Skip to content

Friday, 20 November 2026 · New Delhi

Modern India — Prelims· Prelims

Constitutional, Administrative and Judicial Developments in British India

From the Regulating Act of 1773 to the integration of the princely states in 1947: how the British built India's civil service, police, courts and local government, and how famine and foreign policy were run.

By Pinky20 November 2026Updated 20 November 202634 min readintermediate
Constitutional, Administrative and Judicial Developments in British India | UPSC

When the East India Company was founded in 1600, it was a trading body with no ambition to rule. By 1765, when it received the Diwani of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa from Shah Alam II, it had become a government. The story of the next two centuries is the story of how that trading company, and then the British Crown after it, built a constitutional and administrative machine to hold India down, and how that machine, almost by accident, gave India the civil service, the courts, the police and the local bodies that the republic would later inherit.

Prelims keeps returning to this chapter because it is a mine of dates, acts and committees. The Regulating Act of 1773 and the Government of India Act of 1935, the Aitchison Committee and the Butler Committee, the Doctrine of Lapse and the Famine Code of 1883 are all asked again and again, usually as statement-based questions where one wrong year spoils the answer. This article follows the chapter in order: the constitutional developments first, then the civil services, the police and the military, the judiciary, the administrative reorganisation after 1857, local government, foreign policy, famine policy and finally the policy towards the princely states.

Two periods frame everything. Company Rule (1773-1858) set up the governance framework under the East India Company, and Crown Rule (1858-1947) brought direct British control and the major administrative changes that followed the Revolt of 1857. Every act, committee and reform below belongs to one of these two periods, and knowing which is half the battle in the exam.

Constitutional developments in British India

The constitutional story begins with the Company changing from trader to ruler. The Regulating Act of 1773 was the first parliamentary attempt to control the Company, and it was followed by the Act of Settlement of 1781 and Pitt's India Act of 1784, which created the dual system of Company and Crown control that lasted until 1858. The Charter Acts of 1813, 1833 and 1853 renewed the Company's charter each time on tighter terms, and the Government of India Act of 1858 ended Company rule altogether. The Indian Councils Acts of 1861, 1892 and 1909 then opened the legislature a crack at a time, the Government of India Act of 1919 brought dyarchy, the Government of India Act of 1935 brought provincial autonomy, and the Indian Independence Act of 1947 ended Crown rule.

Year

Landmark

1600

East India Company founded; arrival of British as traders in India

1765

Grant of Diwani rights to the Company by Shah Alam II

1773

Regulating Act; beginning of Company rule (1773-1858)

1781

Act of Settlement

1784

Pitt's India Act

1813, 1833, 1853

Charter Acts

1857

Revolt of 1857; end of Company rule

1858

Government of India Act; beginning of Crown rule

1861

Indian Councils Act

1892

Indian Councils Act

1909

Indian Councils Act

1919

Government of India Act

1935

Government of India Act

1947

Indian Independence Act; end of Crown rule (1858-1947)

The point to hold on to is the purpose behind all of it. These changes were made to further the British imperial agenda, not to serve Indians, yet in the process they modernised India's political framework and created institutions that outlived the Raj.

Evolution of civil services in India

The civil service began as a commercial workforce. The term civil service was first recorded in 1757, and it distinguished Company employees in commerce from those in the military. What started as a body to serve the Company's trade slowly became a comprehensive administrative machinery overseeing governance across India. In 1772, Lord Warren Hastings created the role of District Collector to manage local administration, and that office, the collector at the head of a district, remains the spine of Indian administration today.

Lord Cornwallis (Governor-General, 1786-1793) is recognised as the founding father of modern Indian civil services. He organised the services and laid the foundation for modern administrative practices, raised civil servants' salaries, enforced rules against private trade, and prohibited the acceptance of presents and bribes. His Cornwallis Code of Civil Services emphasised promotions based on seniority and set standards of conduct, a first step towards structured governance. Lord Wellesley (Governor-General, 1798-1805) then built the training system, establishing Fort William College in 1800 for training civil service recruits and founding East India College in 1806 after the Court of Directors disapproved of Fort William College, where recruits underwent a two-year training programme.

Recruitment itself changed only slowly. Civil servants were first selected by the Company's directors and trained at Haileybury College in London before being posted to India. In 1854, a shift towards a merit-based service was proposed through Lord Macaulay's report to the British Parliament's Select Committee, which advocated replacing the patronage system with a permanent Civil Service and introducing competitive examinations. The Civil Service Commission was established in London in 1854, and the first competitive examinations were held in 1855.

