Modern India — Prelims· Prelims
Quit India to Independence, 1942-1947: INA, Cabinet Mission and Partition
Quit India, the 1943 famine, Bose and the INA, the naval mutiny, the Cabinet Mission, the Interim Government and freedom with partition.
The years 1942 to 1947 are the endgame of the freedom struggle. They begin with the greatest mass uprising the British ever faced in India, the Quit India Movement, and they end, five years later, with freedom itself, but freedom with partition. In between come a famine that killed millions, a parallel army in Subhas Chandra Bose's Indian National Army, a mutiny in the Royal Indian Navy, an election that proved the Muslim League spoke for most Muslim voters, and a series of plans, Wavell, Cabinet Mission, Mountbatten, each trying to answer the same question: how would power be transferred, and to whom?
This chapter is unusually dense with facts the preliminary examination returns to again and again: the parallel governments of Quit India, the INA trials at the Red Fort, the three upsurges of 1945-46, the Cabinet Mission's grouping of provinces, the Interim Government's ministers, the Mountbatten Plan, the Indian Independence Act and the long evolution of the two-nation theory. This article follows the chapter in order, and it keeps the dates and numbers exact, because in this period a single date, August 8, 1942, or August 16, 1946, can be the whole question.
The Quit India Movement, 1942
The Quit India Movement, also known as the August Revolution, was launched in response to the failure of the Cripps Mission, a connection asked in UPSC 2013. It called for immediate British withdrawal and began a non-violent non-cooperation movement against any possible Japanese invasion. The movement was endorsed by the Congress Working Committee on July 14, 1942, in Wardha, and it differed from previous campaigns because of its spontaneous mass participation. It was a leaderless movement, a point asked in UPSC 2011. Its slogan was Quit India, or Bharat Chhodo, a national call for liberation.
The movement was marked by unprecedented public courage and militancy, and it faced severe repression. The British, prioritising their war effort, imposed draconian measures and declared most political activities illegal, framing the movement as revolutionary and threatening to colonial rule.
Several factors were responsible. The failure of the Cripps Mission in 1942 highlighted British reluctance to make progress and fuelled demands for self-determination. Inflation and shortages created discontent over essential goods, along with rumours of British scorched-earth policies. British setbacks in Southeast Asia and Burma increased fears of a Japanese invasion. Economic insecurity showed itself in bank runs and gold hoarding. Regionally the movement was strong in eastern U.P. and Bihar, and less strong in Madras.
At the Wardha meeting of July 1942, the Congress Working Committee empowered Gandhi to lead a non-violent mass movement for British withdrawal. The Quit India Resolution was proposed by Jawaharlal Nehru and seconded by Sardar Patel, and was later ratified at the All India Congress Committee meeting at Gowalia Tank, Bombay, on August 8, 1942. Gandhi, confident that the moment was opportune, expressed impatience to proceed with the struggle even if the Congress was hesitant, but the Congress followed his lead, marking unity in the decision for mass action.
The Kurnool Circular of July 29, 1942, shows how carefully the movement was planned. The Provincial Congress Committee in Andhra issued the circular, drafted by Kala Venkat Rao and sent for Working Committee approval through Dr. Pattabhi Sitaramaiah. It outlined strategic directives for the movement, but it was seized by the police when the Kurnool Congress office was raided.
At the Gowalia Tank meeting on August 8, 1942, the Congress adopted the Quit India Resolution, a date asked in UPSC 2021. It contained four demands and directives: the immediate end to British rule in India; the commitment of a free India to resist fascism and imperialism; the formation of a provisional government after British withdrawal; and the sanction of civil disobedience against British rule. Gandhi's rallying cry, Do or Die, underlined the movement's intensity and urgency. He urged unity and non-violent resistance, and gave general instructions to different sections: Hindus and Muslims should set aside religious differences for Indian unity; government servants should stay in service and pledge allegiance to the Congress; soldiers should avoid firing on fellow Indians; students should leave their studies if they could contribute; peasants should withhold rent from pro-government zamindars; and princes should support the masses and ally with anti-government rulers.
The movement spread fast. Gandhi built momentum through civil disobedience and propaganda, but on August 9, 1942, the British pre-emptively arrested the Congress leaders, declared the Congress unlawful under the Criminal Law Amendment Act and used Rule 56 of the Defence of India Rules to ban public meetings. Aruna Asaf Ali took part in the movement and hoisted the flag at the Congress session on August 9. There were acts of defiance, hoisting flags and facing arrest, and sabotage in U.P. and Bihar, where bridges, railway tracks and telegraph lines were attacked. Students and workers struck in Ahmedabad, Bombay, Jamshedpur and Poona, with students leading strikes and circulating illegal news sheets.
With the leaders in jail, the movement went underground. Leadership coordinated activities across Bombay, Poona, Satara, Gujarat, Bihar and Delhi. Usha Mehta's radio established an underground radio station, maintained morale and evaded detection, a fact asked in UPSC 2011. Key figures of the underground included Rammanohar Lohia, Jayaprakash Narayan, Aruna Asaf Ali, Usha Mehta, Biju Patnaik, Chhotubhai Puranik, Achyut Patwardhan, Sucheta Kripalani and R.P. Goenka.
