the Civil Disobedience Movement. Though it was subdued by the government's superior force, the people's political faith in the Congress remained intact and the spirit of freedom endured. The movement could not be sustained because Gandhi and the leaders lacked time to build momentum and the masses were inadequately prepared for a prolonged struggle.
The Third Round Table Conference was held from November 17 to December 24, 1932, without the Congress and Gandhi, who boycotted it, which limited the participation of key Indian leaders. The Indian states were represented by Akbar Hydari, Dewan of Hyderabad, Mirza Ismail, Dewan of Mysore, V.T. Krishnamachari, Dewan of Baroda, and Wajahat Hussain of Jammu and Kashmir. Other prominent representatives included B.R. Ambedkar, Aga Khan III, M.R. Jayakar, N.M. Joshi, Arcot Ramasamy Mudaliar, Tej Bahadur Sapru, Muhammad Iqbal, Sir Purshottamdas Thakurdas and Jahanara Shahnawaz. With the Congress absent, most influential Indian leaders stayed away or had little leverage. Constitutional reform and minority representation remained unresolved. The conference's recommendations were published as a White Paper in March 1933, debated in the British Parliament, and examined by a Joint Select Committee, whose report led to a draft Bill in February 1935 and the Government of India Act of July 1935. Three facts about the conferences are worth fixing in memory: Gandhi and the Congress participated only in the second Round Table Conference; Jinnah participated in the first and second but did not attend the third; and B.R. Ambedkar and Tej Bahadur Sapru were the only leaders who participated in all three conferences.
The Communal Award, 1932, and the Poona Pact
The Communal Award was announced by British Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald on August 16, 1932. It was based on the recommendations of the Indian Franchise Committee, also known as the Lothian Committee. Its provisions were: separate electorates for Muslims, Europeans, Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians, marginalised women and Marathas in Bombay, with the arrangement for the depressed classes to last for 20 years; 71 reserved seats for the depressed classes, with seats in provincial legislatures doubled; weightage for minorities, so Muslims received additional representation where they were a minority; 3 percent of seats reserved for women in all provinces except the North-West Frontier Province; double voting for the depressed classes, who could vote in both separate and general electorates; seats for labourers, landlords, traders and industrialists; and in Bombay province, 7 seats for the Marathas.
The Congress strongly opposed the Communal Award but did not reject or accept it outright, emphasising minority consent. Nationalist leaders, including Gandhi, saw the award as a divisive tactic undermining Indian unity and nationalism. Gandhi saw it as harmful both to Hinduism and to the depressed classes, since it perpetuated untouchability, and he called for elections through a common electorate. On September 20, 1932, he began an indefinite fast to demand joint electorates with increased reserved seats for the depressed classes, a fast asked in UPSC 2012.
The Poona Pact of September 24, 1932, endorsed by Ambedkar, abandoned separate electorates for the depressed classes. It raised their reserved seats from 71 to 147 in the provincial legislatures and gave them 18 percent in the Central Legislature. The government accepted the pact as an amendment to the Communal Award. Its impact on Dalits was contested: it turned the depressed classes into political tools for majoritarian caste Hindu organisations, left them leaderless by undermining authentic representation and reinforcing the Brahmanical order, and denied them a separate existence within the Hindu social order, hindering progress towards equality. After the Poona Pact, Gandhi decided to include the upliftment of Harijans in his political and social programme, a decision asked in UPSC 2025.
Gandhi's Harijan campaign
Gandhi launched an intensive campaign against untouchability to counter the British policy of divide and rule. He formed the All India Anti-Untouchability League in September 1932 while he was imprisoned, and in January 1933 he launched the weekly Harijan to raise awareness. After his release in August 1933, he moved to the Satyagraha Ashram in Wardha, keeping his vow to stay away from Sabarmati Ashram until swaraj was achieved. From November 1933 to July 1934 he travelled 20,000 kilometres, raising funds for the Harijan Sevak Sangh and advocating the eradication of untouchability. He encouraged political workers to take part in the social, economic, political and cultural upliftment of Harijans, and he undertook two fasts, on May 8 and August 16, 1934, to highlight the seriousness of untouchability. Orthodox factions disrupted his meetings and staged protests, accused him of attacking Hinduism, and allied with the government against the Congress. In August 1934 the government defeated the Temple Entry Bill, reflecting opposition from orthodox Hindu opinion.