The Charter Act of 1853 ended the Company's patronage system and introduced recruitment through open competition, and for the first time local representation was introduced in the Indian legislature. But the door it opened was narrow. The examination was conducted exclusively in London with no centres in India, the syllabus favoured British candidates with its focus on Greek, Latin and English, and the maximum age limit was reduced from 23 to eventually 19 years. Prejudice against Indians and intense competition among European candidates for lucrative posts made entry harder still.

The Indian Civil Service Act of 1861 formally created the Indian Civil Services (ICS), with rigorous recruitment through competitive examinations held in England based on classical studies, and the maximum age limit was progressively lowered further. In 1863, Satyendra Nath Tagore became the first Indian to pass the ICS examination. The Act otherwise limited Indian representation in the ICS and kept British authority over governance firmly in place.

A different experiment followed. The Statutory Civil Service, introduced by Lord Lytton in 1878-1879, allocated one-sixth of covenanted posts to be filled by Indians from affluent families, with appointments requiring nomination by local governments and approval from the Viceroy and the Secretary of State. The system was unsuccessful and was eventually abolished.

Committees and reforms that reshaped the services

The Aitchison Committee, formed in 1886 by Lord Dufferin following the founding of the Indian National Congress in 1885, recommended the abolition of the terms covenanted and uncovenanted, the reorganisation of the civil service into three categories, the Imperial Indian Civil Service (examination in England), the Provincial Civil Service (examination in India) and the Subordinate Civil Service (examination in India), and raising the age limit for candidates to 23. It also supported conducting civil service examinations simultaneously in India and Britain, but this was never implemented.

The Montford Reforms of 1919 recommended simultaneous examinations in both India and England and suggested that one-third of recruitments be made in India, to be increased annually by 1.5 percent. The Lee Commission of 1924 went further: the Secretary of State would continue recruiting for the ICS and related services such as the Irrigation branch and the Indian Forest Service, provincial governments would handle recruitment in areas like education, and there would be 50:50 parity between Europeans and Indians in direct recruitment over 15 years. Its key recommendations were the establishment of a Public Service Commission, simultaneous civil service examinations in India and England, and a one-third recruitment quota for Indians, progressively increasing.

The Government of India Act of 1935 recommended the establishment of Federal and Provincial Public Service Commissions, and recruitment to other All India Services like the Indian Agricultural Service, Veterinary Service, Educational Service, Service of Engineers and Forest was provincialised. But Indianisation did not translate into real power: positions of authority remained largely in British hands, and the Indianisation of the civil service did not give Indians actual political power.

Police and military system in British India

Before the British, there was no formal police system. Both the Mughal rulers and the native states governed autocratically, and law and order rested on faujdars, who maintained order, amils, who collected revenue but also dealt with rebellious activities, and the kotwal, who kept order in urban areas. During the Dual Government of 1765-1772, zamindars were entrusted with maintaining law through their staff, including thanedars, but many neglected their duties and were accused of colluding with dacoits.

The Company built its police step by step. In 1770 it abolished the faujdar and amil institutions, then in 1774 Warren Hastings reinstated faujdars to combat dacoits and disorder, supported by zamindars, and in 1775 faujdar thanas were established in major towns, supplemented by smaller police stations. The Regulation of 1791 defined the powers of Police Superintendents, and Cornwallis increased police salaries, offered rewards for capturing criminals, and modernised the thana system, with a daroga (an Indian) and a Superintendent of Police (SP) overseeing each district, relieving zamindars of policing duties. Zamindars lost policing authority and were not accountable for robberies unless complicit, English magistrates gained control over district police, and districts were divided into 400-square-mile areas, each managed by a Police Superintendent and constables. In 1808, Mayo appointed an SP for each division, assisted by spies called goyendas, who sometimes engaged in criminal activities themselves. In 1814, the Court of Directors abolished darogas and their subordinates in all Company territories except Bengal, and Governor-General Bentinck (1828-35) abolished the SP role, assigning the collector and magistrate to lead the police force, which led to poor organisation and an increased burden on collectors.

The recommendations that followed led to the Indian Police Act of 1861, which established a civil constabulary while retaining the village watchman system, and created a hierarchy with an Inspector-General for provinces, Deputy Inspector-Generals for ranges and SPs for districts. The Andrew Frazer Commission (1902-03) proposed direct recruitment of senior police officials, training schools for constables and officers, increasing police strength in the provinces, allowing police to conduct village inquiries, enhancing salaries and creating a Criminal Intelligence Department at the Centre. The police did succeed in reducing crimes like dacoity and thuggee, but they often had an unsympathetic relationship with the public and were used to suppress the national movement.