Parallel governments during Quit India
In several districts the people set up their own governments while the British administration collapsed.
Parallel government | Leader | Activities |
|---|---|---|
Ballia, August 1942 | Chittu Pandey | Secured the release of numerous Congress leaders; emerged for a week as a parallel government. |
Tamluk, December 1942 to September 1944, Midnapore | Jatiya Sarkar | Engaged in cyclone relief efforts, allocated grants to schools, provided paddy from the affluent to the needy, organised Vidyut Vahinis. |
Satara, mid-1943 to 1945, Prati Sarkar | Y.B. Chavan, Nana Patil and others | Established village libraries, created Nyayadan Mandals, conducted prohibition campaigns and arranged Gandhi marriages; known as Prati Sarkar. |
Quit India also saw Ahmedabad create a ward-wise Azad Government, led by young Congress socialists. This urban shadow administration ran tax collection, policing, intelligence units and public notices, and even punished abusive policemen, one of the most sophisticated underground civic governments in India's freedom struggle.
Who joined, and who stayed away
The movement's social spread is best seen section by section.
Section | Role in the movement |
|---|---|
Youth | Students, especially from schools and colleges, played a prominent role. |
Women | Women, particularly school and college girls, were actively engaged. Notable figures included Aruna Asaf Ali, Sucheta Kripalani and Usha Mehta. |
Workers | Strikes occurred in Ahmedabad, Bombay, Jamshedpur, Ahmednagar and Poona, but the labour class did not broadly engage. |
Peasants | Peasants from various strata were central to the movement. Attacks were directed at symbols of authority, with no anti-zamindar violence reported. |
Government officials | Lower-level government officials, including police, participated, indicating a decline in loyalty to the British government. |
Muslims | Muslims provided shelter to underground activists, with no communal clashes occurring during the movement. |
Communists | The Communist Party refrained from participation, aligning instead with the British war effort following the Nazi attack on Russia. |
Muslim League | The Muslim League opposed the movement, expressing concerns over potential minority oppression if the British withdrew. |
Hindu Mahasabha | The Hindu Mahasabha boycotted the movement, reflecting its distinct political stance. |
Princely states | Princely states exhibited a subdued response, showing limited engagement. |
The government's response was harsh. On August 9, 1942, all top Congress leaders were arrested and taken to undisclosed locations. The Congress Working Committee, the All India Congress Committee and the Provincial Congress Committees were declared unlawful under the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1908. Martial law was not implemented, but harsh measures were taken: baton charges, tear gas and gunfire were used on crowds. The death toll was estimated at around 10,000. Press freedom was suppressed, the military took control in numerous cities, and the police and secret service exercised significant authority. Defiant villages faced heavy fines and mass floggings.
Gandhi's fast of February 1943 came in response to the British government's demand that he condemn the violence; instead he focused his protest against the state's own use of force. The fast won widespread public support, leading to hartals, demonstrations and strikes at home and abroad. In solidarity, three members of the Viceroy's Executive Council resigned in protest. The fast boosted public morale, strengthened anti-British sentiment, allowed a surge in political activity, and exposed the government's authoritarian actions. On March 23, 1943, Pakistan Day was observed, marking a significant milestone in the demand for a separate state for Muslims.
The Famine of 1943
The Famine of 1943 struck hardest in southwestern Bengal, including Tamluk-Contai-Diamond Harbour, Dacca, Faridpur, Tippera and Noakhali. Approximately 1.5 to 3 million people died from starvation, malnutrition and epidemics of malaria, cholera and smallpox. The causes were man-made as much as natural: supplies were redirected to feed the British Army; rice imports from Burma and Southeast Asia were halted; and gross mismanagement and profiteering made the crisis worse. Rationing was introduced late and limited to major cities, leaving rural areas without essential support.
Individual efforts to resolve the constitutional crisis
With the Congress leaders in jail and the League pressing its demand, several individuals tried to break the deadlock. In 1944, C. Rajagopalachari, a senior Congress leader, proposed a plan later known as the Rajagopalachari Formula, aimed at bridging the Congress-League divide. The formula tacitly acknowledged the League's demand for Pakistan, and Gandhi endorsed the plan, signalling the Congress's willingness to cooperate.
Its key points were: the Muslim League would endorse the Congress's demand for independence; the League would collaborate with the Congress to establish a provisional central government; after the Second World War, a plebiscite would allow the people in Muslim-majority areas in the North-West and North-East to decide on forming a separate sovereign state; if partition was agreed, there would be a joint agreement to safeguard defence, commerce and communications between the new entities; any population transfer would be voluntary; and the formula's implementation depended on Britain transferring full powers to India.
Jinnah opposed the formula. He demanded the Congress's acceptance of the two-nation theory, proposed that only Muslims in the North-West and North-East, rather than the entire population, participate in the plebiscite, and opposed the idea of a common centre for defence and governance. Hindu leaders, particularly Vir Savarkar, also condemned the Rajagopalachari Plan, viewing it as an acceptance of the League's demand for Pakistan.