After Civil Disobedience: the first stage of debate, 1934-1935
The Civil Disobedience Movement concluded in 1934, with Gandhi acknowledging its limitations and resigning from the Indian National Congress. A two-phase discussion then unfolded about the future strategy of the nationalists, and the first stage, in 1934-35, produced three perspectives.
The first perspective was constructive work on Gandhian lines: social reform, rural upliftment, khadi and village industries to foster self-reliance and grassroots empowerment, strengthening people's power through constructive activity as the way to mobilise millions in the next phase of mass struggle. The second was constitutional struggle and participation in elections, supported by prominent leaders such as M.A. Ansari, Asaf Ali, Bhulabhai Desai, S. Satyamurthy and B.C. Roy. It proposed contesting the Central Legislative Assembly elections of 1934 to sustain political interest and morale, without implying faith in constitutional politics, and building a political front to strengthen the Congress and prepare the masses. A strong council presence, its supporters argued, would bring prestige and confidence to the Congress.
The third was a leftist trend critical of both constructive work and council entry, led by Nehru. It argued that both diverted attention from the anti-colonial struggle, that the economic crisis and the masses' readiness to fight created a revolutionary situation, and that what was needed was continued non-constitutionalist mass action. Nehru criticised the withdrawal of the Civil Disobedience Movement and council entry as a spiritual defeat, a retreat from revolutionary ideals. He urged that the economic and class demands of peasants and workers be addressed, integrating class struggle within the Congress through kisan sabhas and trade unions, and he opposed Gandhi's struggle-truce-struggle strategy, proposing instead a struggle-victory strategy: real power could not be gained through incremental measures or constitutionalist phases. He embraced Marxism, articulating the Left position in speeches and writings, including his addresses at the Lucknow and Faizpur Congress sessions in 1936.
Nationalists feared a split in the Congress reminiscent of the Surat split, while British officials hoped for such a division. Gandhi adopted a conciliatory stance towards the proponents of council entry, agreeing to their demand for permission to enter legislatures. He acknowledged that while parliamentary politics might not directly lead to freedom, Congress members who could not engage in satyagraha or constructive work should not remain idle, and could channel their energies through council work, provided they avoided constitutionalism or self-interest. He assured leftist critics that the withdrawal of the Civil Disobedience Movement was not a submission to opportunism or a compromise with imperialism. In May 1934, the All India Congress Committee met in Patna and established a Parliamentary Board for contesting elections under the Congress banner.
In October 1934, Gandhi resigned from the Congress so that he could serve it more effectively in thought, word and deed, because of fundamental disagreements with powerful factions favouring parliamentary politics and Nehru's socialist agenda. In the November 1934 elections to the Central Legislative Assembly, the Congress secured 45 out of 75 seats reserved for Indians, demonstrating its electoral strength.
The Government of India Act, 1935
The Government of India Act, 1935, grew out of the Third Round Table Conference of 1932, held without the Congress. It proposed an All India Federation of British Indian provinces, Chief Commissioner's provinces and princely states, with voluntary participation required from the states. The federation would form only if states with significant populations agreed to join, and in the event it never materialised, because many princely states refused. In the proposed federation, residuary powers were given to the Governor-General, a point asked in UPSC 2018.