A fact worth remembering is that India's Police Act of 1861 was built on the Royal Irish Constabulary, a militarised, paramilitary force designed for colonial suppression rather than community policing. The objective was clear: contain dissent, prevent rebellion, and create a police force accountable upward to the Raj, not outward to citizens.

Military structure and governance

The military was crucial to British governance. Before 1857 it consisted of the Queen's Army, troops of the Crown's military, and the Company's troops, local European and native regiments led by British officers. After the Battle of Plassey, Robert Clive changed recruitment practices, favouring martial races from wheat-producing regions over those from rice-growing areas. Warren Hastings emphasised recruiting high-caste warriors from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, and focused on Rajputs and Brahman zamindaris. The 1820s saw a decline in cavalry use, with British soldiers adopting muskets and matchlocks, and a uniform military culture emerged through European-style training and discipline.

The Revolt of 1857 forced a reorganisation to prevent uprisings and guard against imperialist threats. The changes stressed European dominance over Indian branches, fixed ratios of Europeans to Indians in the armies, the exclusion of Indians from high-tech roles until World War II, and limited officer roles for Indians until 1918, with a proposal for a 50 percent Indianised officer cadre by 1952. The divide-and-rule principle and the martial race ideology shaped recruitment: Sikhs, Gurkhas and Pathans were favoured, other groups were labelled non-martial, and caste and communal companies were created to balance representation and prevent nationalist sentiment among troops. Restrictions on newspapers and publications limited soldiers' contact with the general populace.

The British Army's presence in India began during the First Carnatic War (1747), leading to a permanent military establishment. The General Services Enlistment Act of 1856 mandated that sepoys serve anywhere, clashing with their caste beliefs. After the revolt, the Royal Peel Commission of 1859 recommended a British to Indian soldier ratio of 1:2.5 and the merging of East India Company forces with Crown troops.

Behind the formal administration sat a quieter instrument of control. British Residents in the princely states maintained classified Political Diaries, intelligence dossiers tracking rulers' habits, factional rivalries, finances, correspondence and court politics. These diaries became a shadow-governance mechanism, enabling indirect control without formal annexation.

Judicial developments in British India

Pre-colonial India had no structured court system. Legal matters were resolved by caste elders, village panchayats or zamindars for Hindus, and by qazis, religious authorities in provincial capitals and larger towns, for Muslims, while kings and emperors were considered the ultimate sources of justice, which made justice delivery arbitrary. The transition to a common law system began with the establishment of Mayor's Courts by the East India Company in 1726, founded in Madras, Bombay and Calcutta. The Charter of 1662 had authorised the Company to execute judicial powers in India, and the Charter of 1726 allowed the establishment of Mayor's Courts but did not clarify the Company's jurisdiction over natives. As the Company shifted from a trading entity to a ruling authority, it began replacing the existing Mughal legal system with new judicial elements.

Under Warren Hastings (1772-1785), District Diwani Adalats were established for civil disputes, presided over by the Collector, applying Hindu laws for Hindus and Muslim laws for Muslims, with appeals to the Sadar Diwani Adalat. District Faujdari Adalats were created for criminal disputes, managed by Indian officers, applying Muslim law, with serious decisions needing approval from the Sadar Nizamat Adalat. The Supreme Court was established in Calcutta under the Regulating Act of 1773, with jurisdiction over all British subjects, though conflicts with other courts persisted. Hastings also established civil and criminal courts in the districts, the Mofussil Nizamat Adalat, and made efforts to codify Hindu and Muslim laws through translations.

Under Cornwallis (1786-1793), the separation of powers was introduced with a clear division of judicial authority. The District Faujdari Courts were abolished and replaced with Circuit Courts presided over by European judges in Calcutta, Dacca, Murshidabad and Patna, serving as appellate courts for civil and criminal cases. The Sadar Nizamat Adalat was relocated to Calcutta under the Governor-General and members of the Supreme Council, assisted by the chief qazi and chief mufti. The District Diwani Adalat was renamed the District, City or Zila Court and overseen by a district judge, limiting the collector's role to revenue administration. The hierarchy that emerged was the Munsiff's Court managed by Indian officers, the Registrar's Court presided over by a European judge, the District Court under the district judge, four Circuit Courts as provincial courts of appeal, the Sadar Diwani Adalat in Calcutta, and the King-in-Council for appeals of 5,000 pounds and above. Cornwallis also centralised authority by empowering Collectors as judges of Diwani Adalats, with expanded magisterial powers to try certain criminal cases.