After Gandhi's release on May 5, 1944, he proposed negotiations with Jinnah based on the Rajagopalachari Formula. The Gandhi-Jinnah parleys of 1944 failed. Jinnah rejected the formula, accusing Rajagopalachari of mutilating the original Lahore Resolution. Gandhi opposed the two-nation theory and advocated Indian independence for all, while Jinnah insisted on Muslims' right to self-determination as a separate nation. The key issues were the plebiscite, which the League rejected, and a common centre for defence, commerce and communications. The talks collapsed after two weeks because of deep ideological differences.
The Desai-Liaquat Pact of 1945 aimed to establish a provisional arrangement for governance at the centre and ease tension between the Congress and the Muslim League. It proposed an equal number of representatives from the Congress and the Muslim League in the central legislature for the interim government, and 20 percent of seats reserved for minorities. No final agreement was reached, but the pact's emphasis on equal representation indicated a potential shift towards parity between the Congress and the League. Its failure underscored the persistent divide between the two parties' visions for India's future.
The Wavell Plan and the Shimla Conference, 1945
After the war in Europe ended, Churchill's Conservative government sought a solution for India's future. Lord Wavell, the Viceroy, began negotiations, and Congress leaders were released in June 1945 for talks. Britain had several interests: the Conservatives wanted to demonstrate commitment to India's constitutional resolution ahead of British elections; the Allied forces urged more Indian support for the ongoing war; and the British aimed to steer Indian efforts in a way beneficial to Britain.
The Wavell Plan proposed: an Indian majority in the Executive Council, with all members except the Governor-General and the Commander-in-Chief being Indian; equal representation for caste Hindus and Muslims; an interim government under the framework of the Government of India Act, 1935; the Governor-General's veto retained but exercised on ministerial advice; party representation through joint nominations or separate lists for council members; and further discussions on a new constitution after the war.
The Shimla Conference of June 1945 aimed to finalise the Wavell Plan, focusing on self-governance for India. The Muslim League demanded that Muslim council members be League nominees, to avoid minority influence from the Congress, and sought a two-thirds majority veto for decisions affecting Muslim interests. The Congress opposed the plan, seeing it as an effort to limit the Congress to caste Hindus, and insisted on the right to nominate members from all communities. The talks broke down when Wavell declared them a failure, inadvertently giving the Muslim League a de facto veto power in council matters. The breakdown strengthened Jinnah's influence and the League's position, as the 1945-46 elections would soon show.
Subhas Chandra Bose and the Indian National Army
Subhas Chandra Bose was born on January 23, 1897, in Cuttack, Orissa. His father, Janakinath Bose, was a prominent lawyer, and his brother, Sarat Chandra Bose, was a notable freedom fighter. An outstanding student, Bose completed his schooling in Cuttack and Calcutta and obtained a degree in philosophy from Cambridge University in 1919.
Bose joined the Indian National Congress, advocating immediate independence and opposing Gandhi's strategy of non-violence. He was elected President of the Congress in 1938 and 1939, where he promoted more radical actions. He resigned from the Congress in 1939 because of ideological conflicts and founded the Forward Bloc to advocate a more aggressive stance against British colonialism. His ideology was complete independence, anti-imperialism and a socialist, secular India. He supported armed resistance against British rule and sought alliances with Germany and Japan during the Second World War. Escaping house arrest in 1941, he led the INA and established Azad Hind Radio. He died mysteriously in a 1945 plane crash, and his slogan, Give me blood, I will give you freedom, endures as a symbol of resistance.
Two other men with confusingly similar names belong in this story, and the examination has been known to test the difference. Rash Behari Bose (1886-1945) fled to Japan in 1915 after revolutionary activities in India, founded the Indian Club in Tokyo, advocated independence and opposed Western imperialism, established the Indian Independence League in 1942, and in 1943 handed over the leadership of the INA to Subhas Chandra Bose, who became Supreme Commander. He died on January 21, 1945, after a lung collapse in February 1944. Ras Behari Ghosh (1845-1921), a different person, was born in the Bengal Presidency, educated at the University of London with a law degree, was Congress President in 1907 and 1908, advocated self-governance and constitutional reform, played a key role in the Surat Split of 1907, promoted women's education and social upliftment for lower castes, and left an intellectual legacy that shaped Congress ideology.
The Indian National Army (INA), or Azad Hind Fauj, began with Mohan Singh. During the Second World War this Indian officer refused to join British forces in Malaya and sought Japanese support to recruit Indian prisoners of war, successfully forming an army. After the fall of Singapore, Singh enlisted about 40,000 men by the end of 1942, building the INA as a response to a possible Japanese occupation of India. The INA was initially organised by Captain Mohan Singh and Rash Behari Bose in Japan in July 1941, to combat British rule with Axis support.