Aspect | Federal level | Provincial level |
|---|---|---|
Executive | Governor-General held pivotal authority as the Crown's representative. Reserved subjects, foreign affairs, defence, tribal and ecclesiastical matters, handled by the Governor-General with non-legislature accountable advisers. Transferred subjects administered by ministers elected by the federal legislature, accountable to it, with possible resignation if a no-confidence motion passed. Special powers: the Governor-General could act on his individual judgement regarding special responsibilities. | Provincial autonomy replaced dyarchy, granting legal and financial autonomy, and provinces could borrow on their own security. The Governor retained control as the Crown's representative and could assume full control in crises indefinitely. Special authority on minorities, civil servants, law and order, British business interests and princely states. |
Legislature | Bicameral legislature. Upper House, Council of States: 260 members, partially elected, 40 percent nominated by princely states, a permanent body with one-third retiring every third year. Lower House, Federal Assembly: 375 members, a portion indirectly elected from provinces, one-third nominated by princely states, five-year term. Legislative lists divided powers into federal, provincial and concurrent lists. Only 20 percent of the budget was votable. The Governor-General held residuary powers: to restore cuts in grants, certify bills, issue ordinances and veto, asked in UPSC 2018. No-confidence motions allowed in the Federal Assembly, not in the Council of States. Communal and class-based electorates were extended, deepening religious divisions. | Direct elections: all members directly elected. Separate electorates implemented as per the Communal Award. Women's enfranchisement: equal rights for men and women, asked in UPSC 2021. Ministers and provincial administration headed by a Premier, ministers responsible to the legislature and removable by a no-confidence vote. Legislative power over provincial and concurrent lists. 40 percent of the budget non-votable. The Governor could refuse assent to bills, promulgate ordinances and enact Governor's Acts without legislative approval. |
The second stage of debate and Congress rule in the provinces, 1937-1939
The announcement of provincial assembly elections in early 1937 sparked a second debate among nationalists over strategy, focusing on how to oppose the 1935 Act without a feasible mass movement. The Congress unanimously opposed the Act but lacked clarity on the method. It agreed to contest the elections with a comprehensive political and economic programme aimed at deepening anti-imperialist sentiment. The left faction, Nehru, Bose, the Congress socialists and the communists, opposed forming governments after the elections, fearing it would dilute opposition to the Act and divert attention from freedom and social justice. They proposed entering the councils to create deadlocks, making the Act unworkable, while integrating workers and peasants into the Congress for a socialist direction. The proponents of office acceptance argued for a short-term tactical approach in legislatures, since no mass movement was possible, and believed provincial ministries could promote constructive work despite limited powers.
Gandhi's stance evolved. Initially against office acceptance, he shifted by 1936, agreeing to experiment with forming Congress ministries. At the Lucknow session of 1936 and the Faizpur session of 1937, the Congress decided to participate in elections but postponed the decision on forming governments until after the elections.
In February 1937, the Indian National Congress formed ministries in 7 of 11 provinces under the Government of India Act of 1935, ruling until October 1939. This was a unique phase in which the Congress operated both as provincial governments and as an opposition to the central government controlled by the British. Its manifesto for the elections rejected the 1935 Act and promised the release of prisoners, removal of gender and caste-based disabilities, agrarian reforms including rent reduction and rural debt relief, and trade union rights and the right to strike.
The election figures are a favourite of the examination. Of the population, 14 percent was enfranchised, 30.1 million people including 4.25 million women. Voter turnout was 15.5 million, including 917,000 women. The Congress won 716 out of 1,161 seats contested, out of 1,585 total. It won a majority in most provinces, except Bengal, Assam, Punjab, Sindh and the NWFP, and it emerged as the largest party in Bengal, Assam and the NWFP. The provinces governed by Congress ministries were Bombay, Madras, Central Provinces, Orissa, United Provinces and Bihar, later extended to the NWFP and Assam. Gandhi urged Congress leaders to hold offices lightly, not tightly, and described the offices as crowns of thorns, to be used for advancing nationalist goals. He highlighted the opportunity to demonstrate Indians' capability for self-governance.