William Bentinck (1828-1833) abolished the Circuit Courts because of their backlog and transferred their functions to collectors, established Sadar Diwani and Nizamat Adalats in Allahabad for local justice, replaced Persian with English in the higher courts while allowing vernacular languages, and formed the Law Commission of 1833 under Thomas Macaulay, which led to the Indian Penal Code (1860), the Civil Procedure Code (1859) and the Criminal Procedure Code (1861). His social reforms included the abolition of sati and infanticide and the suppression of thugs, and he promoted press freedom, education and Indian participation in governance.

Between 1833 and 1935 the legal system kept being reworked. In 1860, Europeans in India lost their special privileges except in criminal cases, so that all individuals were subject to the same laws, although no Indian judge could preside over cases involving Europeans. In 1865, the Supreme Court and the Sadar Adalats were merged to create High Courts in Calcutta, Bombay and Madras, streamlining the judicial process. And the Government of India Act of 1935 established a Federal Court, which came into being in 1937, to resolve disputes between governments and hear limited appeals from High Courts.

Administrative reorganisation after 1857

The reforms after 1857 were driven by British imperial goals, not Indian welfare. Indians were included in the administration so the rulers could better understand local customs, and efforts were made to bridge the gap between rulers and subjects to reduce discontent and prevent uprisings. But the reforms were implemented in phases focused on securing British dominance and safeguarding trade interests against global powers like the United States and Japan, and viceroys like Lytton, Dufferin, Lansdowne, Elgin and Curzon implemented reactionary policies to strengthen British control.

The Act for the Better Government of India (1858) transferred governance from the East India Company to the British Crown after the Revolt of 1857. A new Secretary of State for India, part of the British Cabinet, was established with assistance from a 15-member Council, Parliament retained ultimate control, and the dual system begun by Pitt's India Act of 1784 ended. The Governor-General was now titled Viceroy, representing the Crown directly in India, and he was supported by an Executive Council of department heads, though his authority gradually shrank under the Secretary of State's centralised power. This shift increased the influence of British industrialists, merchants and bankers over Indian policy and made administration increasingly reactionary. The Government of India Act of 1858 introduced the Viceroy title for the Governor-General as the symbol of direct imperial governance.

The Indian Councils Act of 1861 expanded the Executive Council with a fifth member and allowed the Viceroy to appoint 6 to 12 members for legislative functions. But the Legislative Council was weak: limited discussion on financial matters, no control over the budget, inability to scrutinise executive actions, dependence on the Viceroy's approval for bills, and limited, elitist representation. The Viceroy could also issue emergency ordinances. Two symbolic acts followed: the Royal Titles Act of 1876 empowered the British sovereign to adopt the title Empress of India (Kaiser-i-Hind), and the Proclamation of 1877, declared during the Delhi Durbar, further symbolised direct British Crown control.

Provincial administration and legislative decentralisation

The Indian Councils Act of 1861 restored legislative powers to Madras and Bombay, which had been stripped in 1833. Bombay, Madras and Calcutta presidencies held more rights than other provinces and were governed by governors and executive councils appointed by the Crown, while other provinces were led by lieutenant governors and chief commissioners appointed by the Governor-General.

Decentralisation then moved in stages. The Charter Act of 1833 had centralised legislative power, restricting Bombay and Madras to proposing laws to the Governor-General-in-Council. The Indian Councils Act of 1861 reversed that centralisation, granting Bombay and Madras legislative powers, though some actions still required prior approval from the Governor-General, and Legislative Councils were later established in other provinces. The Indian Councils Acts of 1892 and 1909 expanded the legislative powers of provincial councils. The Government of India Act of 1919 introduced dyarchy, splitting responsibilities between elected Indian ministers and British officials in provincial governments, and the Government of India Act of 1935 established provincial autonomy, granting even more authority to Indian leaders at the provincial level.

Financial decentralisation followed a similar arc. Lord Mayo (1870) introduced fixed funds for specific services like police and education, marking the start of provincial financial responsibility. Lord Lytton and Lord Ripon continued devolving financial responsibilities to the provinces. In 1877, provinces gained control over excise, land revenue, law and justice expenses. In 1882, the Divided Heads system replaced fixed grants, splitting income from sources like excise, stamps and forests between the central and provincial governments, lasting until the Government of India Act of 1919. Lord Lytton's reforms transferred spending responsibilities such as land revenue, law and excise to provincial governments, and provinces received a fixed share of income from stamps, excise and income tax, with revenue divided into central, provincial and shared sources. Despite all this, the central government retained ultimate authority and oversaw the provinces closely, and both central and provincial governments were subordinated to the Secretary of State and the British Government.