Subhas Chandra Bose arrived in Singapore in July 1943 and took control of the INA. He established the Provisional Government for Free India on October 21, 1943, appointing key members such as H.C. Chatterjee for Finance and Lakshmi Swaminathan for the Women's Department. The provisional government declared war on Britain and the United States, gained recognition from the Axis powers, and formed the Rani Jhansi Regiment, a dedicated women's unit. The INA headquarters moved to Rangoon in January 1944, rallying recruits with the call Chalo Delhi! The Andaman and Nicobar Islands were given to the INA by Japan on November 6, 1943, and renamed Shahid Dweep and Swaraj Dweep. On July 6, 1944, Bose addressed Gandhi as Father of the Nation and asked for his blessings.
The INA crossed the Burma border into India on March 18, 1944, advancing towards Kohima and Imphal. Colonel Malik raised the INA flag at Moirang, Manipur, on April 14, 1944, a significant moment in the struggle. The INA managed military administration at Moirang for three months until Allied forces reclaimed the territory, and the INA withdrew on July 18, 1944. The Imphal campaign, fought by an INA battalion under Shah Nawaz, faced discrimination, shortages and demoralisation. Following Japan's surrender on August 15, 1945, the INA also surrendered. Subhas Bose reportedly died in an air crash on August 18, 1945, in Taipei, Taiwan. After the war, INA prisoners of war faced court-martial on returning to India, which prompted a strong movement for their defence and raised the issue of Indian independence on the global stage.
Months before the new nation formally existed, Jinnah's election victory rallies of 1946 had already begun to visually construct Pakistan. Crowds chanted Pakistan Zindabad and waved green crescent-and-star flags, virtually identical to the future national flag.
The post-war national scenario
The government's attitude changed between June and September 1945. In June 1945 it lifted the ban on the Congress and released its leaders. The Wavell Plan had failed to resolve the constitutional deadlock. In July 1945 the Labour Party took power in Britain, with Clement Attlee as Prime Minister and Pethick Lawrence as Secretary of State for India. Elections for central and provincial assemblies were announced in August 1945, followed by the plan to convene a constituent assembly in September, aligning with the principles of the Cripps Offer.
Several factors drove the change: the global power shift, with Britain declining and the USA and USSR rising in support of India's independence; increased sympathy, since the Labour government was more sympathetic towards Indian demands; resource strain, with Britain owing 1.2 billion pounds to India by 1945; anti-imperialist sentiment, with resistance to colonial rule in Vietnam and Indonesia; fear of revolt, with the threat of agrarian uprisings and disaffection among the army and the INA; and the inevitability of elections, which made a British retreat unavoidable.
The INA trials
At the September 1945 Congress session in Bombay, a strong resolution endorsed the INA cause. Legal defence for INA prisoners was coordinated by Bhulabhai Desai, Tej Bahadur Sapru, Kailash Nath Katju, Jawaharlal Nehru and Asaf Ali. The INA Relief and Enquiry Committee provided monetary and food assistance as well as employment support, and organised fund collection.
The INA agitation became a landmark movement. It gained widespread support through press coverage, pamphlets, public meetings and editorials. INA Day on November 12, 1945, and INA Week from November 5 to 11, 1945, were celebrated across India. Participation came from social groups and political parties in cities like Delhi, Bombay and Calcutta and regions like Coorg, Balochistan and Assam. Film stars, municipal committees and expatriates contributed, and mass activities included shop closures, student meetings, kisan conferences and demands for the prisoners' release. The Congress, the Muslim League, the Communist Party, the Akalis, the Hindu Mahasabha and even loyalist strongholds supported the cause.
Public trials for INA prisoners began with the first trial at the Red Fort in November 1945, involving Prem Kumar Sehgal, Shah Nawaz Khan and Gurbaksh Singh Dhillon, symbolising unity among Indians, a trial asked in UPSC 2021. The movement questioned Britain's right to adjudicate Indian matters, framing the INA issue as an increasingly Indian-versus-British narrative. The deployment of Indian Army units to reinforce French and Dutch colonial rule in Vietnam and Indonesia heightened anti-imperialist sentiment among urban populations and the military.
The three upsurges of the winter of 1945-46
In the winter of 1945-46, heightened nationalist feeling during the INA trials led to three key confrontations with the authorities. On November 21, 1945, students protested in Calcutta over the INA trials. On February 11, 1946, there were demonstrations in Calcutta against the seven-year sentence for INA officer Rashid Ali. And on February 18, 1946, the Bombay naval strike began, initiated by Royal Indian Navy ratings.
The upsurges followed a three-stage pattern. Stage one, defiance of authority: on November 21, 1945, students, including Forward Bloc and SFI activists, protested at Dalhousie Square, faced police lathi charges, retaliated with stones, and two people died; on February 11, 1946, Muslim League students protested Rashid Ali's sentence, defying Section 144 and facing further arrests and lathi charges; and on February 18, 1946, around 1,100 RIN ratings from HMIS Talwar struck against racial discrimination and poor treatment, raising the tricolour, the crescent and the hammer-and-sickle flags. Stage two, citywide participation: Calcutta and Bombay faced near paralysis from widespread anti-British sentiment, with numerous strikes and attacks on police, shops and transport hubs. Stage three, national solidarity: students organised boycotts and hartals, sparking sympathetic strikes in military establishments across India, and the Royal Indian Air Force also joined the protests. On February 23, the ratings surrendered after assurances from Patel and Jinnah against victimisation.