The work of the Congress ministries, despite structural limits, restricted powers and scarce finances, had a transformative impact. On civil liberties, they repealed the emergency powers of 1932, including the Public Safety Acts; lifted bans on organisations such as the Hindustan Seva Dal and Youth Leagues, and on books and journals; removed press restrictions and restored blacklisted newspapers; returned confiscated arms and licences and curbed police powers; released political prisoners and revoked deportation orders, including those of the Kakori Conspiracy revolutionaries; and restored confiscated land in Bombay and pensions for Civil Disobedience Movement officials. There were shortcomings: the arrests of Yusuf Meherally in Madras for an inflammatory speech and S.S. Batliwala in Madras for a seditious speech, and CID surveillance on leftists in Bombay under K.M. Munshi.
On agrarian reform, the U.P. Tenancy Act of 1939 gave full hereditary rights to tenants and limited landlord powers; forced labour, begar, and illegal levies, nazrana, were abolished; the Orissa Tenancy Bill of 1938 allowed free transfer of occupancy holdings and reduced the interest on rent arrears from 12.5 percent to 6 percent; debt relief Acts regulated moneylenders, reduced interest and provided relief in U.P. and Orissa; and Madras proposals under T. Prakasam recognised cultivators as landowners, though the reforms were not enacted because the ministry resigned. The constraints were real: limited powers under the 1935 Act, financial constraints, the need to conciliate zamindars, opposition in legislative councils and a complex agrarian structure.
On labour, the ministries took a pro-labour stance, promoting industrial peace, workers' rights and conciliation. The Industrial Disputes Act of 1938 promoted conciliation over strikes and empowered a Court of Industrial Arbitration. A Labour Enquiry Committee led by Rajendra Prasad recommended wage increases, maternity benefits and labour recruitment reforms. Even so, there were repressive measures, including Section 144 and arrests, against militant trade union protests; Nehru was discontented with these repressive actions but supported the ministries, and Gandhi opposed violent methods and reliance on colonial laws.
On social welfare, the ministries advanced Harijan welfare through laws for temple entry, public facility access, scholarships and representation; focused on primary, technical and higher education, especially for Harijans and girls; improved sanitation and public health; subsidised khadi, spinning and village industries; improved prison conditions; and set up the National Planning Committee in 1938, led by Subhas Chandra Bose, for structured development planning. Extra-parliamentary mass activity flourished: literacy campaigns, Congress police stations, panchayats and grievance committees, with effective coordination in Uttar Pradesh through village Congress committees.
The ministries resigned in October-November 1939 in protest against Lord Linlithgow's decision to involve India in the Second World War without public consent. After the resignation there was increased industrial unrest and difficulty in meeting public expectations.
Subhas Chandra Bose: Haripura, Tripuri and the Forward Bloc
In the wake of the Civil Disobedience Movement, Gandhi noted a decline in ethical conduct inside the Congress: corruption and indiscipline, leadership rivalries and petty squabbles, bogus membership inflated to manipulate internal elections, and underhanded tactics to control Congress committees. He believed the Congress should prioritise self-reform and adhere to Satyagraha before confronting colonial rule, and sensing fatigue among the masses, he argued that a movement without widespread support would be ill-timed.
Subhas Chandra Bose had built his base as President of the Bengal Provincial Congress Committee, organising youth and promoting the trade union movement. He often clashed with other Congress leaders, particularly Gandhi, over the intensity and nature of the struggle. Along with Nehru he had opposed the Motilal Nehru Report advocating dominion status, calling instead for complete independence, and he announced the establishment of the Independence League, committed to immediate and unqualified freedom.
At the Haripura Congress Session of February 1938, Bose was unanimously elected President, reflecting significant support. In his presidential address he emphasised the revolutionary potential of Congress ministries at the provincial level, stressed economic development through planning, which led to the National Planning Committee, extended moral support to those agitating against autocratic governance in the princely states, and, recognising the disturbed international situation, foresaw that the approaching war could benefit India's independence struggle.