Local government in British India

Local government grew out of overcentralisation and financial strain. Britain needed to delegate responsibilities to local bodies, European-style civic amenities were adopted, and nationalist demands for better public services pushed the British to respond. Involving Indians in governance and using local taxes helped address growing political pressure. Local governance structures were established through Acts passed between 1864 and 1868 for Bengal, Madras, Punjab and the North-Western Provinces (modern-day Uttar Pradesh). Lord Mayo's reforms of 1870 emphasised self-government and strengthened municipal institutions by introducing provincial finance reforms, and municipal Acts for Madras, Bombay, Bengal and other provinces followed in the early 1870s, though the elective principle remained limited. Lord Ripon's reforms of 1881-82 expanded local self-government and promoted the principle of elections, and new Acts in 1883-84 enabled private citizens to chair municipalities, a role previously reserved for executive officers.

Mayo's Resolution of 1870 built on the legislative devolution begun by the Indian Councils Act of 1861, which empowered provincial governments to levy local taxes for budgetary balance. Departments including education, sanitation, medical relief and public works were transferred to provincial control, marking the beginning of financial decentralisation in India. Mayo emphasised local interest and management so that funds in areas like education, healthcare and infrastructure would be handled efficiently, and provincial governments in Bengal, Madras, the North-Western Provinces and Punjab enacted municipal acts to carry out the changes.

Ripon's Resolution of 1882 made Ripon known as the father of local self-government in India. He wanted local bodies developed for administrative improvement and political education, and he sought to empower urban and rural local bodies with specific duties and access to revenue sources. His resolution proposed that non-official members form the majority in local bodies, with chairpersons ideally being non-officials, that official interference be minimised to oversight, with officials approving only critical actions such as loan approvals, new taxes and significant projects, and that elections be introduced if officials considered them feasible.

The Royal Commission on Decentralisation (1908) recommended strengthening local bodies like District Boards, Sub-District Boards and Village Panchayats, but identified a critical lack of financial resources as a major hindrance. It emphasised giving village panchayats more powers, including judicial jurisdiction in minor cases and expenditure on local works, schools and fuel reserves, recommended creating sub-district boards in each taluka or tehsil with distinct responsibilities and independent revenue sources, urged the removal of restrictions on taxation powers for local bodies and the end of regular grants-in-aid from provincial governments, and suggested that municipalities take on responsibility for primary education and relieve the government of certain financial burdens.

The Government of India Resolution of 1915 responded to the Commission's recommendations, but implementation was limited and local bodies' conditions were largely unchanged. The Resolution of May 1918, prompted by the August Declaration of 1917 announcing a shift towards responsible government, proposed representative local bodies with real authority. Under dyarchy (1919), the Montford Report of 1918 advocated increased popular control over local bodies and reduced external oversight, the Government of India Act of 1919 made local self-government a transferred subject while finance stayed reserved, and provinces were to create local bodies suited to their needs. The Simon Commission Report of 1930 found limited village panchayat progress with improvements in some provinces, and recommended more provincial control and local tax imposition. The Government of India Act of 1935 strengthened local self-governance through provincial autonomy, with popular ministries controlling funds, the abolition of tax separation, and new laws granting authority to local bodies. After 1935, though, financial constraints continued, new restrictions limited local taxes, and provincial governments ignored liberal taxation powers. The constitutional story closes in the republic: Article 40 directs the establishment of village panchayats, and the 73rd and 74th Amendments strengthened local governance.

British foreign policy in India

British foreign policy in India was shaped by imperial objectives and led to numerous conflicts with neighbouring countries. The British aimed to establish geographical frontiers for internal cohesion, which produced border clashes, particularly with Afghanistan during the First Anglo-Afghan War (1839-42) and the Second Anglo-Afghan War (1878-80), as part of creating a buffer state against Russian expansionism. Protecting and expanding British commercial interests often clashed with other European powers, notably Russia and France. The Great Game, the geopolitical struggle between the British Empire and the Russian Empire in the 19th century, primarily over control of Central Asia with India as a key area of interest, illustrates this rivalry, intensified by events like the Crimean War (1853-56), which threatened British interests in India.

The cost was borne by Indians. The Second Anglo-Afghan War saw over 16,000 British casualties and severely disrupted local economies. Meanwhile the East India Company had evolved from a trading entity into a political power, especially in Bengal, and after the Battle of Plassey in 1757 it controlled Bengal, deposing Nawabs and exercising significant influence over local governance. The Company's policies led to substantial wealth extraction: R.C. Dutt estimated that from 1757 to 1765 the Company extracted around 6 million pounds from Bengal, nearly four times its total annual revenue, impoverishing India while fuelling the British economy.