The Naval Mutiny: the final straw for British colonialism
The Royal Indian Navy Mutiny of February 1946 marked a pivotal moment in India's independence struggle. Sailors protested poor conditions and racial discrimination, seeking independence. The mutiny gained widespread support from the Indian people, political leaders and military factions, including the Royal Indian Air Force. It exposed British vulnerability and attracted international pressure, particularly from the United States and the Soviet Union, urging independence. It fostered unity between the Congress and the Muslim League and highlighted the impracticality of continued British rule, accelerating the transfer of power.
The upsurges, including the RIN revolt, symbolised the looming end of British rule. The British made concessions: on December 1, 1946, trials were limited to serious offences; in January 1947 there were pardons for the initial INA prisoners; in February 1947 Indian soldiers were withdrawn from Indo-China and Indonesia; and the Cabinet Mission was finalised and a parliamentary delegation sent to India. Participation in the upsurges was limited, mainly militant groups, urban-focused, and British repression mechanisms remained largely effective.
The Congress's strategy is worth noting. From a leftist perspective there was concern over the loss of control, prioritising discipline in an independent India. The uprisings were viewed as extensions of earlier nationalist movements, and the Congress refrained from endorsing violent uprisings. It favoured negotiations, and Gandhi opposed the mutiny, urging resolution through established leadership.
Election results, 1945-1946
The elections of 1945-46 settled the question of who spoke for whom. The Congress secured 91 percent of non-Muslim votes, won 57 out of 102 seats in the Central Assembly, and achieved majorities in most provinces except Bengal, Sindh and Punjab, notably holding majorities in the NWFP and Assam. The Muslim League garnered 86.6 percent of Muslim votes and all 30 reserved seats in the Central Assembly, and secured majorities in Bengal and Sindh, solidifying its position as the dominant party among Muslims. In Punjab, a coalition led by Khizr Hayat Khan included Unionists, Congress and Akalis.
Two features of the elections matter for the examination. Voting was communal, because of separate electorates. And the franchise was limited: less than 10 percent of the population could vote for the provinces, and under 1 percent for the Central Assembly.
The Cabinet Mission, 1946
In February 1946, the Attlee government sent a high-powered Cabinet Mission to negotiate the peaceful transfer of power to India. Its members were Pethick Lawrence, chairman and Secretary of State for India, Stafford Cripps, President of the Board of Trade, and A.V. Alexander, First Lord of the Admiralty. Its goal was to set the framework for British withdrawal and future relations, emphasising the rights of minorities while preventing their veto on majority progress. The mission arrived in Delhi on March 24, 1946, and held discussions on the formation of an interim government and the constitutional framework for India.
No consensus emerged between the Congress and the Muslim League on unity or partition, so the mission proposed its own constitutional plan in May 1946. It rejected a full-fledged Pakistan for several reasons: non-Muslim populations were 38 percent in the North-West and 48 percent in the North-East; communal self-determination risked separating Hindu-majority Bengal and Sikh and Hindu-majority Punjab; and it would disrupt regional ties and create military security risks.
The plan proposed a grouping of provinces: Group A, the Hindu-majority provinces of Madras, Bombay, Central Provinces, United Provinces, Bihar and Orissa; Group B, the Muslim-majority provinces of Punjab, the North-West Frontier Province and Sindh; and Group C, the Muslim-majority provinces of Bengal and Assam. The two sides read the grouping clause differently. The Congress preferred optional grouping and feared it would pave the way for Pakistan, and opposed the removal of veto power. The Muslim League insisted on compulsory grouping as a step towards Pakistan.
The plan proposed a three-tier government at provincial, sectional and union levels. The Constituent Assembly would have 389 members: 292 from provincial assemblies, 93 from princely states and 4 from chief commissioner's provinces. The central authority would control defence, communication and external affairs, and the provinces would have autonomy over other matters. Communal issues in the central legislature would be decided by a simple majority of both communities present. Provinces could exit their groups after elections, and an interim government would form from the Constituent Assembly.
Objections came from both sides. The Congress opposed mandatory grouping of provinces like the NWFP and Assam, and disagreed with the absence of elected representatives from princely states. The Muslim League insisted on compulsory grouping as a step towards Pakistan, and expected to be invited to form the interim government after the Congress's rejection. The Muslim League accepted the plan on June 6, 1946, and the Congress accepted it on June 24, 1946. Provincial elections for the Constituent Assembly were held in July 1946. Then Nehru's statement of July 10, 1946, suggested that grouping might not be necessary because of objections from the NWFP and Assam.
On July 29, 1946, the Muslim League withdrew its acceptance and called for direct action from August 16, 1946, demanding Pakistan. Violent communal riots broke out, notably in Calcutta, Bombay, Noakhali, Bihar and Garhmukteshwar, resulting in thousands of deaths. Members of the Constituent Assembly from the provinces were elected by the Provincial Legislative Assemblies, a fact asked in UPSC 2013.