At the Tripuri Congress Session of 1939, Bose contested for the presidency again despite Gandhi's reservations, representing progressive and radical ideologies. He won with substantial support from the Congress Socialist Party and the communists, garnering 1,580 votes against Pattabhi Sitaramayya's 1,377. Gandhi acknowledged Bose's victory but regarded Sitaramayya's defeat as his own loss. Bose's re-election highlighted the ideological polarisation inside the Congress. His critique of the working committee's compromises led to the resignation of several committee members. Despite poor health, Bose attended the Tripuri session, called for an ultimatum to the British for India's independence, and proposed a six-month ultimatum followed by a mass civil disobedience movement if it was not met. Gandhi opposed the ultimatum, citing internal divisions, communal discord and the Congress's unpreparedness. A resolution by Govind Ballabh Pant urged Bose to align with Gandhi's wishes, reflecting a preference for Gandhi's leadership. Unable to secure Gandhi's support or unify the Congress around his radical vision, Bose resigned in April 1939, paving the way for Rajendra Prasad's presidency.
On May 3, 1939, Bose formed the Forward Bloc within the Congress at Makur, Unnao, aiming to pursue his radical approach to independence. After Bose called for an all-India protest against an AICC directive, the Congress Working Committee took disciplinary action in August 1939: Bose was removed from his position as President of the Bengal Provincial Congress Committee and barred from holding any elective office in the Congress for three years. At the Tripuri session the Congress also passed a resolution expressing solidarity with China in its fight against imperialism.
The Second World War and the nationalist response
The Second World War began on September 1, 1939, when Germany attacked Poland. On September 3, 1939, the British Government of India declared India's support for the war without consulting Indian opinion. This unilateral decision caused deep discontent within the Congress, the principal voice for India's independence.
The Congress conditionally supported the Allied war effort, but on conditions: a post-war Constituent Assembly to chart the future of a free India; the immediate establishment of a truly responsible government at the Centre; and a clear statement of war aims. Viceroy Linlithgow rejected these conditions, even though the Congress argued they were crucial to secure public support for the war. The leaders differed on what to do. Gandhi preferred to avoid an immediate mass struggle, advocating unity and political work among the masses and leaving space for negotiation. Nehru called for complete independence before offering any support to the British war effort, a stance of conditional support that prioritised sovereignty. Subhas Bose and socialists like Acharya Narendra Dev and Jayaprakash Narayan saw the war as an imperialist conflict and proposed a civil disobedience movement to push for independence.
The Congress Working Committee met at Wardha in September 1939, and on October 23, 1939, it rejected Linlithgow's statement as continued imperialism. The Committee condemned fascist aggression, asserted that India could not fight for democratic freedom while being denied the same, and demanded that Britain end imperialism and establish democracy in India, urging clear war aims regarding India's post-war freedom. The British government, for its part, aimed to maintain colonial control during the war, and on October 17, 1939, Linlithgow refused to define war aims regarding India's independence, opting instead to consult the princely states and communities, which the Congress saw as a strategy to divide and weaken it. In protest, the Congress ministries resigned on October 23, 1939, signalling a serious escalation in the struggle for self-determination, a resignation asked in UPSC 2012.
At the Ramgarh Session of March 1940, under Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, the Congress reiterated complete independence as non-negotiable, rejecting dominion status and considering civil disobedience if necessary. There was consensus on the need for a movement, but disagreement on its form: Gandhi favoured continued provincial cooperation and offered moral support to the British on a non-violent basis; Nehru insisted on complete independence as a precondition for support; and Bose advocated direct action, urging India to seize Britain's vulnerability during the war. The Congress declaration was that only complete independence would be accepted, dominion status within the imperial structure was rejected, and civil disobedience would be launched when deemed necessary.
Meanwhile, in March 1940 at Lahore, the Muslim League passed its Pakistan Resolution: it advocated the creation of independent states in Muslim-majority areas, called for autonomous and sovereign constituent units, and demanded safeguards for Muslims in minority areas.