Development of famine policy

A famine is marked by widespread food scarcity caused by war, natural disasters, crop failures, poverty, economic disasters or government policies, and it often leads to malnutrition, starvation, epidemics and increased mortality. Under the Company's rule from 1769 to 1857, the East India Company oversaw twelve famines and four severe scarcities. The worst was 1769-70 in Bengal, when one-third of the population died, no relief measures were taken, and Company servants profited from the rice trade. In 1781-82 in Madras and 1784 in North India specific details were not recorded. In 1792 in Madras relief works were initiated. In 1803 in the North-Western Provinces and Oudh, the state granted revenue remissions, loans and advances to landowners and offered a grain bounty in certain cities. In 1833 in Guntur, 200,000 people died in a population of 500,000. In 1837 in Upper India there were public works projects but limited aid to vulnerable groups. There was no general famine relief system: provincial governments attempted various relief measures such as grain storage and penalties on hoarding.

Under Crown administration from 1858 to 1947 the pattern continued. In 1860-61 in the Delhi-Agra region, the first official inquiry into famine was led by Colonel Baird Smith, but no effective relief principles were established. In 1866, the Orissa Famine, despite warnings the government failed to prepare, adhering to free trade principles, resulting in approximately 1.3 million deaths. In 1868 in Northern and Central India, relief efforts were inadequate compared to the widespread suffering, leading to significant mortality. In 1876-78 in North India, over 58 million people were affected with around 5 million deaths, and the government's minimal response highlighted its negligence. In 1896-97, nearly every province was affected, with around 34 million impacted, and relief operations were insufficient, especially in the Central Provinces. In 1899-1900, about 28 million were affected and delayed relief overwhelmed available systems. Between 1901 and 1908 multiple famines occurred, notably severe in 1906-07 and 1907-08. The Bengal Famine of 1942-43, caused by crop failures, wartime conditions, disrupted rice imports and trade restrictions, resulted in massive loss of life.

The institutional response came late. The Famine Commission of 1880, headed by Sir Richard Strachey, noted that prior to the late 18th century the British had no obligation or means to provide relief during famines. The Famine Code of 1883 set precautionary measures during normal times and instructions for imminent relief campaigns, allowed for the designation of districts as scarcity or famine areas, outlined the duties of officials once a famine was declared, including recommendations for land revenue suspensions, provided for cost-sharing between provincial and central governments for famine relief, and established migration facilities for cattle during droughts.

British policy towards princely states

The princely states, or Indian states, comprised 562 princely entities covering an area of 712,508 square miles. They ranged from minuscule states like Bilbari, with a population of only 27, to larger entities like Hyderabad, comparable in size to Italy and home to 14 million people. The British adopted a two-fold policy towards them, aiming for their subordination to British authority while using them as protective entities for the empire, a policy referred to as the policy of subordinate union.

Between 1757 and 1857, the East India Company reinforced its power using a dual strategy of military conquest and diplomatic tactics. The key approaches were Warren Hastings' Ring-Fence policy, Lord Wellesley's Subsidiary Alliance and Lord Dalhousie's Doctrine of Lapse. Before 1740 the British followed a policy of initial isolationism: their early presence focused on commerce and cooperation with native rulers, and they were reluctant to pursue aggressive policies to avoid conflict as foreigners in India. That changed between 1740 and 1765, when the Anglo-French rivalry, the capture of Arcot in 1751 and the Battle of Plassey in 1757 marked the Company's rise to political power, and after the Battle of Buxar in 1764 the Company gained the Diwani of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa through the Treaty of Allahabad (1765).

The Policy of Ring Fence (1765-1813) was devised by Warren Hastings to create buffer zones protecting British territories from external threats like the Marathas, Mysore and Afghan invaders, promising military aid to buffer states like Hyderabad and Mysore in exchange for payment to British forces. Lord Wellesley then expanded the Ring Fence policy with the Subsidiary Alliance (1798-1805) to curb French resurgence and maintain British dominance. States brought under the Subsidiary Alliance included Hyderabad (1798-1800), Mysore (1799), Tanjore (1799), the Nawab of Awadh (1801), and the Maratha Confederation, including Peshwa Baji Rao II (1802), Bhonsle (1803), the Raja of Berar (1803), Scindia (1804), the Gaekwads and Bharatpur (1818), Jodhpur (1818), Jaipur (1818) and the Holkars (1818) last. Under its provisions, Indian rulers had to allow British forces within their territories and maintain them, host a British Resident, and get British approval for foreign relations. The system solidified British control and subjugated regional states, including Hyderabad, Awadh and the Marathas.