The Interim Government
A Congress-led Interim Government, headed by Jawaharlal Nehru, was inaugurated on September 2, 1946. Nehru maintained the Congress's opposition to compulsory grouping. Despite being called an interim government, it functioned mainly as an extension of the former viceroy's executive authority. In a final cabinet meeting in March 1947, Wavell overruled the ministers on key decisions, including the release of INA prisoners.
Wavell included the Muslim League in the Interim Government on October 26, 1946, despite the League's continued advocacy of direct action and its rejection of both the long-term and short-term Cabinet Mission plans. The League boycotted the first meeting of the Constituent Assembly on December 9, 1946. The Assembly focused mainly on passing the Objectives Resolution, drafted by Nehru, outlining the ideals of an independent sovereign republic.
The League adopted an obstructionist approach. It refused to attend informal cabinet meetings, contested decisions and appointments made by Congress members, and, as finance minister, Liaquat Ali Khan imposed restrictions that hindered the effective functioning of other ministries. The League aimed to promote the cause of Pakistan, viewing its participation in the government as a continuation of the civil war through alternative means. The Congress consistently pressed the British to influence the League's actions or encourage its withdrawal, and in February 1947, nine Congress cabinet members wrote to the Viceroy, demanding the resignation of League members.
Name | Ministry |
|---|---|
Jawaharlal Nehru | Vice President, Executive Council, External Affairs, Commonwealth Relations |
Vallabhbhai Patel | Home, Information and Broadcasting |
Baldev Singh | Defence |
Dr. John Mathai | Industries and Supplies |
C. Rajagopalachari | Education |
C.H. Bhabha | Work, Mines and Power |
Rajendra Prasad | Agriculture and Food |
Jagjivan Ram | Labour |
Asaf Ali | Railway |
Liaquat Ali Khan (Muslim League) | Finance |
Ibrahim Ismail Chundrigar (Muslim League) | Commerce |
Abdur Rab Nishtar (Muslim League) | Communications |
Ghazanfar Ali Khan (Muslim League) | Health |
Jogendra Nath Mandal (Muslim League) | Law |
Wavell's Breakdown Plan
In May 1946, Lord Wavell proposed the Breakdown Plan to the Cabinet Mission, aiming for a compromise between repression and scuttle. Its key aspects were: the withdrawal of British forces, with the British Army and officials retreating to the Muslim provinces in the North-West and North-East; and the transfer of power, with authority over the rest of India handed to the Congress. The plan acknowledged that suppressing a Congress-led rebellion was increasingly untenable. Some British officials desired a partition that would create a division similar to Northern Ireland within Pakistan.
Independence with partition
From an imperialist standpoint, Britain viewed independence as fulfilling its mission to facilitate Indian self-government, and partition as a consequence of the Hindu-Muslim divide and the failure to achieve consensus on the transfer of power. A more radical view suggests that independence resulted from the mass actions of 1946-47, in which Communists emerged as leaders, but bourgeois leaders in the Congress, fearing a revolutionary upsurge, opted for negotiation with the imperialists, leading to a transfer of power that compromised national unity. The Hindu Mahasabha explored establishing a separate Hindu province in West Bengal.
Attlee's Statement of February 20, 1947, announced that British rule in India would end by June 30, 1948, regardless of a constitutional agreement. Power could be transferred either to a central authority or directly to provincial governments, especially in Muslim-majority areas. British responsibilities over the princely states would also end without a successor government, hinting at partition, similar to the Cripps Offer. The decision aimed to resolve the political deadlock, demonstrate British sincerity and acknowledge Britain's declining control, as noted by Lord Wavell. The announcement triggered violence in Punjab, led to the collapse of Khizr Hayat Khan's coalition, and pushed the Congress to accept partition, while the Muslim League saw it as validation of its goals.
On March 10, 1947, Jawaharlal Nehru suggested that implementing the Cabinet Mission plan was the best solution, with the partition of Punjab and Bengal as the only viable alternative. By April 1947, Congress President J.B. Kripalani expressed a willingness to accept Pakistan to avoid conflict, contingent on a fair partition of Bengal and Punjab.
Mountbatten served as Viceroy from February 12, 1947, to August 15, 1947, and showed greater decisiveness than his predecessors, benefiting from a delegation of powers for on-the-spot decisions. He aimed to explore options for unity or division until October 1947, but he quickly recognised the futility of the Cabinet Mission Plan, with Jinnah adamant about establishing a sovereign state.
The Mountbatten Plan of June 3, 1947, meant freedom with partition. One major innovation, actually suggested by V.P. Menon, was the immediate transfer of power on the basis of dominion status, with a right of secession, thus avoiding the need to wait for an agreement in the constituent assembly on a new political structure. Its main points were: the legislative assemblies of Punjab and Bengal would vote on partition into separate Hindu and Muslim groups, and a simple majority in either group would result in partition; if partition happened, two dominions, India and Pakistan, and two constituent assemblies would be created; Sindh would make its own decision; referendums in the NWFP and the Sylhet district of Bengal would determine their fate.