The August Offer, 1940
Hitler's astounding success and the fall of Belgium, Holland and France put England in a conciliatory mood. Both Gandhi and Nehru strongly opposed the idea of taking advantage of Britain's position. The Congress was ready to compromise, asking the British government to let it form an interim government during the war, but the government was not interested. Instead it came up with its own offer to secure India's cooperation in the war effort: the August Offer of August 1940.
Its key proposals were: dominion status, stated explicitly as a post-war objective for the first time; expansion of the Viceroy's Executive Council to include a majority of Indian members from the major political parties; a constituent assembly after the war, mainly composed of Indians, to decide India's future constitution; and protection of minority rights, with no future constitution to be adopted without the consent of minorities, a provision aimed mainly at assuring the Muslim League.
The Congress rejected the offer, viewing dominion status as outdated. Nehru famously declared it as dead as a doornail, and Gandhi believed it widened the gap between the British and nationalist aspirations. The Muslim League welcomed the offer, especially the assurance of a veto for minorities, seeing it as a step towards its demand for partition.
Individual Satyagraha, 1940-41
The British government issued ordinances restricting freedom of speech, press and assembly, and insisted on no constitutional progress until the Congress and the Muslim League reached an agreement. Gandhi initiated the Individual Satyagraha in late 1940, with a limited satyagraha strategy. Its objective was to show nationalist strength and patience, to protest against the war, and to highlight the parallels between Nazism and British colonial rule.
The satyagrahis demanded freedom to make anti-war declarations, and if they were not arrested they would march to Delhi in what was called the Delhi Chalo Movement, escalating the protest. Vinoba Bhave was the first satyagrahi, followed by Jawaharlal Nehru. After them, Gandhi chose Brahma Dutt, a young Sevagram volunteer, as the third satyagrahi. His selection underscored Gandhi's belief that moral conviction, not political prominence, defined genuine satyagraha. By May 1941, around 25,000 people had been arrested for civil disobedience.
The Cripps Mission, March 1942
The Cripps Mission, led by Stafford Cripps in March 1942, aimed to secure Indian cooperation for the British war effort against the Axis powers, driven by the imminent Japanese threat and pressure from the Allies to resolve India's political deadlock.
Its main proposals were: dominion status for an Indian Union, with free relationships within the Commonwealth and participation in the United Nations, a point asked in UPSC 2016; a constituent assembly after the war, with elected members from provincial legislatures and nominees from princely states; and British conditions under which provinces not joining the Union could establish a separate constitution, so that any province not prepared to accept the new constitution would have the right to sign a separate agreement with Britain regarding its future status, asked in UPSC 2022; and the negotiation of a treaty for the transfer of power. During the interim period the British retained control over defence and the Governor-General's powers.
The proposals departed from past offers in important ways: they placed the constitution-making process entirely in Indian hands; they acknowledged the possibility of provinces forming separate unions and allowed for exiting the Commonwealth; and they offered a preliminary blueprint for partition.
The reactions were hostile on all sides. Congress leaders Nehru and Azad rejected the proposal for not providing complete independence, criticised the representation methods for princely states and the right to secession, which threatened national unity, and opposed the lack of immediate power transfer and the retention of the Governor-General's supremacy. The Muslim League opposed the idea of a single Indian Union, criticised the procedures for the constituent assembly, and rejected the denial of Pakistan as a separate nation. Other groups, including the Liberals, Hindu Mahasabha, Sikhs and depressed classes, voiced concerns about the right to secession and the potential impact on India's unity.
The mission failed for several reasons: Cripps's rigid take it or leave it stance hampered negotiations; disputes over the Viceroy's veto powers created a deadlock; British leaders like Churchill undermined the mission's effectiveness; and questions about the execution and interpretation of the treaty hindered progress. In the aftermath, Gandhi described the proposals as a post-dated cheque on a crashing bank, and Nehru criticised the mission as a continuation of autocratic rule. The mission's failure escalated Indian frustrations and fuelled the demand for immediate action against British imperialism, culminating in the Quit India Movement.