The Doctrine of Lapse (1848-1856) was applied aggressively by Lord Dalhousie to annex states without a direct heir. Its premise was that states without a biological heir or the adoption of a son could be annexed by Britain, claiming support from Hindu law. Annexed states included Satara (1848), Jhansi, Nagpur (1854), Sambhalpur, Baghat and others. On misgovernance grounds, Nawab Wajid Ali Shah was overthrown and Awadh was annexed in 1856.

The Policy of Subordinate Isolation (1813-1857) followed. The Charter Act of 1833 ended the Company's commercial functions but retained political control over Indian states. Indian states had to accept British supremacy, or paramountcy, while retaining some internal sovereignty. Annexation was encouraged: in 1834, the Board of Directors supported annexations, leading to the acquisition of Satara and Nagpur under Dalhousie.

After the Revolt, the Policy of Subordinate Union (1857-1935) took over. The British Crown took direct control, shifting from annexation to the punishment and deposition of rulers. Mughal rule ended in 1858, and succession required Crown approval. States had to cooperate with British authorities, and the Crown retained the right to intervene in both internal and external matters for the welfare of the state and British interests. Modern communication, railways, telegraphs and postal systems, made increased British intervention and control easier.

Lord Curzon before 1905 expanded the interpretation of historical treaties, positioning princes as public servants expected to collaborate with the Governor-General in administering Indian governance. His approach included a policy of patronage and intrusive surveillance, and he wanted a direct relationship in which the states would become uniformly dependent on British rule, in contrast with previous feudal or federal relations, aiming to create a consistent and integrated Indian political system. After 1905, in response to rising political unrest and revolutionary sentiment, a policy of cordial cooperation was implemented. The Montford Reforms of 1921 led to the creation of a Chamber of Princes (Narendra Mandal) as an advisory body. Indian states were categorised into three groups: 109 states directly represented, 127 states represented through representatives, and feudal holdings or jagirs recognised as such.

The Butler Committee (1927), set up to improve the relationship between the Government of India and the Indian States, is a question UPSC asked in 2017. Its recommendations were that the supremacy of paramountcy must remain supreme and adapt to the evolving needs of the states, and that states should not be handed over to an Indian government responsible to an Indian legislature without the consent of the states.

The Policy of Equal Federation (1935-1947) came with the Government of India Act of 1935, which proposed a Federal Assembly with 125 out of 375 seats for princes and a Council of States with 104 out of 160 seats. It required ratification by states representing over half the population, but this scheme never materialised, and following the outbreak of World War II in September 1939, the proposal was abandoned.

Integration came in 1946-47. The State People's Movement demanded political rights and Constituent Assembly representation. Nehru led sessions in Udaipur (1945) and Gwalior (April 1947), warning states that opposed accession. Vallabhbhai Patel took charge of the States Department in July 1947, overseeing integration in two phases. In Phase I, the Instrument of Accession, by August 15, 1947 all states except Kashmir, Hyderabad and Junagarh signed the Instrument of Accession, recognising central authority over Defence, External Affairs and Communication. In Phase II, the integration of states, states were integrated into provinces or formed new units: the Kathiawar Union, Vindhya, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh. Princes received privy purses and were appointed as Governors and Rajpramukhs.

The negotiations that failed are worth knowing by name: the Cripps Mission (1942), the Wavell Plan (1945), the Cabinet Mission (1946) and Attlee's statement of February 1947 all failed to resolve the deadlock, leaving states exploring sovereignty. The three holdouts were settled one by one. In Junagarh, the Muslim Nawab favoured Pakistan, but a plebiscite favoured India. Hyderabad desired sovereignty, signed a Standstill Agreement in November 1947, and after violence led to Indian intervention in 1948, it acceded in November 1949. In Kashmir, the Hindu prince delayed accession, signed the Instrument of Accession in October 1947 after a Pakistani invasion, Indian troops defended the state, and Article 370 granted it special status.

The practical work of absorbing the states was enormous. 216 smaller states were merged into provinces, including 39 states in Orissa and Chhattisgarh, 61 states were centrally administered, and new unions were formed: Kathiawar, Matsya, Patiala and East Punjab States Union, Rajasthan and Travancore-Cochin, the last of which later became Kerala. The Seventh Amendment of 1956 abolished Part-B states and integrated them into a uniform structure.

Prelims practice

Q1Prelims practice

Who was the first Indian to pass the Indian Civil Service examination?

Q2Prelims practice

Consider the following statements about the Aitchison Committee of 1886: 1. It was established by Lord Dufferin after the founding of the Indian National Congress. 2. It recommended the abolition of the terms covenanted and uncovenanted. 3. Its recommendation of simultaneous examinations in India and Britain was implemented. Which of the statements given above are correct?