The Congress's concessions were that the demand for a unified India was given up while other demands were secured: princely states would not be independent but would join either India or Pakistan; independence for Bengal was ruled out; the accession of Hyderabad to Pakistan was ruled out, with Mountbatten supporting the Congress on this; freedom was set for August 15, 1947; and a boundary commission would be set up if partition was to be effected.
The decision to set the transfer of power for August 15, 1947, was motivated by Britain's desire to secure the Congress's acceptance of dominion status and to evade responsibility for escalating communal tensions. The reactions were anguished. Gandhi expressed deep distress at the partition and urged people to resist accepting the plan, emphasising that it contradicted the unity fostered during the freedom movement. Maulana Abul Kalam Azad vehemently opposed the Congress leadership's acceptance of the plan, viewing it as a capitulation to power. The concessions to the Muslim League were that the demand for Pakistan was conceded, and the Congress's position on unity was considered to minimise the size of Pakistan.
The Congress's reasons for accepting dominion status and partition were: continuity in administration, allowing continuity within the bureaucracy and military, crucial for governance; the British perspective, for Britain granting dominion status was a way to maintain India's connection to the Commonwealth, given India's economic strength and strategic importance; failure to integrate Muslims, having struggled to unite Muslim masses for a unified nation; urgent power transfer, needed to prevent communal violence and a failed Interim Government; prevention of Balkanisation, since partition avoided fragmentation of the princely states; and exhaustion and failure to control riots, with the Congress fatigued and unable to manage riots, accepting partition as a solution.
The Mountbatten Plan was executed quickly. The legislative assemblies in Bengal and Punjab opted for partition, so East Bengal and West Punjab became part of Pakistan, while West Bengal and East Punjab remained with India. A referendum in Sylhet led to its incorporation into East Bengal. Two boundary commissions were established to delineate the new borders, culminating in the publication of the Radcliffe Line on August 17, 1947.
Before the final Mountbatten Plan, a proposal known as the Dickie Bird Plan suggested that provinces should become independent successor states instead of forming an Indian Union or two dominions. Nehru rejected this plan, warning it could lead to the Balkanisation of India and provoke conflict, and it was cancelled.
The Sir Cyril Radcliffe Commission was established in July 1947, after the decision to partition India, to demarcate the boundaries between the newly formed dominions, particularly in Punjab and Bengal, a commission asked in UPSC 2014. A delay in announcing the Boundary Commission Award, prepared by Radcliffe and ready by August 12, 1947, was intentional: Mountbatten chose to reveal it after August 15, thus absolving the British of responsibility for subsequent disturbances.
The Indian Independence Act, 1947
On July 18, 1947, the Indian Independence Act, based on the Mountbatten Plan, received royal assent after being passed by the British Parliament on July 5, 1947. Its key provisions were: the creation of two independent dominions, India and Pakistan, effective from August 15, 1947; each dominion would have a Governor-General responsible for implementing the Act; the constituent assemblies would exercise legislative powers, resulting in the dissolution of the existing Central Legislative Assembly and Council of States; and the governments would operate under the Government of India Act, 1935, until new constitutions were adopted. Consequently, Pakistan gained independence on August 14, while India celebrated its freedom on August 15, 1947. M.A. Jinnah became the first Governor-General of Pakistan, and Lord Mountbatten continued as the Governor-General of India at India's request.
Integration of the states
The State People's Movement of 1946-47 surged for political rights and representation in the Constituent Assembly. Nehru chaired the All India State People's Conference in Udaipur in 1945 and in Gwalior in April 1947, stating that non-participating states would be treated as hostile. Phase one, the Instrument of Accession: by August 15, 1947, all states except Kashmir, Hyderabad and Junagadh had signed, granting central control over defence, external affairs and communication. Phase two, integration: complex integration into Kathiawar, Vindhya, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh. Hyderabad, Mysore and Travancore-Cochin retained their boundaries. Privy purses were offered, and some princes became Governors or Rajpramukhs.
Evolution of the two-nation theory
The idea that Hindus and Muslims were two nations did not appear overnight. Its evolution can be followed year by year, and the examination has tested this timeline more than once.