Prelims practice
With reference to the Civil Disobedience Movement, consider the following statements: 1. Gandhi broke the salt law at Dandi on April 6, 1930. 2. He began the march with 78 followers from Sabarmati Ashram. 3. The Congress was declared illegal following the mass breaking of the salt law. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Which of the following was agreed to by the Viceroy under the Gandhi-Irwin Pact of March 5, 1931?
With reference to the Poona Pact of 1932, consider the following statements: 1. It abandoned separate electorates for the depressed classes. 2. It raised their reserved seats from 71 to 147 in provincial legislatures. 3. It was endorsed by B.R. Ambedkar on September 24, 1932. Which of the statements given above are correct?
With reference to the Government of India Act, 1935, consider the following statements: 1. It abolished dyarchy in the provinces and granted provincial autonomy. 2. Residuary powers were given to the Governor-General. 3. The proposed All India Federation materialised with the princely states joining it. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Who among the following participated in all three Round Table Conferences?
Answer key
1. (d) 2. (b) 3. (d) 4. (a) 5. (b)
Frequently asked questions
Why did Gandhi choose salt for the Civil Disobedience Movement?
Salt was a grievance that touched every Indian, rich or poor, because everyone consumed it and the British held a monopoly on it and taxed it. Breaking the salt law was a simple, non-violent act that anyone could perform, and it turned a tax into a symbol of British exploitation. Gandhi marched 240 miles from Sabarmati to Dandi with 78 followers and broke the salt law on April 6, 1930, and the act was copied across the country within days.
What did the Gandhi-Irwin Pact achieve?
Signed on March 5, 1931, the Gandhi-Irwin Pact, also called the Delhi Pact, secured the release of non-violent political prisoners, remission of unpaid fines, return of unsold lands, lenient treatment for resigned government servants, the right to make salt in coastal villages for personal consumption, permission for peaceful picketing, and withdrawal of the emergency ordinances. Irwin refused two demands: a public inquiry into police excesses and commutation of Bhagat Singh's death sentence. Gandhi agreed to suspend civil disobedience and attend the Second Round Table Conference.
What was the difference between the Communal Award and the Poona Pact?
The Communal Award of August 16, 1932, announced by Ramsay MacDonald, gave separate electorates to several communities including the depressed classes, with 71 reserved seats for them. Gandhi fasted against it from September 20, 1932. The Poona Pact of September 24, 1932, agreed by Ambedkar, abandoned separate electorates for the depressed classes and instead raised their reserved seats from 71 to 147 in provincial legislatures, with 18 percent in the Central Legislature.
Why did the Congress ministries resign in 1939?
The Congress ministries resigned in October-November 1939 because Viceroy Linlithgow involved India in the Second World War on September 3, 1939, without consulting Indian opinion. The Congress had demanded a responsible government at the Centre and a post-war constituent assembly as conditions for supporting the war, and Linlithgow rejected these conditions. The ministries had been formed in February 1937 in 7 of 11 provinces after the Congress won 716 of 1,161 seats.
Why did the Cripps Mission fail?
The Cripps Mission of March 1942 offered dominion status, a post-war constituent assembly and the right of provinces to opt out, but it gave no immediate transfer of power and kept defence and the Governor-General's powers with the British. The Congress rejected it for not providing complete independence, the Muslim League opposed a single Indian Union, and Cripps's rigid take-it-or-leave-it stance, disputes over the Viceroy's veto and Churchill's opposition killed the talks. Gandhi called the offer a post-dated cheque on a crashing bank.
Who attended the Round Table Conferences, and which one did Gandhi attend?
Gandhi and the Congress attended only the Second Round Table Conference, held in London from September to December 1931. The Congress boycotted the first conference of November 1930 to January 1931 and the third of November to December 1932. Jinnah attended the first and second but not the third, while B.R. Ambedkar and Tej Bahadur Sapru were the only leaders who attended all three conferences.