Q3Prelims practice

The Indian Police Act of 1861 is correctly described by which of the following?

Q4Prelims practice

The Butler Committee of 1927 was set up to examine which of the following?

Q5Prelims practice

Consider the following statements: 1. The Famine Commission of 1880 was headed by Sir Richard Strachey. 2. The Famine Code of 1883 allowed districts to be designated as scarcity or famine areas. 3. The Orissa Famine of 1866 caused about 1.3 million deaths. Which of the statements given above are correct?

Answer key

1. (b) 2. (a) 3. (b) 4. (b) 5. (d)

Frequently asked questions

Who is called the founding father of modern Indian civil services?

Lord Cornwallis, Governor-General from 1786 to 1793. He organised the civil services, raised salaries, enforced rules against private trade and the acceptance of presents and bribes, and issued the Cornwallis Code, which emphasised promotion by seniority and set standards of conduct for civil servants.

What was the Statutory Civil Service of 1878-79?

It was introduced by Lord Lytton and allocated one-sixth of covenanted posts to Indians from affluent families, with appointments needing nomination by local governments and approval from the Viceroy and the Secretary of State. The system proved unsuccessful and was eventually abolished.

When were the High Courts established in India?

In 1865, when the Supreme Court and the Sadar Adalats were merged to create High Courts in Calcutta, Bombay and Madras. The Supreme Court itself had been established in Calcutta much earlier, under the Regulating Act of 1773.

What was the Doctrine of Lapse?

It was Lord Dalhousie's policy of 1848-1856 under which a princely state without a biological heir, or without the adoption of a son, could be annexed by Britain. Satara was annexed in 1848 and Nagpur in 1854, while Awadh was annexed in 1856 on grounds of misgovernance after Nawab Wajid Ali Shah was overthrown.

What was the Chamber of Princes?

The Chamber of Princes, or Narendra Mandal, was created in 1921 under the Montford Reforms as an advisory body for the princely states. States were categorised into three groups: 109 directly represented, 127 represented through representatives, and feudal holdings or jagirs.

What did the Butler Committee of 1927 recommend?

The Butler Committee, set up to improve the relationship between the Government of India and the Indian states, recommended that the supremacy of paramountcy must remain supreme and adapt to the evolving needs of the states, and that states should not be handed over to an Indian government responsible to an Indian legislature without the consent of the states. UPSC asked about this committee in 2017.

upsc-prelimsModern HistoryConstitutional DevelopmentsCivil ServicesPolice ReformsPrincely States

Related articles

Continue your preparation with more on this topic.

Modern History in Trends: Recent Exam Facts 2024-2025 | UPSCModern India — PrelimsModern History in Trends: Recent Exam Facts 2024-2025What CDS, CAPF, BPSC and UPPCS actually asked about modern India in 2024 and 2025, fact by fact with the exam and year on each one: Charter Acts, 1857, Round Table Conferences, parties, press and the road to independence.Governor-Generals and Viceroys of British India | UPSCModern India — PrelimsGovernor-Generals and Viceroys of British IndiaEvery Governor-General and Viceroy from Clive to Mountbatten, with tenures, wars and reforms, plus the foreign friends of the freedom struggle: Annie Besant, Andrews, Mirabehn, Sister Nivedita and more.Indian Personalities of the Freedom Struggle | UPSCModern India — PrelimsIndian Personalities of the Freedom StruggleRoy, Tagore, Tilak, Phule, Ambedkar, Nehru, Naoroji, Patel, Periyar, Azad, Vivekananda and more, plus the women leaders of 1857, the fifteen women who framed the Constitution, and the personalities of Swadeshi, Non-Cooperation, Civil Disobedience and Quit India.Evolution of Education and Press in Colonial India | UPSCModern India — PrelimsEvolution of Education and Press in Colonial IndiaFrom the Charter Act of 1813 to Wood's Despatch, the Sadler Commission and the Sargent Plan, and from Hickey's Bengal Gazette to the Vernacular Press Act: how education and the press were built, controlled and turned into tools of the national movement.British Policies and Their Economic Impacts | UPSCModern India — PrelimsBritish Policies and Their Economic ImpactsHow British rule drained India's wealth, broke its handicrafts and rewrote its land system: the three phases of exploitation, the drain of wealth, land revenue settlements and the committees that ran the Raj.People's Resistance Against the British | UPSCModern India — PrelimsPeople's Resistance Against the BritishFrom the Sanyasi Revolt of 1763 to the Telangana insurrection of 1946: civil rebellions, tribal revolts, military mutinies, peasant movements and the rise of the working class against British rule.