Year | Development |
|---|---|
1887 | Dufferin and Colvin's anti-Congress strategies included leveraging figures like Syed Ahmed Khan to discourage Muslim participation in the Congress, despite some Muslims joining. |
1906 | The Shimla Delegation, led by Agha Khan, demanded separate electorates for Muslims, leading to the formation of the All India Muslim League to support British loyalty. |
1909 | The Morley-Minto Reforms granted separate electorates, strengthening communal identities. |
1915 | The first All India Hindu Mahasabha session marked organised Hindu political mobilisation. |
1912-1924 | The Muslim League experienced internal shifts, increasingly adopting a communal perspective. |
1916 | The Congress's acceptance of separate electorates for Muslims signified political validation of the Muslim League. |
1920-22 | Muslim involvement in movements like the Khilafat continued, but communal elements persisted in their political outlook. |
1920s | Communal riots escalated, with reactions from both communities, exemplified by the Arya Samajists' Shuddhi movement and Muslim counteractions. |
1928 | The Nehru Report faced backlash from Muslim leaders, leading to Jinnah's fourteen points, which intensified communal demands. |
1930-34 | Limited Muslim participation in the Civil Disobedience Movement highlighted divides within nationalist movements. |
1932 | The Communal Award legitimised separate communal demands for Muslims. |
Post-1937 | The Muslim League embraced extreme communalism, influenced by figures like Rahmat Ali and Iqbal, asserting Muslims as a separate nation. |
March 24, 1940 | The Lahore Resolution called for independent states for Muslims in contiguous regions, crystallising the two-nation theory. |
World War II | The British government gave the League significant power, allowing it to press for a separate Pakistan, which was ultimately achieved in 1947. |
Prelims practice
With reference to the Quit India Movement, consider the following statements: 1. It was launched in response to the failure of the Cripps Mission. 2. The Quit India Resolution was adopted by the AICC at Gowalia Tank, Bombay, on August 8, 1942. 3. Gandhi's rallying cry was Do or Die. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Which of the following pairs of parallel governments during the Quit India Movement is correctly matched?
With reference to the INA trials, consider the following statements: 1. The first trial was held at the Red Fort in November 1945. 2. The accused included Prem Kumar Sehgal, Shah Nawaz Khan and Gurbaksh Singh Dhillon. 3. The legal defence was coordinated by Bhulabhai Desai, Tej Bahadur Sapru and others. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Under the Cabinet Mission Plan of 1946, which of the following provinces were placed in Group B?
With reference to the Indian Independence Act, 1947, consider the following statements: 1. It received royal assent on July 18, 1947. 2. It created two independent dominions effective from August 15, 1947. 3. M.A. Jinnah became the first Governor-General of Pakistan. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Answer key
1. (d) 2. (a) 3. (d) 4. (c) 5. (d)
Frequently asked questions
Why is the Quit India Movement called a leaderless movement?
The Quit India Resolution was adopted on August 8, 1942, and on the morning of August 9 the British arrested all the top Congress leaders, including Gandhi, and declared the Congress unlawful. With the leadership in jail, the movement ran on spontaneous mass participation and on an underground network led by figures such as Jayaprakash Narayan, Aruna Asaf Ali, Rammanohar Lohia and Usha Mehta, who ran an underground radio station. Parallel governments also appeared at Ballia, Tamluk and Satara.
What was the significance of the INA trials?
The first INA trial at the Red Fort in November 1945 tried Prem Kumar Sehgal, Shah Nawaz Khan and Gurbaksh Singh Dhillon, and the Congress, the Muslim League, the Communist Party and even loyalist groups supported the accused. The defence was led by Bhulabhai Desai, Tej Bahadur Sapru, Kailash Nath Katju, Jawaharlal Nehru and Asaf Ali. The agitation around the trials, with INA Day on November 12 and INA Week from November 5 to 11, 1945, turned the INA issue into a national cause and led directly to the three upsurges of 1945-46.
What were the three upsurges of 1945-46?
The three upsurges were the Calcutta protest of November 21, 1945, over the INA trials; the Calcutta demonstrations of February 11, 1946, against the seven-year sentence for INA officer Rashid Ali; and the Bombay naval strike of February 18, 1946, when about 1,100 Royal Indian Navy ratings of HMIS Talwar struck against racial discrimination and poor treatment. The naval mutiny spread to other cities and the Royal Indian Air Force, and the ratings surrendered on February 23 after assurances from Patel and Jinnah.
What did the Cabinet Mission propose, and why did it fail?
The Cabinet Mission of 1946, with Pethick Lawrence, Stafford Cripps and A.V. Alexander, rejected a full-fledged Pakistan and proposed a three-tier federation with provinces grouped into A (Hindu-majority), B (Punjab, NWFP, Sindh) and C (Bengal, Assam), and a 389-member Constituent Assembly. The Congress accepted it on June 24, 1946, and the League on June 6, but the League withdrew on July 29 after Nehru's statement of July 10 questioned compulsory grouping, and called for Direct Action from August 16, 1946.
What were the main points of the Mountbatten Plan?
The Mountbatten Plan of June 3, 1947, provided for the partition of Punjab and Bengal by votes in their legislative assemblies, the creation of two dominions, India and Pakistan, with two constituent assemblies, a decision by Sindh on its own, and referendums in the NWFP and Sylhet. Princely states were to join either India or Pakistan, not remain independent, and freedom was fixed for August 15, 1947, with a boundary commission to draw the borders.
When did India and Pakistan become independent?
The Indian Independence Act received royal assent on July 18, 1947, after being passed by the British Parliament on July 5, 1947. It created two independent dominions effective from August 15, 1947. Pakistan celebrated independence on August 14, 1947, and India on August 15, 1947. M.A. Jinnah became the first Governor-General of Pakistan, and Lord Mountbatten continued as Governor-General of India.